I think the key is that every story on the home page helps you to better understand how something works or why something happened. You know, the hacker part of "hackernews".
We should probably save the flags for stories that are being manipulated by spammers or small groups. Anything else will rotate off the home page in a few hours anyway.
Politics/economics are low hanging fruit that anyone can dig up a story on and comment on. Erlang vs Scala in terms of creating distributed systems... not so much. The first will always crowd out the second, given enough time.
It's a tough, but interesting, question. Limiting the topics allowed reduces the functional value of the group. But loosening it too much will reduce the quality of the group itself. I don't know the solution (yet).
I have a suspicion that these two things are mutually incompatible.
Personally I am not convinced what happened to Reddit and Slashdot etc would happen here anyway. It is quite possible that Reddit has accomodated all the people who wanted a current-style Reddit and they are all happy where they are. There is a finite number of people, after all, despite how it sometimes seems.
The people arguing against political topics here, based upon the experience at Reddit, do so referring to a single data point in a highly complex environment. I am far from convinced the argument is valid at all. Sure, discourage puns in comments and [PIC] links, couldn't agree more. But I am not sure forbidding whole topics as a rule is a good idea. Plenty of smart hackers are also interested in politics, and they might not be interested in participating in multiple discussion sites. If HN limits itself too much, they might get bored and leave.
Anyway, just my speculation on an interesting topic, not trying to mount a formal argument or anything.
1. It's about a non-technical political topic
2. I am British and care very little about the internal political arguments in the US concerning their health care system.
Although it refers to the US health care system, the narrative applies to health care delivery in general and is applicable to other countries.
You are right that it is non-technical, but it is of a higher quality and more intellectually satisfying than countless other submissions here. Presumably you also have flagged Signaling and Indian Higher Education though I'm not sure whether your nationality would make that more appealing to you.
One wrong doesn't justify another. But sure, flagged that too. I don't vote up or down based on "nationality". An inappropriate (for HN) article (subjective judgment to be sure) is surprisingly nationality independent.
If you had any idea about the complex mix of nationalities that are my daily life you'd realize that I couldn't give a damn about the country being discussed. I'm not interested in discussions of that country's internal politics. The article about Indian education was flagged for a different reason, it seemed irrelevant to HN how the Indian general education system worked. Really interesting topic for an article in The Economist, but I came here for code and related subjects.
Amen Brother!
Political articles should be (imho) shut down very fast. The "flag and wait for a moderator" tactic doesn't seem to be working as well as it used to.
How can we judge how well the system is working when we have no direct insight into it? Perhaps a moderator reviewed the post and found it to be of merit?
I said
"The "flag and wait for a moderator" tactic doesn't seem to be working as well as it used to."
there is a subtle difference between what I said and what you claimed I said.
My response doesn't make sense anymore now that you edited yours! :-) I am leaving it unedited however.
And by the way, the article is quite good, I just don't want it on HN.
The political pieces on HN are starting to overwhelm the technical articles. Isn't there enough of this on Reddit?