Lewis has a drive-by mention of bid-ask spreads in the book (he concedes that they've been decimated, while asserting without evidence that HFT has created a new "shadow spread"), and, thus far, no mention whatsoever of the mechanics of large-block trades. In Lewis' universe, a hedge fund can unload 100,000 shares of XYZ just as easily as you can sell 10 shares of AAPL.
To your point: what's missing is the hedging costs. The reason block trades trade out of the market is not just that they are "bespoke", but that there is the inventory hedge risk. It may take some time to build up a position (during which prices can move adversely). And this may or may not need a hedge to protect the holding period (which someone needs to pay for).
Various types of trading strategies have very different risk profiles when compared to required inventory hold/periods etc. And this is a hidden source of economics or cost. Hedging doesn't always scale well, either.
So its very hard (especially as a lay-person) to make inferences about many things unless you are taking into account both profits and risk. As I'm sure you know.
Read reviews of the book from traders and you will see lots of people scratching their heads the same way I am.
It is confusing that a former bond salesman, who wrote several famous vignettes about how Salomon got its clients into jams by selling them blocks of bonds and having the market move out from under them, would believe the things he appears to believe about RBC's role in the market.
In Lewis' universe, a $2MM/yr sell-side broker accepts a 100,000 share block order from a hedge fund, consults a single blotter screen, enters a 100,000 share order, and is startled and outraged when that order isn't as easy to place as an Amazon one-click order. Egads! The broker has to actually work for his money! Kill the HFTs!
I don't understand what inventory hedging has to do with the point I'm making. Hedge trades are trades. Large hedge trades involve block shopping.
The underlying cause is the "perverse incentive" (Lewis's words) of the taker-rebate (reverse of the usual maker-rebate taker-fee). Is there a sensible reason to such a fee structure? Or is it just useful for HFT firms to bait orders and get an informational edge they can exploit against mom & pop's retirement fund?
The same should be asked about esoteric order types (Hide-n-Slide, Post-only, etc). Its cleary a complex landscape with middle ground, but it would be surprising if there weren't cabals and conspiracies hiding in obscure corners.
ELI5 version is that you need to pay for (1) working capital. This scales with the size of the block (capital cost). You also need to pay for (2) some lead-gen fees to get the block (service cost). You also have to pay for (3) a hedge on economics while your lead-gen process play's out. The cost of this hedge scales with size (just like capital cost), but also with vol (of underlying) and time (speed of lead gen process).
If you don't cut the deal to cover your hedge (or put one on) you run the risk of massive losses from mino movemnets in the market (ie, if you have a <1% cent spread on 5 mill position and the stock spikes 10%).
So a trade's profits:
(A) scale+fees = Revenues
(B) capital+hedge = Costs
Both the hedge and the capital are proportionate to time.
TLDR when you talk about HFT you are optimizing on time; and thus talking about (B) as much as (A) in terms of profits. Most of the optimization is on (B).
What's unique here is that (B) is blind to the casual observer and to some extent, the market.
But analytically, it influences profits and drives behaviour/incentive structure.
If you dis-regard it out of hand, you're missing an important part of the picture.
You might think you can fill 100,000 @ $10 and allegedly many people did. In fact if the exchanges were consolidated into one you would be filled.
It seems to me a displayed order should be able to be traded and not behave in a seemingly prescient way by disappearing when the order is made.
In an ideal world would the latency between exchanges serve any beneficial purpose?
The reality is that electronic trading systems have different values for all of those variables. I've worked on a trading system that only traded 4 times a week, had no human operator, but extremely tight latency requirements.
I've also worked on a system that did very high volume of trades every day, that was watched like a hawk by a team of human traders, and didn't much care about latency.
A firm simply unloading thousands of shares in 100 block increments in a number of milliseconds with very low latency technically would be a bunch of "high frequency" trades, but that type of activity is not what is being debated.
Mark Cuban misunderstands a lot of things, including Dennis Rodman and High Frequency Trading.
One side: "HFT hurts the little guy and helps billionaires! Boo HFT!"
The other side: "HFT helps the little guy and hurts billionaires! Yea HTF!"
Reality: "HFT is pretty much irrelevant to the little guy. It helps some billionaires and hurts other billionaires, and this is only a story because billionaires are all talking about it."
This trade used to be extremely lucrative. I was there. It was awesome. Years ago the ETF and basket NAV would cross one another constantly and you could build a fully-hedged position for a profit if you were extremely fast. People still make money on it, but not as a pure speed arb. Like everything else, the fastest traders and those who execute best win. The fact that it's not as lucrative or easy anymore is indication that the markets have become so much more efficient.
So instead of this rent (amount of money X) getting all captured by a single player who is necessarily a large, wealthy trader, it gets divided up more broadly. That sounds like a textbook case of arbitrage being in the public good.
HFT does that. Does it also do other things which create rents rather than break them up? Hard for me to say. It's a complicated subject.
What do you think traders get paid in, cupcakes?
Michael Lewis is a master of taking something complicated and turning it into a clever narrative. However, this narrative is simpler than, say, Moneyball: bad guys are "stealing" from good guys, there's a detective story about figuring out how it's happening, and there's a build-a-better-mousetrap montage at the end. It's too perfect. Odds are there's a screenwriter crunching this sucker down into three acts right at this moment.
Proper investing, buying a stock in the belief it will go up massively over the course of many years is trivially affected by HFTs. You may pay less than a penny per share extra on trades, but if you're looking for tens of dollars of capital gain do you care?
Instead, Joe Sixpack eats his chilli at another store that is more competent in managing their supply chain, and the Wendy's Corporate takes a hit.
Source: some Matt Levine article.
I don't think it's helpful to anyone's understanding of any situation to try to pretend that tens or hundreds of millions of Americans -- who are on the whole somewhat wealthier than average -- are mega-rich snobs who drink ten-thousand-dollar-a-bottle wine.
1) Indirectly via mutual funds, pension funds, and so on.
2) Directly through buying individual stocks on E*Trade or the like.
The second amounts to an expensive hobby (in risk adjusted terms). Whether some people who aren't ultra-rich choose to indulge in such an expensive hobby is neither here nor there, the underlying fact remains that there's no good reason to care about or optimize for their benefit. Yet for some reason so many articles on this subject instead of talking about the funds that are broadly and rationally held, analyze the situation for the small retail investor.
http://www.csmonitor.com/Business/2013/0508/Dow-hits-15000-b...
The rate of stock ownership (including through mutual funds and retirement accounts) for Americans is around 52%, down from last year. So, while the median American owns some stock, it's probably a minuscule amount. Two percentage points lower, and the median American (Joe Six Pack) owns no stock.
EDIT for more related info:
45% of Americans have no retirement savings [1]
1/4 of Americans have no savings whatsoever [2]
[1] http://www.twincities.com/ci_23505006/americans-retirement-s...
[2] http://www.ibtimes.com/over-fourth-americans-have-no-money-t...
Plus, the interviews he's given on 60 minutes and Fresh Air never once mention the terms "market order" or "limit order". If you don't explain those two basic terms at the heart of the HFT controversy, you're not giving people information, you're only giving them disinformation.
That said, there's obviously lots of shady ass shit happening on Wall Street every day, but Michael Lewis is not helping the situation one iota, from the looks of it.