News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by danso on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @12:30PM (#7598747)
Let me preface this by saying: I have the upmost respect for the Webflow developers and designers...they've created a highly-functional web app with the purpose of enabling creators...the process to make such a full-featured web-browser product with such a range of capability is astounding.

That said, I disagree with the implication that Webflow, and similar products, solve the problems of code, e.g., the phrase "Do xyz without writing a line of code". Knowledge of code does constrain non-developers, but in the end, that is not the hard part. To use a quick example: the mechanics of baking responsiveness into a new site from scratch is significantly easier than the conceptual process of "What information and features should be prominent, or excised, in the mobile view of our website?"...and in my opinion, that latter problem is something that people can get into without knowing how to write code.

So despite the technical strength of the Webflow product, I don't think that it makes things easier in the end. Instead of "code", a newbie has to learn a whole new interface, a whole new set of iconography/terms (used for buttons, subheads, etc.), and last but not least, a whole new set of quirks inherent to the Webflow program. And when they become experts at this, they have spent 50-90% of their cognitive ability mastering Webflow, and the remainder understanding the creative and technical process of web development.

At some point, isn't it just better to learn some code? Not 10 years worth, but something in between that and "0 lines of code". I've used Webflow, and I'll repeat again, it is an excellent web product in execution and design...but the problem it attempts to tackle is just too big, and the abstractions it offers may ended up hindering creators in the medium-to-long run.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by callmevlad on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @12:36PM (#7598793)
I'm the founder and CEO of Webflow, and I can't agree enough with your statement that code is not the hard part. That's why we're trying to create tools for designers to help them focus on the hard parts (content, usability, etc).

I love what Bret Victor says about this in his Magic Ink paper [1]. Replace "information software" with "web applications" as you read it:

"I suggest that the design of information software should be approached initially and primarily as a graphic design project. The foremost concern should be appearance—what and how information is presented. The designer should ask: What is relevant information? What questions will the viewer ask? What situations will she want to compare? What decision is she trying to make? How can the data be presented most effectively? How can the visual vocabulary and techniques of graphic design be employed to direct the user’s eyes to the solution? The designer must start by considering what the software looks like, because the user is using it to learn, and she learns by looking at it."

The act of creating a solution IS the hard part, not tweaking CSS properties or knowing how to integrate Bootstrap components just right. All those things should just get out of the way and let creatives do the important work, without bogging down in the implementation details.

In case you're interested, I wrote a bit more about this on our blog a while ago: http://blog.webflow.com/designers-will-rule-the-web

[1] http://worrydream.com/MagicInk/

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by brenschluss on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @04:54PM (#7600479)
I absolutely agree with all of you say -- which is why "without code" is misleading / unhelpful.

A better tagline for the web interactions site would be: "Don't code website interactions; design them."

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by mbesto on Thursday April 17, 2014 @02:25AM (#7602235)
As long as "without code" is the copy that converts better, then it doesn't matter.
Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by Edmond on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @04:53PM (#7600475)
despite my comment below, I should add that I do like your product...I think if you guys keep your focus right you might ultimately deliver a wonderful product...just don't pitch it as a "get rid of your developer" product :)
Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by lanna_lee on Thursday April 17, 2014 @05:28AM (#7602667)
I agree. In the end, the user doesn't care about how the site is build just like a driver doesn't care how a car works.
Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by Edmond on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @04:45PM (#7600415)
I agree with this sentiment. I think in the long run the best solution is not going to be eliminating coding but building products that eliminate the need for unnecessary technical knowledge and lowering the bar in terms of coding expertise.

I am the developer of HiveMind (crudzilla.com), it is a web app platform designed with the aim of lowering technical barrier in mind.

My approach to the design of the product is to create something that people with moderate programming and web development skills can use to build high quality web apps. That means for instance being able to integrate the work of a more sophisticated developer with the ease of drag-n-drop and "fill in the blank" type workflows. But ultimately the end users still needs to know how to code.

The allure of eliminating the need for coding is one that has been around for a long time and continues to be attractive to businesses but it is a misguided approach that doesn't work.

I worked for an employer that peddles a product that claims to require no coding, instead you end up filling out forms until your fingers hurt because you are essentially coding in a convoluted manner.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by ultimatedelman on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @01:13PM (#7599061)
i actually came here to say pretty much the same thing. as a front end dev, i thought the site looked and functioned pretty well. if you can get someone to build that complex of a site with some "non-coding" tools, well done. my concern is that you've taken the problem of coding and replaced it with a new one. people who don't understand how the web works won't be able to build amazing beautiful sites with this product (ok, maybe some will, my guess is a low percentage). what you've done is create a better WYSIWYG, and we all know what WYSIWYGs get you: Geocities.

again, no knock on the site, it looks like it's really well done, i'm just not sure that a series of complex controls solves the problem of web development any better than just learning how to code yourself.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by thesergie on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @03:25PM (#7599948)
I'm one of the co-founders and designers at Webflow. I have never coded an entire site by hand, but I built this entire responsive site in Webflow. This WYSIWYG doesn't disregard how the web works - users actually have to know some CSS to build a responsive layout. This restriction limits a lot of Average Joe's (so no Geocities here). I actually learned all the intricacies of CSS by building sites in Webflow. Same goes for the designers out there using tool and building actual sites for the first time.

It boils down to investment and return. If designers can build responsive sites faster and easier with great code output (see source code) using a WYSIWYG, then it makes more sense to invest in that versus learning how to write the same code. Front end devs use frameworks like Bootstrap and Foundation to cut development time. Webflow serves the same purpose, but all the framework components are made visual.

This visual abstraction makes it more accessible for more people just like these frameworks made web dev easier. There is always the possibility of people using Webflow and creating poorly-coded websites, but anyone trying to code can do the same.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by ultimatedelman on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @05:20PM (#7600607)
That's totally fine and understandable. However, what if I decide that I want to do something a bit more complex? Data-driven, even? What if I want more interactivity? Now I am limited by what your tool can do, and I've already taken the time to learn to use your tool and build a site in your ecosystem rather than learning how to code myself and be unrestricted in what I can do.

Again, I'm sure your intent with this product is not "build every website out there," but I am concerned by those with a little knowledge and ambition using your site as the easy way out for making a website rather than taking the time to actually learn how to do all those things for themselves.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by Kequc on Wednesday April 16, 2014 @05:45PM (#7600739)
I find I have the same problem when I enlist the use of any tool more complex than jQuery, haml, sass, coffeescript. Even if it is something like a jQuery plugin, bootstrap or foundation. Those addons are great as a way to impress your boss and get to a starting point quickly or early. As soon as something needs to become sufficiently complex that's when I really start to regret my decisions.

I imagine this tool is perfect for creating a beautiful landing page or similar. Obviously one isn't going to try and use it to build anything enterprise grade.

But there lots of jQuery plugins or css frameworks out there but they largely seem to have active user bases.

Re:Create JavaScript, CSS Interactions With Zero Lines of Code by tremols on Thursday April 17, 2014 @10:20AM (#7603694)
This is like saying that people shouldn't use Excel because they won't understand how the CPU works.

The audience here is people that feels comfortable doing stuff tweaking parameters on a dialog box, they don't care if the dialog box is actually a lazy evaluated reactive continuation or whatever as long as it does the job.

An abstraction layer for web technology is as relevant, revolutionary and useful as an abstraction layer for the CPU was on its time (in fact the most succesful companies did exactly this).