No, that would involve a very complicated and expensive breaking maneuver to slow down the spacecraft, not to mention getting in exactly the right orbit to rendezvous with the ISS. It's much, much easier to just the payload sturdy enough to survive atmospheric entry and a crash landing.
(Sorry, normally I wouldn't nitpick spelling when the meaning is clear, it was just a funny error!)
I know, I know, budgets. It'll 'never' happen.
But what if we just send a nano-factory with its own assembly/disassembly abilities? Feasible, 5 - 10 years on from now?
Well anyway, the point is: why bring it back, really? Just send more machines to do better jobs in space.
(that is, the probe as whole can still orbit the sun in the same direction as the planet, it just needs to do it slower.
(ducks)
Regarding planetary contamination, with the amount of meteorites hitting ocean I do not think we have anything to worry about.
The amount of oxygen in the atmosphere helps a lot. The onset of photosynthesis caused a mass extinction ~two billion years ago.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Great_Oxygenation_Event
I love that name. It sounds like some kind of a party.
But regarding your last sentence: I'm not very fond of that risk analysis. Potentially introducing an alien aquatic micro-organism (that's what we hope to bring back, remember) into earth's system... No competition, paradise compared to its hostile home. No meteorite has ever been shown to carry life, but into this case we intend to deliberately introduce it, either controlled or uncontrolled.
NASA can bill me for the extra cost for taking it to ISS instead of earth's surface.
A life form which evolved in a (relatively) low-energy environment (low temperature, low light level, lower pressure) is more in hell than in a paradise. Earth organism evolved to make the best of available resources on Earth, be it energy or materials; the organism would be teared apart in no-time.
That is, unless it is a highly intelligent and evolved life form with big environment alteration capacities, but then it might already be a problem, just one we aren't aware of.
I'm surprised that we aren't equally worried about contaminating Enceladus with terran microbes.
Get FAR, RSS, Deadly Rentry, put your space station somewhere around 50 degrees inclination, then try it with suitably small probe. The Stardust spacecraft was 300kg; the sample return capsule was 46kg and reentered at nearly 13km/s.
Just one full small kerbal RCS tank puts you at 250kg, so you'll need to nearly empty that just for starters...
I don't think that would be a real risk. Earth life has spent billions of years both adapting and adapting to the environment to make it the best growing medium and even then it exists in exclusive bands. For example, put a polar bear in the desert or a fresh water fish in salt water. It is more likely that we would have to take extreme care not to kill any lifeforms we brought back than to worry about them killing us.
- rabbits/cane toads in Australia [0][1]
- Japanese knotweed [2]
- Tumbleweed (yep, not as native as Hollywood suggests) [3]
- Algae [4]
... and the list goes on and on, here's a top-100:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_the_world%27s_100_worst...
[0] http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pgPhn4tYxJQ
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cane_toads_in_Australia
[2] http://www.environment-agency.gov.uk/homeandleisure/wildlife...
The challenges are to make sure that the interesting particles would not break apart, to take precautions that any alien life would not infect Earth, and to fit it into the $500 million budget of one of NASA’s lower-cost planetary missions."
Why bring it back to earth? Wouldn't it be safer & less expensive to return it to ISS instead, (or is that what's implied) ?
Didn't know the carbon & nitrogen part of the story, read the article thinking only 1 thing: "when are you going to mention Europa".