News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:21AM (#7559812)
I have a q&a site with 4 million visitors a month - an ESL learning site. We have 2 employees, total cost <1 million :D - 1 million, even saying that makes me laugh. Completely coded by us from the ground up. This says https://siteanalytics.compete.com/quora.com/ they have only a million visitors a month??? - I'm guessing that must be wrong.

My question: What in pickled f*s are these people doing with 80 million on a Q&A site? How far out of the reach of reality is this industry?

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by fidotron on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:29AM (#7559878)
I've wondered along these lines too. There is clearly something else going on in the VC business beyond strictly evaluating company value based on ability to generate it directly. One factor I'll project (since I can't tell where you're based) is that companies with proven engineering staff in the Bay Area get a boost in inherent value just from acquihire potential. Bonus points for famous and connected founders, as Quora has.

Bay Area VC activity looks a lot like Wall Street to me, with the same disconnect between price and value happening.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:41AM (#7559965)
I'm nowhere near the 'bay area' or any US state, nor even in Europe. I'm British, but living abroad, have never known anyone else in the IT industry. HN is my only contact :)

When I hear and see the things people in SV say and do - I honestly wonder what the hell is going on out there. It seems people who can put a bit of html + css together are getting paid 10 million these days.

-- good luck to them and everything - but it's a bit mental (imho).

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hack_edu on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:50PM (#7562280)
Software is made by teams, and teams that can ship quality products and code consistently are invaluable. Few companies actually know how to ship product or complete projects, let alone succeed.

Early-stage companies are purchased/funded because their teams and not the checklist of experience on the team-members resumes. Successful, or even good products often take second-seat to this. Surprisingly enough, people pay boatloads for functional teams.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by pbreit on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:47PM (#7562253)
That sentiment could not be further from the truth. You could prove it to yourself simply by doing what you describe and seeing how far you get. Breaking through the noise and building a large, attractive user base is incredibly difficult. Sure, just building the web site isn't that hard (actually it is).
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by fidotron on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:11PM (#7562432)
I think you're right, but it's definitely the outside perception that something is odd about SV in this respect, and relatively trivial products can get blown out of all proportion there.

For me it was Cover, that Android launcher, that caused the confusion. The value of that is not in being able to develop it, because that aspect of it was trivial, but having the idea to do it, the vision to see it's possible, and the connections to get PR to get visibility for that in SV seems much more valuable than "just" the ability to execute. I think the surprising factor is just how valuable those intangibles can be judged to be. (Not saying they're not valuable, as they clearly are, but it's interesting just how much the VC market thinks they're worth, amplified by the effect if you happen to be in SV).

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by Retric on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:32PM (#7562153)
Most VC'S take ~20% of the money invested at the time of the investment. They also get a cut of the returns but there better off investing in crappy company's than sitting on the money. Sure, they do have to have some justification and can't say donate it to charity but as long as the fit is reasonable and there are no good options there going to pick something.

This is also on of the reasons they do separate funds. If 9/10 funds lose 50% of the money and one get's 500% returns they take a bug cut of that return despite only breaking even on average. It also explains why they don't care about small returns if a fund does not break even they don't care if it loses 1% or 99% they already have there cut and are not making any extra cash.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by pbreit on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:44PM (#7562234)
Not sure how you define value but Quora is creating quite a lot of it.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wankerrific on Saturday April 12, 2014 @12:27PM (#7578271)
Oh look more value:

http://www.quora.com/Family/I-caught-my-younger-brother-watc...

http://www.quora.com/How-does-a-sixteen-year-old-get-a-girlf...

Look - I don't care if Quora wants to spam my inbox with link bait in order to generate AU and page views, but they could at least not try to take the high road and pretend to be anything more than the lowest common denominator, no-business-model, spam factory that they are.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by jonathansizz on Thursday April 10, 2014 @12:25AM (#7564200)
Well, the experts they somehow get to donate their time, effort and knowledge for free are certainly creating value for the Quora execs.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wankerrific on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:54PM (#7562306)
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wpietri on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:43AM (#7559990)
It is a really good Q&A site.

I was a Quora Top Writer in 2012 and 2013, and I've also built a lot of web stuff and spent a lot of time studying web communities. Purely from a craftsmanship perspective, they've done an incredible job. The visual design, the interaction design, the writing and reading experiences, the social incentives, the notification system: all of it is top notch.

That said, I have never understood what their economic plan is. I have a very good understanding of the economics of content businesses, and the people at Quora are either incredible geniuses or totally nuts. Since they won't say how they plan to make money, we can't say. If I had to bet, It be "totally nuts", just because so many content businesses get seduced by a creative vision that current revenue streams just can't support. But having met some of them, I know they're very smart, so I am hoping that I am wrong and that they have some clever monetization strategy that will let them justify their very large valuation.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by webwright on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:26PM (#7560327)
"The visual design, the interaction design, the writing and reading experiences, the social incentives, the notification system: all of it is top notch."

I SO disagree here. It's a mess. It's 10x more complex than it needs to be. And it's horribly unapproachable for new/non-geeky users. I've had non-technical relatives sit down and try to use it who were positively baffled by the user-experience.

I think Quora is an example of what happens if you listen exclusively to your most active users, when you should be tempering that with conversations with new and drive-by users. The Curse of Knowledge is deadly for product designers (http://hbr.org/2006/12/the-curse-of-knowledge/ar/1).

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by techwatching on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:44PM (#7561396)
Agreed. Its always felt spammy to me - "Register to see more than the first answer." Why??
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by Smudge on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @03:33PM (#7561755)
Growth. It's spammy, but it works.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by techwatching on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @07:05PM (#7563129)
I guess. I would have agreed, except that Stack Overflow pointed the way. Quora feels like freaking Experts Exchange to me.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by Detrus on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @03:41PM (#7561810)
As a power user I really liked the early iterations of the UI. But it went downhill for me around the time they added posts. They added a lot of spammy follow crap too.

The quality of content is hard to manage. There's no granularity in rating content, but when the content persists, isn't meant to be forgotten like HN comments, that's a serious flaw. Answers and wikis should be gradually improved, voted on per edit, etc.

I agree that when you're not in editor/contributor mode there is too much going on. There should be a separate browsing and contributing UX.

Simplifying all UIs for the lowest common denominator is not the way. Bicycles vs tricycles argument of Doug Engelbart and Alan Kay.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wpietri on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @10:09PM (#7563778)
I think one's opinions on the UI depend a lot on what the perceived audience is. If they're really after random internet users, then yes, I think it's too complex. But I think their initial play has been for that small slice of people who contribute content, vote extensively, and comment usefully. Because those are the people you need to generate a very large base of content, which is necessary to draw in the people who are going to do the ad-clicking to pay for it.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by gagaga on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:50PM (#7561446)
Definitely agree. Some of the stuff is just terribly confusing and very visually dense.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by return0 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:00PM (#7561945)
Am I the only one who sees none of this "top notch system"? Last time i used it it felt clunky* , now every time i get a search result to them on a random computer, they ask me to login to read the answer, experts-exchange-style. Thanks, but no thanks.

PS. I guess the people who find this useful live in San Francisco, and enjoy the "insider" feel.

*: Right now, while viewing any question while logged out, the "Continue with facebook" button text wraps outside the button.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wpietri on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @10:12PM (#7563785)
If you haven't logged in, then I think yes, you're not seeing it. As a power user, I think they've done a great job. As I mention elsewhere, I think that their initial focus is the power users, because those are the people who have been creating the content they need if they are going to attract regular users.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wmeredith on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:51PM (#7562284)
Seriously. They are the new experts exchange to me. I consider their presence in my search results a nuisance.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by return0 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:16PM (#7562471)
I believe if it was any other website, google would penalize them for spamming their results. But it's not happening due to silicon valley nepotism.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:45AM (#7560011)
I do like their simple form and layout, they have indeed got an elegant site. Nice piece of UX engineering without a doubt.

There can't (in my v. humble opinion) be any realistic way of recouping 80 million from a Q&A site. They would surely need to be extremely aggressive at the least.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wpietri on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:00PM (#7560122)
Yeah. Having served some time in the magazine industry, there's a common pattern there:

You decide to make something way better than the existing alternatives. Your smart and literary friends tell you it's a great idea, because they want something better too. You find inexperienced investors with the same vision, and present them with early samples that make them say, "Yes! This awesome! Let me invest in your vision." Then you start shipping, and the small fraction of the population that isn't satisfied with mid-market stuff signs up and praises you. You're not profitable, but everybody is so excited that you keep going, possibly for years, getting new investor money and never selling as much as you hope.

Basically, it's like making a quirky indie film and thinking it will be a $500m blockbuster because you and your friends love it so. My fear is that Quora's on exactly the same path. That this new chunk of money comes from an outsider, Tiger Global, worries me further.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by jgalt212 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:49PM (#7561434)
I think Stack Overflow definitely can, but mostly because it has a very high value audience that can be monetized through ad sales and and its job posting biz.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by not_paul_graham on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:07PM (#7560179)
I know that $140 million sounds like a lot, but when they IPO after rejecting the 2 billion acquisition offer from Google, Goldman Sachs will peddle QUOR to institutional investors, and surely they will be able to recoup the $140 million investment + a 10x return if the stock pops. </sarcasm>

On a more serious note, Quora users have a better profile for advertisers because they are likely to be in the top brackets for income and education and unlike an English Q&A site the topics on Quora are limitless. You could target ads at 20-40 year females that have a PhD and live in New York very easily.

Also from the looks of it the decision might not purely be for financial gains. Adam D'Angelo is apparently one of the smartest people around (as referenced by Mark Zuckerberg in some interview) and also independently wealthy so keeping yourself in his good graces might lead to future positive outcomes not entirely related to Quora.

Also Tiger Global is run by a youngish hedge fund manager born into old school money family and he probably pals around in the same circles as Zuckerberg, Adam D'Angelo, Charlie Cheever, other young SV entrepreneurs with FU money and this seems a lot like friends helping friends (this is just a hypothesis which might not be true).

It can also be that the investors know something compelling that we don't know or are hoping that Quora will be the next big social thing after Facebook / Pinterest / Twitter / etc.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:41PM (#7560428)
That all makes sense, I would disagree on one point:

"topics on Quora are limitless"

The thing (only based on my experience) is that when you grow/diversify too much on a Q&A site, quality tends to dilute, and the audience tends to drop off. I don't know if this is true for Quora; I merely suspect it might be (as it has been for all the others who tried).

In many ways our focus on just one topic has been our saving grace. Many 'globals' try to compete (even S.E.) few manage to top 'specialisation'. Not sure why.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by not_paul_graham on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:51PM (#7560512)
My question is completely off topic, but I have some questions regarding your site, if you don't mind answering:

How long have you been operating englishforums.com ? Is this your full time engagement?

How did you grow it to the 4 million+ number ? Was it purely organic or some paid advertising ?

And is the site profitable?

Thanks.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Thursday April 10, 2014 @01:19AM (#7564325)
Hi not paul,

And is the site profitable?

I started it in 2002. It's part of my full time engagement. It's paid my way since 2006.

There has never been any business model. Adsense only, yes it's profitable - we pay the 3 of us from that - but only because our costs are so low (single server, I've optimised the code to handle itself on an 8 core with 24gb - it runs at about 10% usage, @ about 10 requests a second)

How did you grow it to the 4 million+ number

We knew what Google wanted, we knew what our visitors wanted. We put our visitors first, but made sure the entire site worked in a way that would help Google do its job. (never really SEO). Our design is lacking, we didn't have a designer - we do now (very exciting for us!)

Essentially we predicted for many years what Google would be looking for, did some things ahead of other folks and tried our best to keep the quality of our content high. We also created a very friendly (most of the time) atmosphere on our site and encouraged high-quality posters to stick around - as much as we could. A lot of sites copied us, but missed the concept of keeping the community conducive to friendly interaction. We also did some interesting things to keep out trolls. Like our 'ghost' mode which makes a troll thing they've annoyed everyone, when in actual fact they're being system-level ignored. Fun stuff like that. This reduced further our overhead, and allowed us to expand while not worrying so much about spam. We spent time to build a system that self-managed, and self-grew. That seemed to work.

That's all the old system, what we've created now is far more interesting.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by majani on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @06:10PM (#7562824)
Quora's largest source of traffic is a third world country, India(source is Gawker, which is blocked on HN)

As harsh as this will sound, that automatically puts it into the garbage pile of advertiser profiles. They are never getting 80mil out this deal.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by wpietri on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:45AM (#7560005)
As an aside, I am delighted that there are 4 million people learning English from somebody who uses the phrase "pickled fucks". They are, and I mean this sincerely, in very good hands.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:53AM (#7560061)
Lol, cheers! OFC The last person you want teaching English is a coder. I have many thousands of volunteers to help with that ;)

For the first 3 months of our site (before help came) 'grammar' was spelt wrong on the header.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by Smirnoff on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:10PM (#7562003)
Here is my theory:

Most likely this huge investment is a way for investors to get their money from their previous investment, which might be locked up due to some contract rules.

Basically, in order to free their funds (or avoid taxation) from their first investment (let's say from some portfolio company of Benchmark/or other participated investors), they will transfer funds from the big company to the small company aka Quora (in which these investors got a better contract).

I am not going to be surprised if Quora gets acquired from the bigger company, which happens to have the same investors ;)

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by webwright on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:22PM (#7560304)
First off, Compete.com is a JOKE (I've regularly seen it off by 10-100x). Second, investors care about growth more than traffic-- do we have any data on Quora's growth? Third, Quora's founder/team is pretty bankable-- a failure scenario for them is an $80M acqui-hire. Assuming preferred shares or liquidation prefs by the new investors, that almost entirely de-risks this investment. That coupled with their long term ambition (supplant Wikipedia?) makes this a non-terrible bet.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by shitgoose on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:48PM (#7562265)
"How to boil water?" [http://www.quora.com/How-do-you-boil-water] - supplant Wikipedia???
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by davidgerard on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @06:28PM (#7562927)
Wikipedia doesn't want your Facebook login before you can read the answer.

Seriously, any talk of Wikipedia around Quora is strictly Quora's wishful thinking. This will never happen.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by sixQuarks on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:27PM (#7561259)
First, you have a great site! congratulations.

Second, there is no way Quora only gets 1.5 million visitors per month. They have an Alexa ranking in the 400s. Yes, the tech audience skews this, but even a tech-heavy audience can't skew it that badly. Getting in the top 500 of Alexa is very, very difficult.

My guess is that they get at least 10 million visitors per month.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by AznHisoka on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @03:12PM (#7561603)
I disagree. MyFitnessPal is in the top rankings in Alexa, and they get less than that. Add to to fact that tech is more skewed, I wager they get a bit less than a million a month.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:21PM (#7562508)
Thanks!!

re: alexa reference: we had hit 5,000-ish on alexa a while back (then google had some fun with Q&A sites) - at that level we were getting around 180,000 uniques a day. 40k was the difference between 7000 and 5000 on alexa, it's also not as 'exponential' as one might think.

I previously would assume more than 10 mill a month, but I tend to imagine the guys above me must be 'rolling in traffic'. 10 is probably closest.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by RivieraKid on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:42PM (#7562661)
I also don't understand the 80million (perhaps rich people don't know where to put their money?).

But Quora is definitely not just another Q&A site.

First, they have incredibly good technology. I would say that their livenode/webnode2 framework is one of the (or the) most technologically advanced web frameworks in existence. (Although now that React exists, it should be relatively easy to create something even better than what Quora has.) Also, I like their deployment process - they auto-deploy on every commit if tests run flawlessly. And their CEO is pretty smart (http://www.quora.com/Adam-DAngelo-1/What-are-some-good-stori...).

Second, there's lot of very valuable and high quality content. I've learned a lot from Quora.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by return0 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:11PM (#7562009)
Great tech people often make mediocre or bad investments, or invest in things that are not really worth their time in the end. Things like, Max Levchin creating slide.

It's just that the amounts being available to invest are so staggering in SV compared to other places, that any movement of money will look huge in comparison. That makes news like this sound infuriatingly irrational. Also, i guess the facebook link is important.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by ulfw on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:02PM (#7561016)
Wasn't Quora hot like years ago when it came out? Do you guys actively use it?
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by smackfu on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:40AM (#7559960)
Consider that Quora basically forces mobile users to access the site via their app.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by balladeer on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @12:53PM (#7560535)
And it's like a parasite. It's takes everything from users for free but it never lets the outside world see the content without a Quora account.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by pbreit on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:52PM (#7562296)
...without a [free] Quora account.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by majani on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @05:40PM (#7562645)
if it were anywhere else in the world, we'd immediately be calling it out for exactly what it is: barefaced corruption amongst the incestuous VCs. But since the Valley has convinced many that it's the meritocratic mecca for formerly maligned nerds, we scratch our heads trying to preserve that image while the truth lies right in front of you.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by akc on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:24AM (#7559836)
what's your site?
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:25AM (#7559847)
Can I PM that to you?
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by hitchhiker999 on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @11:39AM (#7559955)
sod it - cant find PM on HN. www.englishforums.com (that's the old version, we're updating in a couple of months)
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by mknits on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @01:52PM (#7560952)
Really americans are fucking idiots. They think whatever they think and use is correct! Stupid assholes.

So if americans use some otherwise popular qna website much less, they think it's foolish to spend 80 million fucking dollars on that.

Enjoy the fucking kickstarter.

Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by dang on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @02:06PM (#7561045)
Please don't post comments like this to Hacker News. They violate the two most important values of the site: substance and civility.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by kumarski on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @03:32PM (#7561754)
How you stay so aggressively on top of all comments amazes me.
Re:Quora collects $80 million in funding by shitgoose on Wednesday April 09, 2014 @04:51PM (#7562288)
He's got a filter on "Americans fucking idiots". Never fails.