we should be encouraging people to drive fewer miles
To do this we basically need denser neighborhoods, as Edward Glaeser points out in The Triumph of the City (http://www.amazon.com/Triumph-City-Greatest-Invention-Health... he points out, as does Matt Yglesias in The Rent is Too Damn High, that the big problems are with local zoning requirements, which by and large forbid density increases.
There are lots of local battles going on regarding density, and I agree that these are good things: "living closer to where you work, using mass transit, biking, and walking more," but they can all be encourage or discouraged by zoning. In most of America they're discouraged.
In the meantime better mileage is at least an improvement.
https://www.flickr.com/photos/12588351@N02/sets/721576231926...
If half the land set aside for cars were instead converted into public parks, you could have the benefits of nature in the city.
What's your threshold for where a house becomes a "McMansion?" What would you think of ~1200sqft, two stories with a basement, with a good yard?
Still, the internet can significantly reduce peoples need to drive because package delivery can be much more efficient than driving to a shopping mall.
This is always an interesting aspect of the zoning debate to me. People who prefer to live in suburbs often seem to oppose zoning that allows densification. But if more development were allowed in cities, there would be less pressure to densify the suburbs. Seems like it would be a win-win for both lifestyle preferences.
Besides, many suburbanites work or take entertainment in the city, where they get utility from the city services.
Because of progressive taxation and the fact you have to pay people a lot more to live in dense cities. Any time you want to propose a flat tax you'll have my support.
But you miss the point: a large fraction of those suburban dwellers work and get paid in the city. Cities like London have literally millions of daily commuters.
Money flows out of cities because they contain a lot of taxpayers that consume resources efficiently. Collecting the garbage from a 200-unit condo building is way cheaper than visiting 200 houses in a suburban subdivision. Yet the dollar value of the house and condo are similar and they pay similar taxes. If the city condo dweller works at the next desk to commuting suburbanite, they get paid the same and pay the same taxes. The suburbanite costs more to service and consumes more energy, etc.
Also, cities have a higher ratio of taxpayers to non-taxpayers. There are fewer kids and retirees living there, for example.
I'm not against suburbs at all. Often a great place to live, particularly with kids. But it's helpful to understand their costs.
Yes, and they use fewer services than locals. They also pay transportation-related fees (commuters are a gold mine for San Francisco), and sometimes even income taxes (as in NYC). Hell, New York forces you to pay city income taxes if you telecommute to a company there even if you never set foot in the city.
In my local big city the two biggest budget items are "protection" (police and fire, mostly) and "health and welfare". Commuters don't require police or fire protection in the evenings, and they don't use the local methadone clinic. They don't use residential services either, which tend to be subsidized by businesses.
>Money flows out of cities because they contain a lot of taxpayers that consume resources efficiently. Collecting the garbage from a 200-unit condo building is way cheaper than visiting 200 houses in a suburban subdivision. Yet the dollar value of the house and condo are similar and they pay similar taxes. If the city condo dweller works at the next desk to commuting suburbanite, they get paid the same and pay the same taxes. The suburbanite costs more to service and consumes more energy, etc.
Suburban people pay the cost of their own trash pickup, as well as other utilities. At least where I live these kinds of services are done on a city-by-city contract basis, so nobody is subsidizing the water, trash, communications, or sewer for my suburban city. And yet, I pay less than the local urban people do, which implies it's not as efficient to provide services to built-up areas as proponents claim.
I work at a mobile provider, and for us urban customers cost many times what the suburban customers do. Everything in cities is crazy expensive, the permitting process always takes longer, and you can never put things where you want to put them. When I want to do a drive test it takes forever because of traffic, and people who work in the city have to be paid more. If I want to open a storefront for customer service the rent is many times what I pay in the suburbs.
Everyone who's providing services has to be running into the same sorts of costs.
>Also, cities have a higher ratio of taxpayers to non-taxpayers. There are fewer kids and retirees living there, for example.
That's because high density cities are too expensive to raise children or take care of grandpa. This is a counter-argument to the one you're trying to make, as it implies cities are forcing suburbs to take people who aren't a net tax benefit.
>I'm not against suburbs at all. Often a great place to live, particularly with kids. But it's helpful to understand their costs.
Yes, well, my argument is the costs you've enumerated are being paid by the people who incur them. Usually people who try to claim cities are subsidizing suburbs lean on highways, which are normally paid on a regional or national basis. But that argument rests on the fanciful notion that when California builds a highway between Los Angeles and San Francisco it's primarily a benefit to the people in the Central Valley.
Just as we have mile-per-gallon ratings for city driving, highway, etc, we could have mile-per-day ratings for different lifestyles, based on how much you eat out, whether you have children, whether you cycle, etc.
Commuting distance might be tricky to incorporate, as there are a wide range of places you might work. If you live in Guildford, then if you work in Guildford, your commuting distance could be 3 miles, but if you work in central London, it could be 30 miles. Perhaps that falls into the classification of lifestyles as well. Perhaps we just exclude commuting as too variable.
If we knew how long it took to get to places, we could make this measure in the time domain rather than the distance domain - minutes per day. Say you work for Google in London. If you live opposite East Croydon station, your commute is 11.3 miles by road, and takes 16 minutes on the train. If you live opposite Wallington station, your commute is 11.1 miles by road, but takes 38 minutes on the train.
While the technological advancement is pretty much a universal win, the behavioral change isn't, or is at least debatable/not everyone's cup of tea - a lot of Americans prefer to live in large houses with lower density neighborhoods (of course others prefer large dense cities). Many also live in rural or semi-rural areas, and the US has a lot of cheap land compared to say Western Europe. Zoning in a city is dictated by those residents. However with better technology and cheaper energy, the expense of this lifestyle will be lowered and allow more choices (similar to how remote work allows people to remove geographical limitations). If we think about developing countries, any efficiency gains will also reduce their energy impact as consumption increases
People do seem to misinterpret MPG ratings. A study published in Science in 2008 [1] found that participants consistently overvalued vehicles with high MPG ratings. They assigned values linear in MPG rather than linear in its inverse.
The study's authors told participants to "assume you drive 10,000 miles per year for work, and this total amount cannot be changed." The participants were then asked to come up with values for vehicles of varying fuel-efficiencies. That is just the sort of optimization problem people face when choosing which car to buy, and apparently a fuel-efficiency metric that puts the amount of fuel in the numerator makes the problem easier to solve because expenditure is proportional to the amount of fuel burned, at least when distance driven is taken as given.
But in reading many of the words expended on this topic over the last couple of years, my lasting impression is that this a lot of hullabaloo about the wrong problem. It's the lack of attention paid to the "miles" part of the equation that most needs fixing. If the goal is to reduce carbon emissions (or any of the other negative externalities of driving), then taking distance driven as fixed frames the problem in a way that obscures the real solution: we should be encouraging people to drive less.
Yes, reordering your daily life to drive fewer miles is more disruptive than simply buying a car that goes farther on a gallon of gas. And, granted, once you've chosen your style of life, minimizing the amount of gas you burn as you go about your daily routine is the thing to do (even if your optimization problem is a purely financial one). All the same, it's ludicrous to ignore the basic inefficiency of the suburban lifestyle that predominates in America while we wait for automotive engineers to come up with clever solutions to pricey gas and to carbon emissions that are twice as high per capita as in similarly wealthy countries.
Elon Musk isn't going to save us all by himself. Surely living closer to where you work, using mass transit, cycling, and walking more must be part of the solution as well. ... So maybe houses and apartments should come with a "miles per day" rating suggesting how far you'd travel getting to and from shops, restaurants, entertainment venues, and your place of work every day you live there. ...
0. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4020885
1. http://www.sciencemag.org/content/320/5883/1593.summary (paywalled); http://nsmn1.uh.edu/dgraur/niv/theMPGIllusion.pdf [PDF]