News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by FD3SA on Sunday April 20, 2014 @03:56PM (#7618262)
Many of these pictures are based on designs described in one of my favorite books of all time, The High Frontier, by Gerard K. O'Neil.

In it, O'Neil, a Princeton physicist and founder of the Space Studies Institute, goes on to describe in great technical detail the feasibility of building artificial space habitats of varying sizes. I heartily recommend it to anyone even remotely interested in space. The ideas from this book have been implemented in countless fictional universes[1], so you may find that you've seen them before.

It all started here in this excellent book.

1. http://gundam.wikia.com/wiki/Space_colony_(UC)

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by abecedarius on Sunday April 20, 2014 @05:58PM (#7618634)
I liked http://www.nss.org/settlement/ColoniesInSpace/ better as a book, though of course O'Neill had more authority.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:01AM (#7619707)
Quite. Just acknowledging you beat me to the punch ;-)
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Sunday April 20, 2014 @06:18PM (#7618688)
They're also featured heavily in T.A. Heppinheimer's Colonies in Space, now available in full text online:

http://www.nss.org/settlement/ColoniesInSpace/index.html

That featured strongly in my childhood imagination. I'm no longer the technotopian I was at the time, but it's a powerful vision. Much of what it (and O'Neil) promoted should have been done by now were it possible.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by abecedarius on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:58AM (#7620105)
O'Neill clearly wanted it to happen and let it bias his estimates. But what bothered me the most was that even if you did follow their strategy of build-powersats-in-place-out-of-extraterrestrial-materials, you could do it cheaper with workers in tin cans (and lots of automation and teleoperation) instead of livable colonies. The argument against this wasn't too convincing, but I was a teenager and figured "Hey, a lot can happen in a few decades." A lot more than actually did so far, sigh.

I still think large-scale work could have been done in space, and wasn't more for societal than technical reasons.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:59AM (#7620440)
I suspect the powersat evolved as a mission justification: so, we can conceive of human-habitable structures in space, but why would we do that. From Heppenheimer's book, it seems that the colony concept emerged first, then the powersat concept.

Once you've arrived at "orbiting solar power stations built from lunar regolith", questioning your premises and realizing that the colonies really don't make all that much sense. But then again, pragmatism and overt missions never really ruled space anyway -- see Apollo and the Shuttle.

As for the technical reasons, to paraphrase Douglas Adams: Space is expensive. Really expensive. You just won't believe how vastly, hugely, mindbogglingly expensive it is.

The ISS is the most expensive single structure ever constructed, and among the most expensive single projects ever undertaken -- and that for a habitation for six people. Total cost is somewhere north of $100 billion (how far north isn't clear, the budget's spread among multiple agencies and nations).

Given that, and absent tremendous gains in efficiency and automation, the cost of solar power satellites let alone O'Neil space colonies would be in the tens of trillions of dollars, minimum. That's on the scale of the entire US GDP, if not more.

As for your observation "a lot more than actually did [happen]": Colonies in Space is one of my benchmarks for rates of technological change that didn't happen. I'd anticipated that that could well be my future, but a decade and a half past when it was supposed to be a reality, it remains science fiction. It's given me a good sense of the sorts of change which are possible and likely, and those which aren't. And no, not all progress is subject to Kurzweil's Law of Accelerating Returns.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by marktangotango on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:49AM (#7621005)
>> It's given me a good sense of the sorts of change which are possible and likely, and those which aren't. And no, not all progress is subject to Kurzweil's Law of Accelerating Returns.

Indeed, we may be in Vinge's "Age of failed dreams".

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:51PM (#7624506)
Interesting Vinge reference. I wasn't familiar with that.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:33AM (#7620933)
It hasn't been done already because launch is still crazy expensive. Now we've got SpaceX making solid progress towards a fully reusable launch vehicle, which should drop costs by an order of magnitude, and Planetary Resources working on near-earth asteroid mining.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by SlipperySlope on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:02PM (#7618797)
I was a member of the L5 society and continue to believe that low earth orbit habitats will be a better option than colonizing Mars.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by FD3SA on Sunday April 20, 2014 @07:36PM (#7618896)
They are both extremely difficult to accomplish with current technology. The issue with Mars is that it has no magnetosphere [1], and as such, all habitats will have to be underground and/or shielded with very thick layers of lead, dirt and water.

Man made colonies will have the same problem, in addition to requiring space manufacturing and assembly at a level that is currently impossible.

If SpaceX brings the cost of space flight down to its basic energy costs, we will have solved one problem. The other problem is the power generation required to conduct space manufacturing at a large scale. Solar, although consistent, is low in power density and thus requires large amounts of surface area that is very difficult to maintain in space.

Until we crack compact, high yield fusion, I doubt we will make much progress in realizing our space-faring dreams. This was also the opinion of the late Robert Bussard, inventor of the Bussard ramjet and the polywell fusor.

1. http://www.space.com/24731-mars-radiation-curiosity-rover.ht...

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by rbanffy on Sunday April 20, 2014 @09:10PM (#7619169)
Mars colonies, at least, can rely on Nitrogen and CO2 from the Martian atmosphere. Orbital habitats have to import everything but sunlight.

Having the colonies underground may have an extra advantage, both on Mars and on the Moon, as they may be closer to sources of ice. I remember hearing something about the Moon being much less dry than previously thought. No running water nor blocks of ice, but maybe crunching rocks yields something useful.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by afhdshufdufdo on Sunday April 20, 2014 @09:37PM (#7619267)
Right on. To add to this, early stage terraforming is in the immediate rather than long-term plan for Mars. As soon as we start producing CO2 on Mars, we're on our way.

I'm not against colonizing space itself, but early seagoing explorers didn't attempt to colonize the ocean. We need to establish ourselves in environments that allow easy production of oxygen, water, and food.

In the end, it is about money. It takes a lot of money to get setup on Mars, but after it is setup, it is a HUGE resource, which means much, much more money. The moon could also be a huge resource, but it is expensive to colonize because it can't hold atmosphere easily. Colonizing space itself without mining a resource in a way that eventually will pay off the initial investment is useless and a drain on our society.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by rbanffy on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:14PM (#7625155)
There is no reason to require the place to hold an atmosphere - you just need to build your colony underground (which you already have to do to protect it from radiation). The Moon may be interesting for magnetic launch systems (no atmosphere, plenty of energy and reduced propellant requirements) and all kinds of metallurgic processes (no atmosphere, low - but not too low - gravity). Mars is also interesting if you can industrialize the manufacture of fuel and oxidiser from the atmosphere - gravity is low enough you can make it into a chemical rocket fueling station (landers and such will still use chemicals for a long time), at least until we develop some icy moons further out.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by Nick_C on Sunday April 20, 2014 @11:05PM (#7619555)
> because it can't hold atmosphere easily

But neither can Mars. Most of its early atmosphere was blown away and that will continue. There's nothing we can do about the lack of gravity.

The problem with Mars is that it is cold, terminally. The nuclear furnaces have gone out. I haven't seen a proposal from the terraformers that counteracts that. You might be able to counteract it with CO2, but then that gets blown away by the solar wind. It's crazy hard to fix.

Don't get me wrong, I would love to see us on Mars. Unfortunately, the engineering and science obstacles are huge, enormous.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by stevep98 on Monday April 21, 2014 @02:31AM (#7620054)
> Unfortunately, the engineering and science obstacles are huge, enormous.

Yes, I agree we should go to Mars. I don't see the urgency, though. I mean, in terms of the humanity-backup situation, ten years or a hundred, doesn't really make much difference.

We would be better putting the money into energy research, and when we've got that figured out, then we tackle mars.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by sirkneeland on Sunday April 20, 2014 @11:50PM (#7619680)
"No running water nor blocks of ice, but maybe crunching rocks yields something useful"

Space Fracking?

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by rbanffy on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:04PM (#7625104)
The bright side is you have no ecosystem to worry about.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by onnoonno on Monday April 21, 2014 @12:55AM (#7619855)
> Until we crack compact, high yield fusion, I doubt we will make much progress in realizing our space-faring dreams.

What about regular, fission nuclear power?

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:26AM (#7620492)
Not enough fuel.

Projections that there's enough uranium for 200 years[1] are based on levels of present utilization: around 3.7% of global energy use[2]. Bump that to 100% and we'd run through all available reserves in less than a decade (7.4 years, if you're counting).

Solar energy (including solar mediated via plants, wind, or water), hydrogen fusion, possibly geothermal energy, or with really long odds: hydrocarbon prospecting from another body (say, maybe Titan) are the only energy sources which could last a considerable human population for the possible maximum lifetime of the species.

Yes, a small Mars outpost could be powered off of nuclear power for a considerable period, but that would take away from available nuclear fuel supplies on Earth.

The likelihood of managing usable sustainable fusion under terrestrial or other contained circumstances are fairly unlikely IMO.

________________________________

Notes:

1. http://www.scientificamerican.com/article/how-long-will-glob...

2. IEA: http://www.iea.org/Sankey/index.html

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:41AM (#7620971)
The fuel supply for conventional reactors is limited because they rely on U235, which is 0.7% of uranium. Fast reactors could use the rest of the uranium. That multiplies the supply by more than 100x because it means you can economically retrieve fuel from lower-grade ore, or even from seawater, which would extend the supply to millions of years. Russia has several fast reactors in production right now, and is building more.

Liquid thorium reactors are another option. There's no thorium in seawater, but on land there's several times as much thorium as U238, and it's all the same, useful isotope. China has an aggressive R&D program hoping to get a prototype reactor ready in a decade.

But personally I think it's likely that we will achieve sustainable fusion in the fairly near future.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @10:59AM (#7621342)
My understanding of seawater is that uranium concentrations are 0.01 - 0.02%, and that it's not thermodynamically feasible to extract it for energy at those concentrations.
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @11:15AM (#7621449)
A quick google of "extracting uranium from seawater" gives a different impression. For example: http://spectrum.ieee.org/energy/nuclear/nuclear-fuel-from-th...

...which says that EROI is 22 assuming a conventional reactor. Ie., we'd get 22 times as much energy out as we spent on extraction. With a fast reactor the ratio would be a hundred times better, since we could use all that uranium instead of 0.7% of it.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by DennisP on Monday April 21, 2014 @05:18PM (#7623965)
Also, geological processes bring more uranium to the surface, and rivers are constantly putting more uranium in the oceans, at a rate that would provide 25 times our current electricity usage. If we keep our usage at that level, uranium will last until the sun goes out.

http://www-formal.stanford.edu/jmc/progress/cohen.html

Of course in the context of the current discussion we should also consider the possibility of getting uranium from various other spots in the solar system: http://nextbigfuture.com/2009/08/how-much-uranium-is-in-sola...

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by TheSpiceIsLife on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:03AM (#7620842)
I've read that Thorium and Fast Breeder technology pushes that out to somewhere beyond 50,000+ years - http://www.skepticforum.com/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=21247
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Tuesday April 22, 2014 @03:53AM (#7626346)
Looking over that page, there's a critical error materially affecting his supply estimate.

Rob Lister gives global annual energy consumption as 140 TWh.

The true number is 211,782 TWh, for 2011, from IEA (expressed as 18,210 Mtoe -- million tons of oil equivalent)

http://www.iea.org/Sankey/index.html

That's 1512x higher than Lister's value. Dividing his 64,000 year supply by 1512, we get 42 years supply of thorium.

I see a problem.

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by onnoonno on Saturday April 26, 2014 @03:10PM (#7652425)
That's only proven reserves, though. Thorium right now is in basically no demand. Given the extremely high energy density of the fuel, A LOT of ores will become economically extractable.

It might not be 64ky, but >1ky seems to be very realistic.

Edit: See also the Wikipedia section on it: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thorium#Reserve_estimates

Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by evantish on Monday April 21, 2014 @09:29AM (#7620922)
typeof fusion !== typeof fission
Re:Space Colony Art from the 1970s by dredmorbius on Monday April 21, 2014 @06:54PM (#7624521)
Sorry?

I'm not claiming otherwise.