Of course, once I go down that rabbit hole I have to start patting government contractors on the back for circulating money at the expense of taxpayers. I guess the overall question is: is an artificial economy better than a stagnant economy?
He went so far as to suggest that agency problems in
the delegated investment process, specifically the inability
of career-minded fund managers to stay away from bubbles
regardless of any personal reservations, make an important
contribution to innovation. Steven Fazzari (whose work on
inequality this blog has featured before) described research
showing that R&D expenditures of young firms are constrained
by external finance and increase in bubblicious periods.
Ramana Nanda investigated whether investments made at the
top of bubbles were poor, and found that they were not. They
were just riskier. Firms funded by venture capitalists in
heat were unusually likely to crash and burn, sure, but they
were also unusually likely to succeed spectacularly.
1. http://www.interfluidity.com/v2/5066.htmlPeople played the heck out of Farmville, and I'm certain Zynga has had other successes. It's not like they don't produce some value.
EDIT: I guess to elaborate, what I need to hear from you is evidence of deception before I can accept your claim.
In my opinion Zynga didn't need the cash that the IPO offered to re-invest in their business, it was simply a vehicle to cash out investors.
So, evidence of deception? All I can provide is that as a solid investment opportunity Zynga was anything but, as a well sold story that wall street spun, perhaps so.
Don't forget that this viral growth was achieved through unethical methods. [1] In the fall of 2009 a number of articles appeared calling out the unethical behavior which changed the climate and forced Facebook to alter its policy:
Scamville: The Social Gaming Ecosystem Of Hell [2]
Scamville: Zynga Says 1/3 Of Revenue Comes From Lead Gen And Other Offers [3]
Zynga CEO Mark Pincus: "I Did Every Horrible Thing In The Book Just To Get Revenues" [4]
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zynga#Scam_ads[2] http://techcrunch.com/2009/10/31/scamville-the-social-gaming...
[3] http://techcrunch.com/2009/11/02/scamville-zynga-says-13-of-...
[4] http://techcrunch.com/2009/11/06/zynga-scamville-mark-pinkus...
The smart folks have realized that going public is where the money is at. And you don't need to produce value to go public, you just need to get Wall St. to be your evangelist and convince ignorant investors that your company's shares will be worth more than their IPO price at some uncertain point in the future. Does this sound familiar to anyone else? Yes indeed, its the same old "Penny Stock" scheme that common folk fall for (see: Wolf of Wall St.). This well oiled money printing machine evolved out of the Dot Com boom, wherein it existed in a functional but crude state. It has since been perfected.
So, what is a start-up? Is it a vehicle to solve a problem? Or a marketing-based ponzi scheme designed to pump and dump stock after stock in IPOs, making the "investors" unfathomably wealthy at the expense of common folk through zero-sum wealth transfers?
This is the real question Sam Altman and PG have to answer. Because it seems to me for every Elon Musk, there are hundreds of Mark Pincus clones, just itching to ride the next wave all the way to the bank.