News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:21PM (#7525425)
I would have considered him a worse person if he'd done that. I disagree with his opinions on marriage, but he has the right to have those opinions, and to provide support for causes he believes in.

I'm not shocked the he is stepping down, or that others in the organization appear to have applied substantial pressure on him to do so, but it makes me sad. Their statements about supporting freedom of speech are hollow: the community has pressured him to step down because he expressed an opinion not held by the majority.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by blisterpeanuts on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:34PM (#7525633)
Ironically, though, his opinion was supported by the majority in that California election: 7 million to 6.4 million in favor of Prop 8.

I guess if they consider any other candidates for CEO from California, they'll have to ask them how they voted.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by thinkpad20 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:46PM (#7525783)
The majority that voted. Those in favor were more likely to go out and vote than those opposed. Many of the opinion polls showed that more people were opposed, but clearly not enough of them actually went to the ballot.

Either way, I'm confident that the same measure today would have a snowball's chance in hell of passage.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by blisterpeanuts on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:08PM (#7526086)
That's the way democracy works, though. If about 320,000 more conservative voters had turned out to vote in several swing states in 2012, we'd have a different President in the White House.

That doesn't mean Romney should have won, though. It's the people who turn out to vote who get to decide. If you don't care enough to vote, tough beans!

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by yohui on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:54PM (#7526554)
> That's the way democracy works, though.

> It's the people who turn out to vote who get to decide. If you don't care enough to vote, tough beans!

Democracies with more complete voter participation don't seem generally worse off for it.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @05:04PM (#7526651)
I don't think anyone is disagreeing with that. The point being made is that the people who come to vote are the ones who make the decisions. If people are being prevented from casting their votes, that is a serious problem, but if people choose not to exercise their right to vote then whatever vote they would have cast doesn't count towards the outcome.

Saying that a vote would have gone differently if more people on the losing side voted is obvious. It's also not constructive, except in the context of wishing more people would participate in the political process in the future. Amusingly (or perhaps not), the fervor against Brendan Eich is based in large part around his participation in that process.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by yohui on Thursday April 03, 2014 @06:29PM (#7527459)
I agree that in practice elections are won by those who manage to cast their ballots, but I disagree with the notion that this is not a defect but rather how democracy ought to work.

I'm all for the option to not vote, but I want it to be a choice. I think the current setup provides the wrong incentives: it encourages politicians to care about how they can rouse up enough to come to the polls or demoralize enough to keep away, in addition to or at the expense of reaching out to all constituents. We can change this either through cultural or legal means, but the legal way is faster and not demonstrably harmful.

Greater participation is far from a panacea, of course. It may even introduce its own particular ills (e.g. takes longer to change the status quo). But I hardly think it would make no difference at all. That's why I pointed to other democracies with better voting records, to show that overall democracy isn't harmed by more voting.

See: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Voter_turnout#International_di...

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by SimHacker on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:53PM (#7525890)
So you're saying it was wrong for the Supreme Court to strike down bans on mixed race marriages because at the time an overwhelming majority of Americans were against it?

Why do you think human rights should be put up for a vote? Are you against mixed race marriage because it was so unpopular at the time the "activist court" struck it down?

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by mkr-hn on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:41PM (#7525731)
How can it be a right if it's subject to a majority vote?
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by icebraining on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:00PM (#7525977)
All rights are subject to majority vote. Or subject to the majority, anyway.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by matthewn on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:08PM (#7526091)
No, rights are manifestly NOT subject to a vote. That is why they are called rights.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:19PM (#7526213)
That is the case in an ideal world, where we receive some blessed words inscribed upon our souls and also a way to read them.

Since we don't live in that ideal world, our only option is to designate some body to decide what are rights and what are not. Whether that body is a king or a judge or a council of judges or a legislative body or the full populace (or some combination of the above) is an important and worthwhile discussion, but in the end we do need to designate some entity to decide what the rights are.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by mkr-hn on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:20PM (#7526226)
Fortunately, that entity sits above California's voters.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:52PM (#7526537)
Except the population votes for the people who pick the members of that entity.

We've added a few hops, and hopefully increased the average intelligence of the people who get to decide on rights, but they still end up there based on the population's vote.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by hkphooey on Thursday April 03, 2014 @05:00PM (#7526611)
Is marriage a civil right, or even a fundamental human right? On closer examination, the answer appears to be NO.

The campaign for gay marriage, branded as marriage equality, actually leaves many people behind.

Brothers can't marry sisters, mothers can't marry sons (nice way to avoid inheritance tax!), men and women can't join in a polygamous marriage even though there is a long history of polygamy in many cultures around the world.

It's quite ironic that the campaign for marriage equality is itself highly discriminatory.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by blisterpeanuts on Thursday April 03, 2014 @10:47PM (#7528868)
You left out bestiality.

(which I've never understood why it wasn't spelled "beastiality")

I guess the rationale for specifically bestowing marital rights on same-sex (but non-related) spouses is that there's a significant number of them.

Polygamy, too, there might be a lot of that somewhere in the world, possibly Africa, obscure corners of Utah, certainly pre-modern China when it was normal for a wealthy land owner to have several wives, etc. I suspect it won't be long before polygamy is legalized. Maybe a couple of decades at most.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by icebraining on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:16PM (#7526178)
Reality disagrees.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by matthewn on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:21PM (#7526240)
No, it doesn't: Californians passed a proposition that violated people's rights. The courts, playing their proper role in our system, said, "Nope, you can't do that." That's what happened; that's reality.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by icebraining on Thursday April 03, 2014 @07:35PM (#7527917)
The courts played the role that the majority allowed them to play, just like they did for the hundreds of years during which even same-sex sexual activity was illegal, let alone gay marriage.

Like a diet that sometimes prevents people from eating what they crave, the system is nothing more than a mechanism of self-control for the majority.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by baddox on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:55PM (#7525901)
What's the other option? One person, or a small elite group, deciding the list of "rights"?
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by scintill76 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @05:48PM (#7527138)
> I guess if they consider any other candidates for CEO from California, they'll have to ask them how they voted.

Interesting. The difference between which box you check, and giving money to influence other people to check a certain box. The privacy of the former is a nearly-sacred privilege, while the latter is not allowed to be private. And I do tend to agree with campaign finance disclosure, but the double-standard is interesting. To be consistent, will we have to make all voting records public?

Would there be outrage if there were political questionnaires for employment/promotion like this? If proof of lying was found, would there be more outrage over the lie; or over violating privacy to find out about the lie?

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by stiles on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:36PM (#7526391)
Please remember that part of the reason many voted in favor of Prop 8 was because of the amount of money raised in donations allowed a massive ad campaign that was full of lies and deceit.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by cglee on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:26PM (#7525524)
Not sure why people always bring up "freedom of speech" in these types of scenarios. You can say what you want without going to jail; that's freedom of speech. It doesn't mean you won't feel social consequences.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by Aloha on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:39PM (#7525708)
I'm an openly gay male, I came out at 15.

Why should there be social or employment consequences - in my mind this is just as bad as when employers fire employees for being gay.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dalke on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:16PM (#7526177)
http://www.popehat.com/2013/09/10/speech-and-consequences/ describes it well:

> Speech is designed to invoke private and social consequences, whether the speech is "venti mocha no whip, please," or "I love you," or "fuck off." The private and social consequences of your speech — whether they come from a barista, or your spouse, or people online, or people at whom you shout on the street — represent the free speech and freedom of association of others.

> Yet people often confuse these categories.

I believe you are making the same confusion between the right of free speech - Eich can support a political position - and the freedom of association so employees of Mozilla and OKCupid need not be associated with a company that has Eich at its head. (In the employees' case, the right to quit.)

There can be and is a tension there. As a country we have said that the right of free association is limited while at work, and that certain factors - race, religion, country of origin, etc. - cannot be used to discriminate between employees. But other factors, like disrupting the office every hour on the hour for a boisterous rendition of the National Anthem, can be grounds for punitive action.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by Aloha on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:18AM (#7529982)
Exercising Freedom of Speech and Association shouldn't open one up to trial by public opinion - we did this once before, McCarthyism and the blacklist in the 50's - I'd rather not see us ever return to an era where there are bogymen lurking in the corners.

As much as I strongly disagree with the Prop 8 folks, I think resorting to trying them in the court of public opinion is fundamentally wrong.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dalke on Friday April 04, 2014 @09:41AM (#7531280)
Could you tell me how 'trial by public opinion' in this case is different than a call for a boycott or picketing? That is, I assume that you think people should have a right to boycott and picket. Those are well protected free speech rights in the US.

McCarthyism and the blacklist involved decades of government pressure, including passing various laws against Communists at both state and national levels. The blacklist specifically started after various people were cited for contempt of Congress for refusing to testify to the House Committee on Un-American Activities.

That's hardly the same as a few organizations calling for a boycott of Firefox and a few people threatening to quit their jobs at or stop volunteering for Mozilla, is it?

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by lordCarbonFiber on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:15PM (#7526167)
The main point here is the notion of protected class. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class In the United States protected classes are predominately traits upon which the individual has no control over (the notable exception being religion, pregnancy, and veteran status which are present because of constitutional and social value reasoning). Because of this line of logic egalitarians in this country support moving sexual preference as a protected class. Holding opinions (for whatever reason, you don't get to hide behind religion on that one) is on you and if that causes your employer to look bad or runs against what they stand for it is perfectly reasonable to expect to be let go.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by homulilly on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:48PM (#7525810)
Being gay and being a bigot are not comparable, that's insane.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by fleitz on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:06PM (#7526068)
I think what he's getting at is that you shouldn't suffer work consequences for opinions that you hold outside of work.

Alternatively, maybe we can decide on a set of American values and we can investigate and blackball people who hold unamerican views.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by homulilly on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:28PM (#7526309)
Things like this are about ethics, not "American Values" or any cultural norms. It used to be the cultural norm to be a white supremacist but that position as never actually been ethical.

Additionally, in this specific case it's worth noting that the Mozilla Foundation and its subsidiary the Mozilla Corporation are largely political organizations and someone who holds such obviously bigoted views is pretty clearly unqualified to lead an organization who's goals are freedom and openness.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by fleitz on Thursday April 03, 2014 @05:02PM (#7526632)
Since you think ethics are absolute and unchanging, can you please tell the rest of us what the one true ethical code is?

I'm pretty sure a much more reasonable interpretation is that ethics are subject to cultural norms, and that we should not decide on one true version of ethics and force that upon everyone.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by homulilly on Thursday April 03, 2014 @06:20PM (#7527399)
Obviously there is too much detail and history to lay out the Correct Ethical Choice for every single situation ever, but stuff like "give people equal rights," which is what we are talking about in this case, should be incredibly obvious to any reasonable person these days and judging by the backlash against Eich's appointment to CEO, that seems to be the case.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by themoonbus on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:03PM (#7526021)
Being a bigot is a lifestyle choice, and I don't support it

(this is just a joke)

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dasil003 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:29PM (#7525560)
> the community has pressured him to step down because he expressed an opinion not held by the majority.

That's not true. The fact that the majority believe the idea was necessary for the pressure to be applied, but it is not why the pressure was applied. The pressure was applied because his views trample on others' rights, and equal rights is philosophically closely tied with the entire mission of an organization like Mozilla. There are many other things which the majority believe, but which most people would acknowledge an individual's right to disagree with. This issue is different because Eich's personal opinion negatively materially affects another class of people without any justification.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by Gormo on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:59PM (#7525957)
> his views trample on others' rights

No; I don't agree with Eich's views, but merely having those views does not implicate anyone else's rights in any way at all. Rights are violated by actions, not merely by expressing distasteful opinions.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dasil003 on Friday April 04, 2014 @04:51AM (#7530088)
It's shocking and irritating to me that the three of the replies pointing out the strictly false nature of your post are all downvoted while your post sits inexplicably positive.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by tommorris on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:31PM (#7526336)
You mean actions like donating $1,000 to a campaign to deny people's rights.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by ionforce on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:36PM (#7526393)
Donating money over time against marriage equality is pretty distasteful.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dasil003 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:31PM (#7526339)
I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you somehow have been living under a rock and did not know that he donated $1000 to support California Prop 8.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by crassus on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:49PM (#7525836)
You can turn any political belief into "someone's rights". There are people who believe abortion is a woman's right, and others that believe legal abortion is an unprecedented holocaust. I believe we should be able to work together and respect each other while we work that out.

This is enforcing an ideological litmus test on the industry, policing people's internal beliefs. It is terrifying.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by homulilly on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:03PM (#7526018)
Personally, I feel the opposite. I think it's terrifying that so many in the tech industry apparently feel that ethics are irrelevant.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dasil003 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:28PM (#7526304)
Sure, the world is not black and white, you can always twist things around and mince words to support any viewpoint. But you picked a bad example, because the argument with abortion is that the unborn baby has rights too.

The only way you can say gay marriage violates someone's rights is to say that people have the right to not be offended, or the right to hate people who are different from them. For all the contortions that people will make on this issue, it's fundamentally about fear and hate and nothing more. Abortion is a much more nuanced issue.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by jessedhillon on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:12PM (#7526133)
Yes the framing is intentionally naïve, as if the minority-ness of the opinion is why he was rejected. If he was a vegan I doubt anyone would give a shit despite that belief being way more unpopular than opposition to gay marriage. The key is not that his belief was unpopular, it's that he held a belief widely regarded as bigoted and unjust. He then went on to enact those beliefs by proxy, through financial contributions.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by ameen on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:32PM (#7525597)
Freedom of speech is to be exercised only for populist opinions.

If we continue to travel down this path, we'd all have the same opinions, as anyone who dares to hold an different opinion than the majority would be ostracized from the society.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by homulilly on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:55PM (#7525898)
Ironically, what you're saying is that the right to free speech for the people who dissented shouldn't be respected.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by baddox on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:57PM (#7525935)
Human society seems quite capable of forming isolated regions (usually geographic, but also online) where a certain belief can prosper despite it being opposed in other regions.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by thinkpad20 on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:47PM (#7525798)
No one is abridging Eich's freedom of speech. Freedom of speech is the right to express yourself, not the right to have no one judge you for it.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by crassus on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:52PM (#7525877)
This is how East Germany worked. You weren't usually harmed for holding non-communist beliefs, but you were blacklisted so that you would never work again.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by lordCarbonFiber on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:21PM (#7526238)
It's also important to remember that freedom of speech is only protected from the government (which is why your East Germany example is nonsensical). The first admendment says you can stand on a public street corner and yell "God hates Fags" however, if you do so on my property I will remove you.

Mozilla is not a governmental body and (so long as it doesn't violate the protected classes as codified by law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Protected_class) can hire and fire people to project whatever image they see fit.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by DerKommissar on Thursday April 03, 2014 @06:57PM (#7527652)
Correct me if I'm wrong, but blacklisting was done by the government. It wasn't just some business owners that decides they weren't going to hire non-communists. Big difference.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by dirtyaura on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:03PM (#7526016)
Not all opinions are equivalent. There are opinions that are factually wrong or ethically wrong in the context of accumulated and shared wisdom of the society.

If you stubbornly hold on to latter, is it bad to you eventually become ostracized? Should we respect a holocaust denier as a good member of the society? As a CEO? How about someone who doesn't deny it, but thinks it was a right thing to do?

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by bashinator on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:45PM (#7525776)
There's a difference between expressing an opinion, and actively working to establish legal and social policy.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:02PM (#7525996)
Is there? I don't think we want to take the stance, as a society, that it's ok to have unpopular opinions as long as you don't advocate for your opinions.
Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by lern_too_spel on Thursday April 03, 2014 @04:40PM (#7526432)
Why not? I don't care if my neighbor believes aliens built the pyramids and some deity created all animals in their present form in six days. I do care if they pressure the school board to teach those things to my children.

In the same way, I don't care if somebody believes that different races shouldn't intermarry because of dilution of racial purity or that people of the same sex shouldn't marry because of Adam and Steve. I do care if they try to put that into law.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by akerl_ on Thursday April 03, 2014 @07:19PM (#7527781)
This is the same logic that was used to justify policies like Don't Ask, Don't Tell.

We are not perfect beings; we make mistakes, we believe things that end up being false, and we do things that we (or the rest of society) will regret later. As such, advocating that opinions other than the current prevailing set should be suppressed is a dangerous game to play. I know that like most of the people advocating it are doing so out of a desire to see the world become a better place. But since we've been wrong before about what "a better place" looks like, we should exercise utmost caution in telling others to be silent about their own views.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by lern_too_spel on Friday April 04, 2014 @03:13AM (#7529806)
Really? You think there's a chance we're wrong about the pyramids and allowing racial mixing?

Clearly, we aren't. Clearly, the people who push the opposing policies are harming society. Just like with evolution, there is no debate among thinking people about this.

Re:Brendan Eich Steps Down as Mozilla CEO by SimHacker on Thursday April 03, 2014 @03:50PM (#7525845)
Society has the right to protect itself from intolerant bigots like Brendan.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance

Michael Walzer asks "Should we tolerate the intolerant?". He notes that most minority religious groups who are the beneficiaries of tolerance are themselves intolerant, at least in some respects. In a tolerant regime, such people may learn to tolerate, or at least to behave "as if they possessed this virtue". Philosopher Karl Popper asserted, in The Open Society and Its Enemies Vol. 1, that we are warranted in refusing to tolerate intolerance. Philosopher John Rawls concludes in A Theory of Justice that a just society must tolerate the intolerant, for otherwise, the society would then itself be intolerant, and thus unjust. However, Rawls also insists, like Popper, that society has a reasonable right of self-preservation that supersedes the principle of tolerance: "While an intolerant sect does not itself have title to complain of intolerance, its freedom should be restricted only when the tolerant sincerely and with reason believe that their own security and that of the institutions of liberty are in danger."