News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Sunday April 20, 2014 @06:18PM (#7618688)
They're also featured heavily in T.A. Heppinheimer's Colonies in Space, now available in full text online:

http://www.nss.org/settlement/ColoniesInSpace/index.html

That featured strongly in my childhood imagination. I'm no longer the technotopian I was at the time, but it's a powerful vision. Much of what it (and O'Neil) promoted should have been done by now were it possible.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by abecedarius on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:58AM (#7620105)
O'Neill clearly wanted it to happen and let it bias his estimates. But what bothered me the most was that even if you did follow their strategy of build-powersats-in-place-out-of-extraterrestrial-materials, you could do it cheaper with workers in tin cans (and lots of automation and teleoperation) instead of livable colonies. The argument against this wasn't too convincing, but I was a teenager and figured "Hey, a lot can happen in a few decades." A lot more than actually did so far, sigh.

I still think large-scale work could have been done in space, and wasn't more for societal than technical reasons.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:59AM (#7620440)
I suspect the powersat evolved as a mission justification: so, we can conceive of human-habitable structures in space, but why would we do that. From Heppenheimer's book, it seems that the colony concept emerged first, then the powersat concept.

Once you've arrived at "orbiting solar power stations built from lunar regolith", questioning your premises and realizing that the colonies really don't make all that much sense. But then again, pragmatism and overt missions never really ruled space anyway -- see Apollo and the Shuttle.

As for the technical reasons, to paraphrase Douglas Adams: Space is expensive. Really expensive. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly expensive it is.

The ISS is the most expensive single structure ever constructed, and among the most expensive single projects ever undertaken -- and that for a habitation for six people. Total cost is somewhere north of $100 billion (how far north isn't clear, the budget's spread among multiple agencies and nations).

Given that, and absent tremendous gains in efficiency and automation, the cost of solar power satellites let alone O'Neil space colonies would be in the tens of trillions of dollars, minimum. That's on the scale of the entire US GDP, if not more.

As for your observation "a lot more than actually did [happen]": Colonies in Space is one of my benchmarks for rates of technological change that didn't happen. I'd anticipated that that could well be my future, but a decade and a half past when it was supposed to be a reality, it remains science fiction. It's given me a good sense of the sorts of change which are possible and likely, and those which aren't. And no, not all progress is subject to Kurzweil's Law of Accelerating Returns.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by marktangotango on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:49AM (#7621005)
>> It's given me a good sense of the sorts of change which are possible and likely, and those which aren't. And no, not all progress is subject to Kurzweil's Law of Accelerating Returns.

Indeed, we may be in Vinge's "Age of failed dreams".

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:51PM (#7624506)
Interesting Vinge reference. I wasn't familiar with that.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:33AM (#7620933)
It hasn't been done already because launch is still crazy expensive. Now we've got SpaceX making solid progress towards a fully reusable launch vehicle, which should drop costs by an order of magnitude, and Planetary Resources working on near-earth asteroid mining.