News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by sliverstorm on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:52PM (#7502593)
I would think porting OSX to ARM would be the real hurdle? Not undoable by any means, but the lion's share of the challenge.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by mcculley on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:58PM (#7502646)
I wouldn't imagine porting OS X to ARM would be the hurdle as most of it is already done in that iOS is most of OS X. Apple has full control of that source code base and probably already has done this, like they did during the transition to IA-32.

It would be the third party applications that would be a hurdle. Without a transparent layer like the deprecated Rosetta, they would not be able to run existing applications and would have to explain that a new MacBook Air can't run all of the old MacBook Air applications.

Maybe if they come out with an ARM powered laptop, they will call it something other than MacBook Air to avoid that confusion.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by gonzo on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:15PM (#7502783)
Just the Apple Air, I'd bet.

Don't forget that Apple has spent years getting everyone on Xcode, and disciplining them to avoid the parts that would make a recompile & test straight-forward.

They also have a "good enough" office suite (for many people), as well as the iWork apps.

Such a device could potentially also run iPad apps without much change.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by wiml on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:57PM (#7502634)
The machine-specific parts of OSX already run on ARM in the form of iOS.

Also remember Apple has already successfully made two or three architecture transitions already: m68k to PPC to i386 to x86_64.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by justincormack on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:03PM (#7503078)
And the (brief) PPC64 transition.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by coldtea on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:37PM (#7503611)
They've already ported it. iOS is OSX for ARM plus different UI stuff -- all the kernel, basic userland etc are there.

So, it's mainly a matter of porting the higher level stuff -- mainly the Cocoa libs, which are slightly different on iOS vs desktop OS X.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by sliverstorm on Monday March 31, 2014 @06:09PM (#7504555)
I guess I'm not familiar with just how much iOS and OSX shares.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by rsynnott on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:07PM (#7502720)
Given Apple's history with this stuff, there's a very good chance that that's already done. Intel was supported internally for years before the PPC -> Intel change.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by cpeterso on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:40PM (#7502937)
Jobs claimed that Apple maintained a secret x86 port of OS X for five years before the public release. A small cost.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by leoc on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:37PM (#7503282)
Apparently this is true enough, with the added qualification that for the first year or so it was largely secret from Apple too. :) http://www.theregister.co.uk/2012/06/11/apple_project_markla... http://www.quora.com/Apple-company/How-does-Apple-keep-secre... (Though of course the fact that the OS X codebase had been kept cleanly portable was neither one person's secret project nor a matter of chance.)
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by rsynnott on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @07:53AM (#7507401)
Makes perfect sense, really; not only would it be a hedge against having to adopt Intel, but just the value of having it around to show IBM people when negotiating over the PPC would probably have been worth the cost.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by mikeash on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:00PM (#7502660)
The real challenge will be figuring out the compatibility question for third-party software. Do you make everybody recompile before their stuff works on the new hardware? Do you ship an emulator for x86-64 for a while, like they did when they went PPC->Intel?

OS X and its predecessors have already been ported to run on a bunch of architectures: x86-64, i386, PPC64, PPC32, PA-RISC, SPARC, and Motorola 68k. All, or nearly all, of the CPU-dependent parts of the OS are the parts that are shared between OS X and iOS. Making OS X run on ARM would be trivial for Apple, and I'd be shocked if they didn't have it up and running already as a hedge.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by chipotle_coyote on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:58PM (#7503051)
The emulation question is the main reason -- not the only reason, but the main reason -- I don't see Apple really moving in this direction with the Mac line any time soon. But I don't think it's just a matter of third-party software for OS X that's the issue; Windows compatibility is a pretty big deal. Apple doesn't push Macs as being great Windows machines currently (although they did for a while), but they're certainly aware of this use case and how it's been a minor but measurable plus for the Mac line. Even as much as Apple is known for burning down the old to make way for the new, I think they'd be pretty cautious with this one.

The notion that this CPU is really about giving ample power to the iOS line makes more sense to me. There will eventually be an "iPad Pro," whether or not it gets stuck with that moniker, and it won't have to worry about backward compatibility with anything other than previous iOS devices.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by kevinchen on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:14PM (#7503483)
I don't see low-end users (think entry-level MacBook Air) running virtualization or Boot Camp. The well-known Mac developers will recompile their apps as soon as Xcode is updated, and huge apps like Office will probably get a pre-release version beforehand. So a cheaper ARM MBA should be usable for most of it customers.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by __david__ on Monday March 31, 2014 @04:32PM (#7503946)
> I'd be shocked if they didn't have it up and running already as a hedge.

Especially because they were known to have OS X running on x86 as far back as 10.0, years before they actually switched to Intel officially.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by gsnedders on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @04:31AM (#7506826)
Rhapsody, the stepping-stone between OPENSTEP and OS X, had public releases on x86, while the PPC port was new.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by rsynnott on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @07:51AM (#7507392)
> I'd be shocked if they didn't have it up and running already as a hedge.

This seems very likely to me. They presumably have a fair bit of the work done with iOS, which shares a kernel codebase and so on, and really, it'd be worth the effort just to have it to show to Intel executives during negotiation.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by endianswap on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:23PM (#7502831)
That was my thought, too. It seems like if they do this then they'll be going down the same path as Microsoft did with the Surface RT and Surface Pro, right?
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by twoodfin on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:27PM (#7502861)
Not exactly. Remember that the Surface RT deliberately restricted the applications that could be run via Win32 on the familiar desktop. Just about every third party application needed to adopt the new RT APIs and run "Metro"-style.

If they go down this road, Apple will not put constraints like that on their Mac developers: I'd expect that all the most commonly used frameworks would continue to be available, and porting most applications would amount to a recompile against a new Xcode.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by rmrfrmrf on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @08:55AM (#7507677)
I never once gave much thought to the idea that Apple would somehow shut out unsigned apps from its desktop computers, for the main reason that there would be too many existing apps that would suddenly lose functionality and cause a backlash.

With a port to ARM, though, Apple can simply say that the developers haven't ported their app to the new architecture yet, and that more apps will become available as developers catch up. Meanwhile, all those apps that currently require some kind of lower-level access could be banned.

On the other hand, I think that would be a huge boon for non-power users; it would be nearly impossible for malware to get onto the computer, and even annoyances like Adobe's and Microsoft's auto-updaters would finally get funneled though the App Store, which would prevent programs like that from constantly occupying memory/CPU/network.

For this to work, though, I think Apple would be wise to include some kind of developer mode feature (perhaps even forking over the $99/year fee) that would allow unsigned or potentially dangerous apps to run.

All of this (admittedly wild; sorry, coffee is kicking in) speculation definitely has me excited for the future of Apple, though! I haven't felt like that since Steve was around.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by mikeash on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @10:00AM (#7508201)
"All of this (admittedly wild; sorry, coffee is kicking in) speculation definitely has me excited for the future of Apple, though! I haven't felt like that since Steve was around."

Wacky. Your vision of shutting out unsigned apps has me looking for the exits. I've been an Apple user since the 80s and I'm pretty sure this would finally make me jump ship. Apple's current Big Brother trajectory frightens me to no end.

Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by rmrfrmrf on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @11:33AM (#7509005)
I'm pretty sure this won't change your mind, but my view is more-or-less "better the devil I know." Trading in Microsoft and Adobe's phone-homers for Apple's is fine in my book.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by mikeash on Tuesday April 01, 2014 @01:02PM (#7509785)
I don't use Microsoft or Adobe software as it stands. Getting rid of a couple of third-party updaters I don't even use in exchange for giving Apple complete control over whether or not I'm allowed to run something is an awful tradeoff. It's just barely tolerable on iOS because I use those devices more as appliances than computers, but it's not workable for me on a real computer.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by gozzoo on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:57PM (#7503406)
I don't think they will go that path. It would make much more sense to introduce a desktop version of iOS itself. iOS has already everything that's needed for a light desktop OS. It would provide much better experience than ChromeOS, there are already thousands of applications doing about anything and it would require very little effort to adapt iOS to run as a desktop OS and to adapt the existing applications. I think that a hint for that is the recent port of Microsoft Office. If users want more sophisticated OS they can just use 13" MacBook Pro. It's quite easy to guess that the next version will be thinner and lighter and probably cheaper - very similar to the current MacBook Air.
Re:Apple's Cyclone Microarchitecture Detailed by userbinator on Monday March 31, 2014 @10:11PM (#7505729)
> but the lion's share of the challenge.

This would've been the perfect phrase last year.