News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @10:55AM (#7586485)
Never sign these.

They have no right. None at all.

It's fair enough to get people to sign something that says they won't leak IP, and even that they won't do other projects that compete with company business. But a catch-all "All your code belongs to us?"

No. Way.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @11:18AM (#7586631)
> They have no right. None at all.

Depends on where you are. In germany this is actually enshrined in the Arbeitnehmererfindungsgesetz. The employer has the right, even without the contract clause. Good luck opting out.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @11:53AM (#7586892)
Wow.

Remind me never to work in Germany! (It comes up once in a while. I probably wasn't going to anyway, but this is further reason not to)

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @12:03PM (#7586957)
Just out of interest, to whoever did it - why the downvote?

I think Germany's a great country, there's an awful lot done right there, but it's important enough to me that I retain ownership of my own out-of-hours projects that I would not work there.

Is this wrong of me?

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @12:12PM (#7587010)
Why? There's an easy way to solve this problem: Go talk to your employer. The ones you might want to work for are reasonable: I'm not claiming IP rights for unrelated side projects of employees.

Now if you get into the area where you're dealing with trade secrets and patents on stuff that directly relates to your work, even if you write the code on the side, you'll probably run into trouble in a lot of jurisdictions. There's no way to effectively draw the line and say "oh, this small idea about the flux-compensator, I had that at work, but this great, patent-worthy-and-billion-dollar idea, that builds on my previous findings at work, that one, that totally came to me in my spare time (exactly at 08:01 pm, just as I stepped into my car)." That's the problems that these regulations try to tackle. It's imperfect, but hey, at least you're entitled to a fair compensation by the same law.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:32PM (#7587554)
Talking to your employer solves nothing. Many times people will renege on verbal agreements to allow things, either because of inflated concerns about liability or competition, or simply out of ignorance or spite.

I don't wish to exposed to those legal possibilities. It's just not acceptable to me.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @02:04PM (#7587767)
> Many times people will renege on verbal agreements to allow things, either because of inflated concerns about liability or competition, or simply out of ignorance or spite.

That's what I meant with 'people you don't want to work for', especially the ones that act out of spite. I found all employers that I worked for in my career quite supportive, some would even allow me to work on the side projects during office time.

> I don't wish to exposed to those legal possibilities. It's just not acceptable to me.

Certainly your choice. Given that a lot of US employment contracts have clauses to the same effect I'd be curious what options remain. European law is fairly well standardized and I'd not be surprised if other european countries have laws to the same effect. Germany tends to be pretty employee friendly.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @02:20PM (#7587862)
And how do you tell ahead of time if someone's going to change their mind or go back on their verbal agreement? You can't.

In the US I would at least be free not to sign such a contract, or demand the clause be removed. I'm in the UK and I wouldn't sign anything like that here either. I also don't believe we have anything like that in law, though I could be wrong.

I know Germany (and much of the EU) are very employee friendly, which is why I find this so surprising, and frankly pretty outrageous.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @03:44PM (#7588372)
> And how do you tell ahead of time if someone's going to change their mind or go back on their verbal agreement? You can't.

Ok, sorry, I was unclear: Talk about it, come to an agreement and get that in writing. E-Mail as confirmation should be enough to move the burden of proof to the employer.

> I know Germany (and much of the EU) are very employee friendly, which is why I find this so surprising, and frankly pretty outrageous.

I'm not surprised. This certainly is an area that will get a lot of problematic cases. The law in germany not only contains the first right of the employer to certain inventions, it also stipulates fair compensation and guidelines about the correct process. I much prefer that over "let's battle that out in court." It's actually quite employee-friendly.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @04:47PM (#7588825)
I don't prefer that at all. If I'm doing something work related I do it at work and it belogs to them. If I'm not there and it's unrelated it's mine.

Lawsuits need only occur when someone strays into the middle.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by jsmthrowaway on Monday April 14, 2014 @12:47PM (#7587238)
You know, not being a German speaker, the first time I read that name I thought you were being facetious. No disrespect to the German language, but that is one hell of a name.

I'm assuming an English equivalent is something like "standard conflict resolution for employees?" I can see "arbitration" in the German, if I'm not mistaken.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @12:50PM (#7587264)
No, I'm not being facetious. The official name is "Gesetz über Arbeitnehmererfindungen", the official short "ArbnErfG". (http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/arbnerfg/BJNR007560957.htm...)

The english equivalent would be "Law governing inventions made by employees".

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by rz2k on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:04PM (#7587367)
"Arbeit" is a way to free yourself, but it isn't arbitration.
Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:12PM (#7587423)
I hope the nazi reference ("Arbeit macht frei") was not intentional.
Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Dewie on Monday April 14, 2014 @02:15PM (#7587821)
You could say that German is one of the languages where you can combine words to form new words pretty freely.

A lot of language features seem pretty weird from other reference points. But I don't think it's constructive to point it out like this.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by JackFr on Monday April 14, 2014 @11:25AM (#7586679)
What about working for a competitor? Presumably a company can ask that you not actively undermine their product while cashing their paychecks?

From that I would argue that by building a similar product in his free time he was effectively working for a competitor.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @11:52AM (#7586885)
I'm not sure that my attitude to "we own all your stuff" clauses is directly relevant to the case at hand, no.

I agree entirely that the employer has the right to ask you not to compete while you're still employed by them. I won't sign non-competes that extend past employment, but I don't think it's unreasonable to sign one during employment. Particularly not for products (FOSS or otherwise) that directly compete with the very thing you're working on now.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Xylakant on Monday April 14, 2014 @12:14PM (#7587017)
> Particularly not for products (FOSS or otherwise) that directly compete with the very thing you're working on now.

But that's the case discussed here. The guy was tasked to build a CI-System at work and built another one in his spare time.

Re:Avow-CI Is No More by Nursie on Monday April 14, 2014 @01:35PM (#7587569)
Yes, I know, which is why my comment was specifically about clauses in which employers claim ownership of side projects and other out of scope productivity. Please track back up-thread to see the comment I was responding to.