News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dmix on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:21PM (#7567505)
Amazon is building a $600 million datacenter for the CIA. The CIA did all of the bad things listed in Dropbox article as directed by Bush and Condoleezza, and they are still actively trying to cover up torture. I've never heard anyone here not using EC2 over it?

The tech scenes pitchfork mobs are wildly inconsistent.

I have a feeling this one hit a nerve because Condoleezza Rice is famously hated across the internet and in the press (especially on the Daily Show) and this isn't really about upholding some strong high-moral consistency that we all have.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by sheri on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:46PM (#7567730)
And your point is what? That demonstrating outrage here is in some way invalid since similar outrage was not demonstrated in every other similar situation? Do I have no moral authority to speak up in this situation if I have not before?

Maybe we should boycott Amazon. Not boycotting Dropbox because we didn't do the same for Amazon doesn't get us anywhere.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dmix on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:15PM (#7568001)
The system Condaleeza represents is still active and is heavily entrenched. This campaign may be a good start, but its going to take much more than that to change anything -- and that requires a strong moral consistency than extends well beyond participating in an occasional mob.

Amazon is actively supporting infrastructure to an agency that supports torture. Condaleeza isn't even in power any more. It's not that you shouldn't boycott Dropbox, it's that you are probably not really doing anything as a result of not doing it when it matters. The thing that created Condaleeza is still moving full steam ahead.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by selmnoo on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:32PM (#7568153)
> Amazon is actively supporting infrastructure to an agency that supports torture. Condaleeza isn't even in power any more. It's not that you shouldn't boycott Dropbox, it's that you are probably not really doing anything as a result of not doing it when it matters.

That's probably true, but we have to consider the situation in the context of what's practicable in our own lives.

I have a Dropbox account, and I use Amazon's cloud service to host my sites. I will be canceling my Dropbox account as a protest, but probably will not cancel Amazon's cloud services. Why? Because I still need my paycheck, I still need to put food on my kids' plates at the end of the night -- and I do this in part with Amazon's cloud services. I have to pick and choose, and compromise along the way when I'm making my voice heard.

It's okay that sometimes some big companies get away it, and some don't. Godaddy got picked on a lot... there was a symbol attached to the Godaddy situation (a CEO who hunts elephants, and says weird things) -- in the end we won, because there was an easy narrative to follow. It wasn't perfect justice all the way, but what matters is progress was made at the end of the day -- SOPA was then beaten.

In a similar fashion, it's okay if folks decide to stick with Amazon's services, because ditching it would bring them a lot of inconvenience. We don't all have the resources and time to be ditching every service we don't like on principle -- we can pick and choose. We can pick and choose, especially, when there's momentum going on. Right now there's momentum going on with this Dropbox thing -- let it happen, this is how progress is made. Next time, a company will think twice before appointing to their board a warmonger.

edit (mostly to duaneb): to be clear, I am canceling my paid Dropbox account. Though, I think it's a good idea to cancel free Dropbox accounts in this case as well.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by duaneb on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:41PM (#7568243)
Dropbox doesn't matter. Your money does. It speaks volumes about you that you are outspoken on ethical issues except where your wallet is. Like the vast majority of Americans. Of course, that's precisely the attitude that gets us gay marriage (good), two wars, a dying environment, and an absolutely unsustainable economy based on putting our lower class out of work.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by justizin on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:06PM (#7568911)
Right. I work in a position where I am somewhat responsible for decisions such as whether to use AWS or not, which at other companies has been a different decision such as what hardware to purchase and where to install it.

This is a difficult situation to balance, because what you are suggesting, from my perspective, ends up being about saying, "I will quit working here unless we quit using Vendor X!" - that will end predictably, and I have lost that fight over GoDaddy as well. At the end of a day of following such a philosophy, I have no job, the Evil Vendor(tm) still gets their money, and I have to explain to people at Next Potential Job(tm) why I don't seem to be a team player.

That said, these are important fights to fight at some level. When I was dealing with hardware, I found many of our decisions frustrating. I found it frustrating that we cared about the USD$ cost of power, and not the environmental cost of it. I found it frustrating that we turned off almost all power saving features of our hardware because they don't deliver as one would hope and tend to harm the workload in a way that may actually require more gear which is expensive, has a carbon cost to manufacture, and has a carbon cost to operate and cool. Guess what? a 2U Rackmount server that sometimes runs at 1.5Ghz for a few seconds instead of running at 2.8GHz all of the time doesn't have a significant impact on the cooling bill, and it can reasonably be expected that your cooling power budget will be roughly equal to your equipment power budget, probably higher because of infrastructure overhead.

It is difficult to find a framework in which to push these decisions because the day to day business does not center around them.

The solution is for decision makers to make them a priority, just like worker safety and other things which don't obviously contribute to the short-term bottom line. I can't spend all of my time advocating up for socially responsible decisions.

Also, Amazon may be in a difficult place wrt other contracts with the government, they may have gotten themselves somewhat entangled. Dropbox does not need Condoleeza Rice on its' board, and it's hard to envision what value she will have other than internally advocating for cooperation with the government and its' defense armature.

That is what she does.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by duaneb on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:23PM (#7569450)
I mean, I use EC2 and see nothing wrong with it. I'm just pointing out the double standard of making a big fuss when what you're fussing about is probably a waste of energy and what you're not fussing about would be much more effective if you DID fuss about it.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by johnchristopher on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:54PM (#7568829)
> Dropbox doesn't matter. Your money does. It speaks volumes about you that you are outspoken on ethical issues except where your wallet is.

No, you distorted parent's statement by slightly reframing the perspective when it should be read like this:

It speaks volumes about you that you are outspoken on ethical issues except when it comes to putting food on your kid's plates.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by justizin on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:08PM (#7568930)
There is something to be said for making sacrifices, including on behalf of your entire family, in the face of ethics, and that most massive ethical challenges the human race has faced are because of people who would not refuse to participate.

But this structure can be applied to varying degrees in varying situations. A company who keeps an unencrypted copy of all my files and welcomes, for no particularly good reason, an INCREDIBLE advocate of overreach in government surveillance, not to mention violent tactics such as torture to extract information, and an architect of today's guantanamo bay facility, onto their board is a reason to be concerned about doing business with that company.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by duaneb on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:21PM (#7569443)
It's a false dichotomy that you either have to let your kids starve or support evil companies. Again, it's this dichotomy that has led to the present situation.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by rdc12 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @07:36PM (#7570375)
But your false dichotomy ignores reality, sure he could leave his current job (assuming he can't ditch evil company X at his current job), but will he then find another job at an "ideal" company that is a) not evil and b) uses no evil companies products, probably not
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Touche on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:36PM (#7569129)
> I have a Dropbox account, and I use Amazon's cloud service to host my sites. I will be canceling my Dropbox account as a protest, but probably will not cancel Amazon's cloud services. Why? Because I still need my paycheck, I still need to put food on my kids' plates at the end of the night -- and I do this in part with Amazon's cloud services. I have to pick and choose, and compromise along the way when I'm making my voice heard.

This is a great comment. I'm going to challenge you to do something I suspect you'll be resistant to.

You admit that some times you have to sacrifice your values for a greater cause (in this case your family's well being).

I challenge you to look back on the things you believe Condoleezza Rice did wrong and think about them as though she was making the same sort of sacrifice. Does that change your opinion of her?

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by general_failure on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:31PM (#7568148)
Well, one has to start somewhere. You start with small things and if things work out, you expand the scale.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by bm1362 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:12PM (#7568495)
Does this logic apply to the workers who maintain the physical infrastructure for the CIA? The Coke guys who refill soda machines? The internet providers?

Where do you draw the line? A government agency leverages services to further it's agenda- should those businesses take a moral position?

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by justizin on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:09PM (#7568936)
Businesses can take a moral position, and in fact, many businesses who work with the government _do_ take a moral position in doing so.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by powera on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:12PM (#7567986)
Yes. Selectively demonstrating a ridiculous amount of outrage at the hate target of the day is absurd. The fact that you couldn't possibly do it in every similar situation shows why it is absurd.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by arjie on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:55PM (#7568345)
Very Kantian. But there are other things for which the argument is successful. Take feeding a starving man, for instance. You cannot feed them all. That's absurd. Therefore, it is also absurd that you can feed the man starving in front of you.

That argument follows the same structure.

For what it's worth, I'm not talking about Ms. Rice here. It's the argument that bothers me. Seems shaky.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by bowlofpetunias on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:55PM (#7568839)
If I wasn't selective in what, when and how I choose to protest my only options would be a) not give a shit, ever, or b) not leave my house and possibly kill myself.

Some of us live in the real world where we have to pick our battles.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by ryanobjc on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:31PM (#7568149)
You make some great points.

I also note that if I wanted this controversy to fade away, I would seed conversations with people who say things exactly like this.

There is no way to know for sure!

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by grifpete on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:32PM (#7569114)
I think C Rice is an disturbing figure because she appears to be a contradiction. Nobody expects much of figures such as Rumsfeld or Chaney - they come across as ruthless unprincipled technocrats who are prepared to do some extraordinary dangerous things in pursuit of their ideological convictions. But CR is obviously highly intelligent and somehow more relatable. Which makes her actions feel like a betrayal. Hence the highly emotive reaction to her apologetics. One senses she should and indeed must know better.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by rantanplan on Friday April 11, 2014 @07:49AM (#7572326)
>in pursuit of their ideological convictions

Now that is an overstatement! Please don't give them so much credit. They are just sociopaths in pursuit of (more)power; no ideology behind them.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by PhasmaFelis on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:00PM (#7568873)
It's a pretty popular anti-activism stance, yeah. Unless you're an ascetic hermit who makes your own toilet paper, you're not allowed to protest anything without being labeled a hypocrite.

And of course if you do become an ascetic hermit, then you're just a crazy hippie.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:25PM (#7567530)
I don't use EC2 over it. I host a site with a million+ pageviews per month with >250GiB of user data and I host it with Voxility. It used to be on AWS.

Edit: FWIW, I also don't use dropbox. I use rsync and a VPS.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by azth on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:28PM (#7568645)
Out of curiosity, who is your VPS provider?
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:45PM (#7568764)
Digital Ocean. It doesn't really matter because I handle crypto myself, and don't offer trust to the VPS provider.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by azth on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:25PM (#7569069)
I've been meaning to do something like that myself. Did you use off the shelf tools for crypto, or did you write something yourself?
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:29PM (#7569094)
Yeah, I'm using gpg.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by doesnt_know on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:08PM (#7569347)
Would you be willing to do a little write up or make a blog post about your process or something?

I've been meaning to setup encrypted backups for a while. At the moment mine are all unencrypted, but are stored on hardware under my control that I have direct physical access too.

I'd like to use a convenient offsite storage provider, but have no interest in trusting them with data. Tarsnap would be ideal if it was actually Free Software, but the current license is a deal breaker.

Already use gpg in my workflow for some documents and password management. Do you literally just tar and then gpg the result or is it something more involved? It seems that would be fairly bandwidth heavy.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Sir_Cmpwn on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:24PM (#7569453)
Yes, I literally just tar and gpg the result. I could sort out something more elegant and do a writeup. Keep an eye on http://drewdevault.com.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by azth on Thursday April 10, 2014 @06:17PM (#7570057)
Looking forward to it :)
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by azth on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:21PM (#7569439)
> Tarsnap would be ideal if it was actually Free Software, but the current license is a deal breaker.

I looked at it from the angle that it is basically a 1-person company. The bus factor is too high! :)

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by res0nat0r on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:30PM (#7567580)
I believe this and Eich are easy targets (soft targets if we want to keep with the war theme) for people to go after.

Seeing the internet mob rally behind this and Eich remind me that these are easy targets for people to pick because it doesn't require much work (internet slacktivisim at work).

It would be more enlightening if someone would research all of the board members of many well known SV companies whos names none of us know, and post all of their political donations and leanings we might not all get along with, then we can see how picky we are in our outrage. Board members of Apple and Tesla donating to groups overseas who violate human rights? How about Apple supporting Foxconn, where is the boycott in that?

Eich and Rice are just being picked because it is easy to change your Facebook picture to protest, throw together a quick .com, or if you are really motivated write a petition on whitehouse.gov to show your outrage, vs. real actual sleuthing to determine if you agree with said Big Corp.

Unfortunately the latter takes much more work and that isn't in the general interest of those of us clicking +1 to show our "outrage"...

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dmix on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:47PM (#7567738)
This is my primary criticism of modern representative democracy and why I lost faith in it. Every couple years we politically assassinate a few easy targets, mostly in the press, we all pat ourselves on the back for standing up for something, while the massive entrenched groups stay in power and everything stays exactly the same.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by gress on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:20PM (#7568575)
That's one way of looking at it. Another is that if you want to change something big, it's a good idea to start out with achievable steps and build up from there.

As to 'Apple supporting Foxconn' - Apple have done more to improve working conditions at Foxconn than any other organization. If you want to boycott someone, it should be all of the other Foxconn customers who are doing nothing.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by wonderzombie on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:48PM (#7569204)
...which are all rational ways for people to optimize their time. And lo, it works sometimes.

So what you're really saying is that even though this is a fairly well-optimized use of people's time and effort, it's illegitimate because people aren't sweating for it. This is HN— if you leveled a similar complaint at a CEO, startup, or corporation, you'd be criticized for implying they're lazy rather than rational.

Don't get me wrong; I don't love slacktivism, either. I suspect it has an opportunity cost. I tentatively agree that it's a proxy for more substantive protest. However, I submit that this is because people don't otherwise feel empowered. If you believe any sort of activism is low percentage, then why not choose the route that is the least amount of effort?

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by scarmig on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:32PM (#7569112)
I hate these maximalist "unless you do X and Y and Z, you have no right to criticize ANYTHING, because I say so, so shut the fuck up" ideas. It's startlingly close to the USSR's "and you lynch negroes" response to any criticism of its policies by the USA: it brings up an irrelevancy, and it's made in bad faith. The only way to escape it would be to detach entirely from the system.

Would you have criticized MLK for only choosing convenient, media-visible targets for his protests? Hell, he ignored so many places, and even stayed in hotels that were segregated. What a fucking hypocrite.

Cesar Chavez? Loser: he only called for people to boycott some agricultural interests. Sure, anyone can give up grapes, but anyone who does that is worse than contemptible--they should have given up all food that's harvested in exploitative conditions!

Mother Teresa? Lame. She only helped people in India. What about people in Namibia?

Lech Walesa? He seemed so myopically focused on government in Poland. It wasn't even the worst communist country! If he were really freedom focused, he'd have left Eastern Europe to try to overthrow the Khmer Rouge.

Your criticism amounts to an incredibly lazy attempt to sidestep the issue. Condi Rice is a war criminal. Second only to Cheney, she is the person most responsible for the mass murder of hundreds of thousands of people. She broke numerous laws; authorized illegal torture; and engaged in illegal violations of Americans' rights. In a just world, she'd be brought before a jury, convicted, and put behind bars for life.

You have no right to criticize me for trying to reduce how implicated I am in one of the most evil acts of the 21st century.

And if you disagree, well, I can name a thousand other forums for you to post your comment in before you come here to Hacker News. Otherwise you're just being wildly inconsistent and deeply morally corrupt.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by chc on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:54PM (#7569252)
I hate political posts on Hacker News because they lead to petty, histrionic bickering like this.

What is intellectually gratifying about mean-spirited sarcasm like:

> You have no right to criticize me for trying to reduce how implicated I am in one of the most evil acts of the 21st century.

> And if you disagree, well, I can name a thousand other forums for you to post your comment in before you come here to Hacker News. Otherwise you're just being wildly inconsistent and deeply morally corrupt.

Political threads make people forget how to make positive contributions and instead they compete to express the most outrage. Nobody wins from that.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by bendoernberg on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:30PM (#7567583)
Better to be inconsistently principled than consistently unprincipled.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by vinhboy on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:47PM (#7567741)
I like your quote. It reminds me of a buddy of mine who says I am a hypocrite for buying local fruits and vegetable, because I buy toilet paper made by a Koch-owned company.

For some people, unless you live in a cave and refuse all modern technology, you are not allowed to have any moral authority.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by bduerst on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:54PM (#7568341)
I think it's more of an appeal for validation for your [more] consistently unprincipled friend's part.

They've decided that the effort is futile, so why can't you?

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by 001sky on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:05PM (#7567907)
Better to be inconsistently principled than consistently unprincipled.

That's some Jim Crow logic right there.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Crow_laws

Or perhaps its just psychopathy:

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/culture/books/10737827/Psychopath...

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by 001sky on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:02PM (#7568399)
Or, maybe you just got your quote wrong?

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perfect_is_the_enemy_of_good

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by IanDrake on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:40PM (#7567682)
I'm pretty sure "inconsistently principled" == "consistently unprincipled".
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dllthomas on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:01PM (#7567864)
I think that depends on the reading of "inconsistently principled". If the principles are inconsistent, then I tentatively think your equality holds. If the principles are consistent, and the stridency in application is inconsistent, then I don't think they are equal.

With the second reading, a tangential concern is what drives the inconsistency. If it is purely stochastic, then I think the above saying holds ("better to be..."). If it is manipulated by unprincipled agents, then it's much more questionable.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by 001sky on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:13PM (#7567992)
Keeping it intellectual, these arguments get put in front of the US supreme court all the time. Under "uses and abuses" of power, type cases. Disregarding their fundamental import has important consequences (at least if you believe wikipedia). See, eg

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equal_Protection_Clause

There's also a long history in cognitive science on social trust and perceived consistency (anti-hypocrisy).

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cognitive_dissonance

So that is why people normally vet these issues outsied of the context of SCOTUS, even on social issues. These are valid ideas irespective of people's views on any subject, IMHO.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by mindrag on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:05PM (#7567911)
Nahh
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by crystaln on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:46PM (#7567726)
It's quite simple.

Rice and Eich are not directly useful and their dismissal would have no effect on the protestors, so there is almost zero sacrifice. There is no sacrifice necessary on behalf of the protestors.

Dropping AWS on the other hand could be difficult and expensive for many, so protesting AWS requires either hypocrisy or sacrifice.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by pedrocr on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:22PM (#7568070)
>Rice and Eich are not directly useful and their dismissal would have no effect on the protestors, so there is almost zero sacrifice. There is no sacrifice necessary on behalf of the protestors.

And yet getting them fired has the impact of dissuading similar behavior. If you're a protestor why wouldn't you go for the low-hanging no-cost some-benefit moves?

>Dropping AWS on the other hand could be difficult and expensive for many, so protesting AWS requires either hypocrisy or sacrifice.

So the protestors have prioritized lower cost moves over higher cost moves. Sounds rational.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by thirsteh on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:12PM (#7567978)
While I personally think Eich shouldn't have been CEO, you sum up Internet protests nicely: People will scream and moan, but only a fraction of those people would continue to do so if it required they actually do anything--even something as simple as moderate physical exertion.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by wonderzombie on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:39PM (#7569147)
Why wouldn't people take action which has even a small percentage of success when it requires negligible effort and little time? It seems utterly rational to me.

Likewise, moderate physical exertion (read: effort and time) for a low percentage play is a more dubious proposition. There's a fixed amount of time in a day and you simply can't get more of it; you can only optimize.

I'm not saying people don't jump on bandwagons or whatever. I think outrage & anger are in some sense addictive and cyclical on their own. (Whether they are "legitimate" in any given case is orthogonal IMO.) And I'm sort of with you in spirit, as I gather you're basically criticizing slacktivism.

But if you're trying to set a bar for "real" activism, it's best to keep the above in mind, particularly when people feel otherwise disempowered.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by higherpurpose on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:28PM (#7567559)
I've been trying to avoid Amazon since they censored Wikileaks with a single phone call from a politician. I'll never forgive them for that. The fact that they're working with the CIA now just adds to the pile of reasons to dislike them.

Will history make a difference between IBM selling mainframes to Nazis to help their holocaust and Amazon selling servers to the CIA to help them assassinate people around the world and plan state coups? Maybe not quite on the same level, but pretty damn close.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by res0nat0r on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:31PM (#7567588)
Wikileaks violated the AWS TOS by publishing classified material in violation of US law.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by HillRat on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:53PM (#7567788)
This isn't the UK; it is not a violation of US law to publish classified information; the violation is when a person with legitimate access to classified information disseminates it to an unauthorized person (see, e.g., 18 USC § 798).

To date, the closest the US government has come to prosecuting a publisher was the attempt in the Pentagon Papers case to enjoin publication; SCOTUS struck down the effort, calling prior restraint "the most serious and least tolerable infringement on First Amendment rights." USG has not been anxious to go after publishers since then.

For example, State counsel Harold Koh, in a letter to Wikileaks demanding the removal of unredacted classified information, noted that the materials "were provided in violation of U.S. law ... As long as WikiLeaks holds such material, the violation of the law is ongoing." (Emph original.)

Koh did not state that WikiLeaks was violating US law, but that the person who provided the documents (Manning) had done so, and that the offense was a continuing one. He did not charge Wikileaks, or any of its members, with having broken the law, only that their source was continuing to do so.

There is no case law regarding whether USG can convict a publisher for obtaining classified material, but similar cases (e.g., Bartnicki v. Vopper) suggest that this would be difficult.

Having said that, the Obama administration has been historically aggressive in prosecuting leakers, including naming a journalist (FOX News reporter James Rosen) as an unindicted co-conspirator for receiving classified information from a State source.

If AMZN was talked into dropping Wikileaks, it wasn't because of criminal activity by the publisher; it was because of political pressure from the administration. Not the same thing.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by venomsnake on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:49PM (#7567758)
Publishing classified information is legal. Otherwise the editorial team of NYTimes would have gone to jail lots of times. It is the leaking of the information that is illegal IIRC
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by res0nat0r on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:38PM (#7567656)
Feel free to downvote since it doesn't fit the meme that "information wants to be free", but the statement is 100% correct.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by sitkack on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:13PM (#7567990)
You sound really sure of yourself, yet cite nothing.

http://gigaom.com/2010/12/07/has-wikileaks-actually-done-any...

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by res0nat0r on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:20PM (#7568048)
https://aws.amazon.com/message/65348/

There have been reports that a government inquiry prompted us not to serve WikiLeaks any longer. That is inaccurate.

There have also been reports that it was prompted by massive DDOS attacks. That too is inaccurate. There were indeed large-scale DDOS attacks, but they were successfully defended against.

Amazon Web Services (AWS) rents computer infrastructure on a self-service basis. AWS does not pre-screen its customers, but it does have terms of service that must be followed. WikiLeaks was not following them. There were several parts they were violating. For example, our terms of service state that “you represent and warrant that you own or otherwise control all of the rights to the content… that use of the content you supply does not violate this policy and will not cause injury to any person or entity.” It’s clear that WikiLeaks doesn’t own or otherwise control all the rights to this classified content. Further, it is not credible that the extraordinary volume of 250,000 classified documents that WikiLeaks is publishing could have been carefully redacted in such a way as to ensure that they weren’t putting innocent people in jeopardy. Human rights organizations have in fact written to WikiLeaks asking them to exercise caution and not release the names or identities of human rights defenders who might be persecuted by their governments.

We’ve been running AWS for over four years and have hundreds of thousands of customers storing all kinds of data on AWS. Some of this data is controversial, and that’s perfectly fine. But, when companies or people go about securing and storing large quantities of data that isn’t rightfully theirs, and publishing this data without ensuring it won’t injure others, it’s a violation of our terms of service, and folks need to go operate elsewhere.

We look forward to continuing to serve our AWS customers and are excited about several new things we have coming your way in the next few months.

— Amazon Web Services

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by sitkack on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:57PM (#7568360)
What you cite and what you said are different. Wikileaks did not break the LAW by publishing classified documents.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Joeboy on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:35PM (#7567623)
I think the difference is, people have been calling for boycotts of Amazon for various reasons for years, and it's never made any difference to anything. They are too entrenched. I guess people are buoyed by the success of the anti-Eich campaign and think, perhaps correctly, that it might actually be practically possible to pressure Dropbox into dropping Rice.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by sfk on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:09PM (#7567938)
Politicians should be held to extremely high moral standards, hence the outrage.

If you read the link you'll see that Knuth himself only wrote two letters to government officials. Most people do not have time to become full time activists, so a certain degree of inconsistency seems inevitable.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by yid on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:44PM (#7567715)
> Condoleezza Rice is famously hated across the internet and in the press (especially on the Daily Show)

Her actions are hated; she's been on the Daily Show at least once and had a pretty decent conversation with Jon Stewart.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by thesimpsons1022 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:05PM (#7568428)
I can guarantee that poster has never watched the daily show and just assumes it's liberal propaganda.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by m52go on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:14PM (#7567993)
For the record, I'm not asking for Condi to step down or be removed. It would be hypocritical of me to do so--I openly criticized people on HN for asking Eich to step down.

From a pure business perspective: I just think it's a bonehead move on Dropbox's part, as other people could have brought similar value with less reputational damage.

Views on gay marriage have NOTHING to do with running Mozilla. Views on data security+privacy have EVERYTHING to do with leading Dropbox.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by thesimpsons1022 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:03PM (#7568413)
why do you care about seeming hypocritical? do what you feel is right. in the words of Emerson: " A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do. He may as well concern himself with his shadow on the wall. Speak what you think now in hard words, and to-morrow speak what to-morrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said to-day. — 'Ah, so you shall be sure to be misunderstood.' — Is it so bad, then, to be misunderstood? Pythagoras was misunderstood, and Socrates, and Jesus, and Luther, and Copernicus, and Galileo, and Newton, and every pure and wise spirit that ever took flesh. To be great is to be misunderstood. "
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by m52go on Monday April 14, 2014 @09:23AM (#7585953)
Thank you so much for posting this quote. It's not an uncommon one, but I've never seen the whole thing, i.e., the part after the first line.

Point taken :)

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by thesimpsons1022 on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @02:15AM (#7590542)
no problem haha :) thanks for not replying with a snarky comment. If you like this, you should read "self reliance" by Emerson. It is pretty short but wonderfully inspirational, I take care to read it every once and awhile.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by m52go on Tuesday April 15, 2014 @08:44AM (#7591462)
That's exactly where I ended up!

His wisdom is clear from his quotes, but it's something else to read those essays in their entirety. Great stuff.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by brlewis on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:35PM (#7568184)
CIA: Amazon's customer

Rice: Dropbox's board member

I don't think "pitchfork mobs" would object to Rice merely being a customer, even if she stored documents for objectionable purposes.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by notahacker on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:42PM (#7568743)
This is my view, more or less (though one could legitimately argue that bidding to build one's first ever private datacentre for the CIA is a much closer relationship than simply not preventing the CIA from having AWS accounts). Selecting a board member whose most relevant achievements are circumventing security legislation and browbeating foreign governments (she's undoubtedly extremely smart but she's not been appointed for investment or engineering insights) says a lot more about a company than whose cash they'll accept.

That said, the many calls to boycott Amazon were perfectly reasonable too.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by espeed on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:32PM (#7568671)
I've never heard anyone here not using EC2 over it? The tech scenes pitchfork mobs are wildly inconsistent.

You can't fight them all. Choose your battles wisely.

   Any fool can criticize, complain, condemn,
   and most fools do. Picking your battles
   is impressive and fighting them fairly
   is essential. —Dale Carnegie
Pick battles big enough to matter, small enough to win.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by pedrocr on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:17PM (#7568023)
This is an instance of "but someone else also does horrible things". That may very well be true but isn't really an argument for why the "horrible thing" we're discussing at the moment isn't horrible.

There's a great article by a journalist explaining this phenomenon (my google-fu is weak today). He discusses how every time he reports on "X country has done atrocity Y" he gets replies of "but why aren't you covering country Z which is also horrible?".

If the standard for being able to protest anything is that you must do full due-diligence and protest all similar things then no one would ever be able to protest anything.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by Tloewald on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:28PM (#7567558)
I don't [yet] use AWS but thanks for raising this issue.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by avenger123 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:07PM (#7567927)
The CIA is a big massive blob that represents thousands of people. Rice is an individual. Much easier to critique.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by r00fus on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:15PM (#7569399)
Rice is a public figure that helped sell the Iraq War by lying.

She's done some pretty slimy stuff and essentially admitted to it, so that's why she's easy to target.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by samstave on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:42PM (#7568249)
>isn't really about upholding some strong high-moral consistency that we all have.

YES, it actually is!

The issue is that Rice is a known, singular, actual person wh was directly responsible for the war, death and corrupt profiteering by the defense industry.

Whereas, its much more difficult to connect an actual individual with something like "amazon building a data center" (Yes, you can hate on Bezos - but he did not start a war killing thousands of people on trump up pretense AND get caught actually lying about said pretense)

Condi is a war criminal.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by PhasmaFelis on Thursday April 10, 2014 @03:07PM (#7568919)
So what's your point? Our only options are to either abandon all hope of change, or secede from the world and join a hippie commune?

Nobody has the energy or resources to fight all possible battles at once. All we can do is try to pick the ones that we hope will provide the most benefit, most efficiently.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dredmorbius on Thursday April 10, 2014 @04:42PM (#7569569)
You pick your battles.

In a moral argument, finding a target who's likely sensitive to moral suasion, whose audience or market is vocal, outspoken, and rights-oriented, and in which there's a reasonable chance for success. The Mozilla-Eich situation would be a case in point.

Condaleeza Rice has certainly drawn fire previously in her career -- despite Knuth's apparent support of her while at Stanford, I'm aware of others who were glad to see her move on, though perhaps not fully realizing she could do far more harm as National Security Advisor.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by stephencanon on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:22PM (#7568061)
Inconsistency or hypocrisy doesn’t make someone wrong. Should people be outraged about more things? Maybe. That doesn’t mean that they aren’t justified in being outraged about any one thing.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by camus2 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:37PM (#7568200)
It does when there is an elephant in the room. It's like people complaining about these evil 1% rich while benefiting from quasi slave labor from China when buying all their cheap stuff...
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by pohl on Thursday April 10, 2014 @05:17PM (#7569787)
I have no particular standing in this debate, but I've decided that terms like "pitchfork mobs", "witch hunts", and "bullies" in the context of this issue are far too close to Godwin territory for my taste.

Has there been actual violence that I haven't seen covered in the news? All I've seen are consumers engaging in online discourse about ceasing use of a service.

I don't mind reading the contrary opinions, too, but I'd really like to read some that can explain their case without the hyperbole.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by rjzzleep on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:52PM (#7567774)
there's a few fundamental differences between condi, amazon, and eich.

I'm sure I'll get a few downvotes, but basically the former two are plain business decisions. A lot of the people complaining about dropbox's service are either free tier customers or lower end business users.

Having Condi on board means immediate trust of huge multinational concerns likes Chevron. It doesn't matter if the people in there trust dropbox as long as the board does.

I didn't know Amazon builds the data center, I thought SAIC did, but I guess there is more than one contract. Amazon has huge experience in building data centers. They also have a govcloud. They probably bid on one of the contract offerings, and won. Well that, and some dude from the Amazon probably went golfing with some NSA dude. But it really doesn't matter, since in a way these are morally correct decisions.

Of course there is no such thing as a universal moral standard. By that standard though, you would have to boycott a lot of the tech universities in the US that get their money from DARPA contracts(a view I used to share when I was a bit younger, and still "kinda"(notreally) do).

For the record, it's important to know that I'm against both of these things, but generically speaking my argumentation speaks against what I might be morally thinking, but they're both legally correct, and from a business perspective correct.

OTOH Eich was just a personal tirade. condi, and amazon are just plain old money decisions.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by eik3_de on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:58PM (#7568370)
AFAIK dropbox uses ec2 and s3, so dropping dropbox is a double win
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by PeterWhittaker on Thursday April 10, 2014 @08:11PM (#7570492)
The tech scenes pitchfork mobs are wildly inconsistent.

THIS.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by iambother on Thursday April 10, 2014 @02:06PM (#7568439)
>>>>The tech scenes pitchfork mobs are wildly inconsistent.

Just because the mob is all pitchfork'ed and ready doesn't mean it isn't its own victim to the trap of considering the world black and white.

There really are no absolutes. We're all using machines built for us by slaves. But at least we are communicating on how this enslavement can end. Would you end the show just because you think the last 15 minutes are 'a forgone conclusion'? Hang in here for this argument, and you may discover that the world is not black and white.

Ms. Rice is hated because of the things she allowed to occur as a part of her lifestyle. She is a cog in what many consider to be a highly destructive, death machine.

High-moral consistency is one thing; on the other end of this conversation is a father, laying dying in the ditch, watching the bits of their kids fade into the dirt. Condaleeze Rice is responsible for a fuck of a lot of that.

Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by detokaal on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:11PM (#7567969)
This is a cover up to hide the real motivation: she is a woman and black, and none of you want her involved in a tech company. Disguise this all you want as opposition to the war or Bush or whatever. It is really opposition to her gender and race. This is how you do in silicon valley where blacks and women are considered token employees hire to look good. So make up stuff about her and move her out. Now you have your high-tech lynching hiding behind phony moral outrage.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by scelerat on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:19PM (#7568037)
Got any evidence for this claim? That people are really opposed to her because ~"she's black and a woman" and not because she helped start a war that killed thousands, predicated on lies and misinformation?
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by jdeisenberg on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:38PM (#7568210)
Had Dropbox put former Vice President Dick Cheney (male, white) on the board, I suspect the firestorm of controversy would be far, far greater. As for "make up stuff about her," her comments regarding the Iraq war are on the record and are not fabricated.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by samstave on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:48PM (#7568294)
This is the lamest, most ignorant comment I have ever read on HN.
Re:Knuth: Open Letter to Condoleezza Rice (2002) by dec0dedab0de on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:46PM (#7568284)
I would have expected the same outrage if it were Dick Cheney or Donald Rumsfeld