Maybe much less potent in killing instantly (ie in combat use), but what about long-term low-dosage exposure?
> possibly going up the food chain (does that happen?)
Bio-accumulation in general is very real thing, and imho the most worrisome aspect of this situation.
As for the hydrolysis product of mustard gas, thiodiethanol, it's not very toxic. The MSDS claims acute toxicity in rates starts around 6.5g/kg. So a human would need to consume ~500g in order to see toxicity.
Also, thiodiethanol is quite reactive itself. It would likely be oxidized to the carboxylic acid. Wouldn't surprise me if bacteria could metabolize it.
This abstract suggests that bacteria are utilizing the thiodiglycol that the mustard gas ends up releasing into the water:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/19481794
This one suggests that the thiodiglycol is still harmful:
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/16393936
But that it isn't nearly as harmful as the mustard gas.
http://usnews.nbcnews.com/_news/2012/09/28/14141378-world-wa...
thirty plus million pounds of assorted weaponary
Also: Belgium waters have been a dumping ground for (mustard?)gas.
If all is spread evenly. But as you said, currents and other factors might cause troubles in a few areas. Maybe is better to disturb them, or break them open and have as much control it much as they can over this issue.
We're mainly talking mustard gas. Germany did use nerve gases tabun, sarin, and soman [1]. But nerve gases degrade after a period of a few weeks to a few years. I'm not sure what they degrade into, admittedly, and I doubt it's nice.
Mustard gas lasts longer, but is also much less potent. Military use is about 1 tonne for 2.6 square kilometres [2]. So if it were just leaking into the open sea -- even one as small as the Baltic -- it wouldn't be an issue. The problem is really if something re-concentrates it -- currents, or location, or possibly going up the food chain (does that happen?)
So my initial feeling is it's not quite as catastrophic as it sounds. Would love to hear from somebody better-informed, though.
1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Germany_and_weapons_of_mass_de...
2 - http://www.iraqwatch.org/perspectives/rangwala-powell-020503...