News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:04AM (#7499742)
For those of you who want to understand this topic better (i.e., a lot of the people spinning conspiracy theories), you might want to learn the basic mechanics of HFT. I wrote a tutorial on the topic a couple of years ago, might be helpful:

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology.html

http://www.chrisstucchio.com/blog/2012/hft_apology2.html

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by crdoconnor on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:33AM (#7500155)
This is a pretty weak defense of HFT:

>Although the latency competition provides little to no value to the end >consumers, all HFTs must play the game. If they don’t, a faster HFT >will beat them to market and their order flow will be reduced.

So yes, it's essentially useless to the retail or wholesale investor.

Actually, worse than useless, since the HFT has a built in advantage that brings no value to the rest of the market. It's an endless zero sum game where other investors (who do the real work) are losing.

>I’d also like to note that I don’t believe automated market making is useless. It isn’t. Providing liquidity and reducing the spread is valuable.

Which HFT is actually pretty poor at. Spreads were reduced significantly by having electronic trading systems (computers are cheaper than manual labor), NOT through high frequency trading systems (did spreads drop significantly in the last 5 years?).

Liquidity was already maxxed out in the equities market before HFT, too. HOUSES are illiquid -- it takes weeks to close on a sale on one of those at best. THAT market could do with additional liquidity. Would be nice to close on a sale in a day, right?

Being able to buy and sell your share a thousand times in a second is not providing useful liquidity to anybody except HFT traders.

At the end of the day they're levying a tax on the rest of the market - i.e. as the OP points out, the market IS rigged.

>In the Hacker News comments on part 1 of this series, there were several comments suggesting that HFT’s somehow steal pennies from ordinary investors. I don’t agree with this claim, but I’m very interested in hearing well reasoned disagreement.

I'd be interested in hearing this well reasoned disagreement with the OP. I'm not so interested in reading the same old tired defenses of HFT, though.

It's not about liquidity or transaction costs. It's about gaining an information advantage similar to what front running or insider trading gets you.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @06:45AM (#7500633)
So yes, it's essentially useless to the retail or wholesale investor.

Having liquidity available to take is not useless. You should re-read the article - it is a zero sum game between liquidity sellers, and a positive sum game between liquidity sellers and liquidity consumers.

At the end of the day they're levying a tax on the rest of the market...

It's not a tax. If you choose not to take liquidity you don't pay for it. If you do choose to take liquidity you pay less than you would under other systems (e.g., specialists).

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by curun1r on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:18PM (#7502359)
If it's not a tax, then why was the RBC guy able to save millions of dollars by using software to ensure that his orders arrived simultaneously at all the exchanges? If, as related in the 60 Minutes story, institutional investors are each being charged hundreds of millions of dollars per year, how can that be seen as anything other than a tax?
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:14PM (#7505956)
Institutional computer buyers pay hundreds of dollars to Dell for every computer they purchase. Is Dell "taxing" them? Of course not - if they don't want computers they don't need to buy them. If you read the article, you'd realize the RBC guy was buying liquidity. He wants to purchase what HFTs are selling.

There is a simple obvious way for anyone to avoid paying the HFT "tax". Use ALO orders. They come with execution risk, but you don't pay the spread and the matching engine will pay you rebates. Can you tell me why anyone anywhere would choose to purchase from HFTs rather than using ALO orders?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by acjohnson55 on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:25PM (#7503210)
Maybe it's more of a toll or a rent than a tax
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by crdoconnor on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:16PM (#7502350)
>Having liquidity available to take is not useless.

Um, I covered that point pretty thoroughly.

>It's not a tax. If you choose not to take liquidity you don't pay for it.

It isn't a choice. You cannot chose to not participate in an equities market without HFT. Not right now, anyway.

>If you do choose to take liquidity

You you even understand yourself what that phrase means?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:26PM (#7502411)
If I post an ALO order and don't cross the spread, what "tax" do I pay to the evil HFT?

And why would I not be paying this to a human market maker, in the event that HFTs hadn't driven them all out of the market?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by cynicalkane on Monday March 31, 2014 @07:05AM (#7500690)
You'll notice that any accurate argument against HFT can be applied to any kind of trading.

There's nothing sinister about HFT except that it's a faster version of ordinary market making. If you think market making is evil, then you'll think HFT is evil. But market making is perfectly healthy, economically speaking. Information advantages and speed have been part of this world in the 400-odd years that centralized trading has been a thing.

HFT is a threat to other market makers, but you're smart enough to know that common people shouldn't be market making and can (provably) only benefit from reduced spreads and increased liquidity. Right?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by jellicle on Monday March 31, 2014 @07:45AM (#7500797)
Nonsense. HFT is a variety of front-running, which is provably only a detriment to "common people", and is illegal in most cases.

They even have an example in the linked article of a trader being forced to pay higher prices for his buy orders due to HFTs front-running his orders; you literally couldn't be bothered to even read the linked story.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @07:59AM (#7500847)
HFT is a variety of front-running...

Please explain the mechanics of this.

...a trader being forced to pay higher prices for his buy orders due to HFTs front-running...

Clearly you didn't understand the article, which was about predatory trading increasing market efficiency. It was not about front running, which is when your broker trades in front of you in violation of his fiduciary duty to act in your best interest. (Note that your competitors do NOT have the duty to act in your best interest.)

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by jellicle on Monday March 31, 2014 @08:41AM (#7501012)
Just because the exploit is illegal in one circumstance and not in another doesn't mean it's not an exploit.

When the exchanges are complicit in the deal - being paid for sending information early to particular parties - it's pretty easy to argue there is a conspiracy to defraud the general public, and so regulators have regularly argued:

http://www.gotgoldreport.com/2014/03/why-new-york-ag-wants-c...

I assume that when these practices are finally banned you will change your tune, right?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @09:35AM (#7501322)
I don't understand. Using the multicast quote stream (which costs a few thousand/month) is an "exploit"? Or are traders somehow obligated to ignore the actions of other traders? Perhaps anyone using a computer is obligated to act as an agent for people without a computer, rather than a competitor?

I truly don't understand what you are arguing. Could you please explain the mechanics of what you believe should be illegal?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by mmaldacker on Monday March 31, 2014 @09:47AM (#7501389)
The article you linked calls it insider trading and not front running. In addition, the issue discussed in the article is about making company information public earlier to a select group of people (which is insider trading). However, most HFT (particularly market makers) do no care about this and rely only market data provided directly from the exchanges. This data is provided fairly to everyone.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by crdoconnor on Monday March 31, 2014 @12:20PM (#7502371)
>Please explain the mechanics of this.

You say that a lot.

I already explained the exact mechanics in this comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7500223

...which you did not respond to.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:07PM (#7505931)
I previously ignored your comment because in the context of the conversation, it was completely irrelevant. In the comment you replied to, I was asking how one can "cut in front of you". Your comment was just about rapidly trading and rapidly waving one's hands in order to somehow do something evil.

"Use pattern recognition software to outcompete other traders" is not a trading mechanic.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by mmaldacker on Monday March 31, 2014 @09:53AM (#7501431)
no, the higher price was due to arbitrage and not front-running. Large orders always move the market (this is simple supply/demand economics), HFT makes this move much faster than before. Large orders are usually cut-up in smaller pieces to minimize this price move and get a better price. Katsuyama is just butt hurt that his 1990's trading style doesn't work anymore.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by theorique on Wednesday April 02, 2014 @10:21AM (#7515658)
It has absolutely nothing to do with front running. Front running has a very specific definition in market regulation.

Front running refers to a broker placing his orders (i.e. the BROKER'S orders) in front of his customer's orders. This is a violation of fiduciary duty, SEC regulations, FINRA regulations. When the broker gets a customer order, it must be given priority over the broker's proprietary trading. This has been in place for decades, well before trading was electronic.

If an HFT (or any other trader, regardless of speed) places an order into the limit order book of an exchange or other trading venue AHEAD of another customer of that exchange, that is not front-running. That is the normal and correct functioning of the markets, which operate by price-time priority.

tl;dr - trading faster or more frequently than other market participants (who are not your brokerage customers) is not front running.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by harmegido on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:27AM (#7499803)
Nice posts. You see 0 value to the latency arms race, and I think you are probably right.

However, I think it's not hard to argue that some speed increases have value. For example, if the world's only stock market only allowed trades to happen n times a year, we would expect a pretty inefficient market and this mechanism for capital allocation would be pretty poor. And as we increase n, market efficiency would increase, and this has value.

So are we at a point right now where an increase in n has no value (say market information gets processed on the order of nanoseconds instead of the current microseconds)? What's the cutoff point?

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:35AM (#7499825)
This is a good question and one I don't have a good answer to. I don't actually know the optimal points for most of these values and I'm generally content to let the market decide.

This is why I think eliminating the subpenny rule is a good policy change - it eliminates a market distortion while not requiring you to perfectly tune a parameter (e.g., the size of a transaction tax or a minimal trade latency). All it does is allows price competition.

Of course as a real policy proposal it's dead in the water, since it doesn't provide much opportunity for moralizing or posturing.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by AndrewBissell on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:57AM (#7499890)
> You see 0 value to the latency arms race, and I think you are probably right.

How do you draw the line between investments in reduced latency which are socially beneficial, and those which aren't? It's not like these are cheap investments that HFT firms are making. If they're truly pointless, we should expect them to lead to overcapacity and ultimately the exit of some players (unless, of course, the arms race is being unnaturally subsidized in some way, e.g. by the lack of a sub-penny rule).

When Paul Reuter was using carrier pigeons and telegraphs to move tradeable information between stock exchanges ahead of his competitors, I wonder if people considered this an arms race of negligible social value. After all, the world had gotten by just fine without telegraphs up until then.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by jellicle on Monday March 31, 2014 @08:34AM (#7500980)
> If they're truly pointless

You've conflated "value to society" with "potential to make money". The two are unrelated. Dumping toxic waste in the river may make money, but has negative societal value.

Whatever societal value there was to faster trading was exceeded when trades could execute by the time your browser refreshed. Humans make financial decisions on the scale of minutes at fastest.

At this point HFTs are still pursuing "making money" (and there may still be money to be made) but certainly not providing any societal value whatsoever; since they are stealing from the general public their societal value is strongly negative.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by dllthomas on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:05AM (#7499907)
Meaningful stuff could happen in the elapsed time, so motivating people to get info there sooner was more valuable. As someone who's working in HFT, I think that the surface defined by a given expenditure in (expenditure on price accuracy)x(expenditure on speed)x(profitability) space, the gradient points too far toward speed on too much of the surface.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by cma on Monday March 31, 2014 @02:07AM (#7499915)
Saying something that is such a zero-sum waste is great because as a side effect it brought us the telegraph is like saying government bureaucracy is great because firms have had to develop new technologies that happen to be useful in other domains in order to deal with it.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by floatrock on Monday March 31, 2014 @03:20AM (#7500116)
> So are we at a point right now where an increase in n has no value (say market information gets processed on the order of nanoseconds instead of the current microseconds)? What's the cutoff point?

My intuitions want to say the point of diminishing returns is around the limits of human cognition. Stocks are ownership of some human activity, so once you start valuing them faster than human activity you're really redefining what stocks are. Now stocks become predictions on ownership of some human activity.

Since the first formalization of Sport (some might argue earlier), it's been a human tendency to go Faster, Stronger, Better. Moving from ownership of some human activity to predictions on ownership of some human activity is a manifestation of this Faster, Stronger, Better (since the prediction is itself a human activity... we're owning the human activity of predicting human activity).

All that is not to say any of this is inherently good or bad (I disagree at the loaded term 'rigged' being used by Lewis). There's no single cut-off point in additional value earned. It's more of a transition zone where you're not sure when exactly you left it, but at some point you realize on the other side is not the world you started in.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by baddox on Monday March 31, 2014 @04:06AM (#7500250)
I don't see why the speed of human cognition should have anything to do both it. After all, the HFT algorithms are the result of human cognition. It's just computers "doing human cognition" much faster than human brains can, which is what all computers do.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by AndrewBissell on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:12AM (#7499762)
I really like your idea of allowing sub-penny ticks in the highly liquid stocks as a way of tilting algo trading away from the latency arms race. Unfortunately, it probably runs too counter to the uninformed "no one should be trading to make $0.01 per transaction!" popular perspective for the SEC & exchanges to implement it.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by kasey_junk on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:16AM (#7499774)
As someone who actually makes a living in HFT, if you really wanted to get rid of me, sub-penny ticks would be the single worst thing I can think of. There is literally no transaction tax that would make trading unprofitable. 2 zero's worth of decimilazation though and I have to go find honest work.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by yummyfajitas on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:24AM (#7499794)
I'd only get rid of you insofar as you are fighting over latency. If you can deliver price improvement or useful market depth there is still a place for you.
Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by kasey_junk on Monday March 31, 2014 @11:00AM (#7501848)
I think decreasing the minimum bid/ask spread value would make it very difficult to continue doing traditional market making. I think that exchanges would then need to add some other incentives/perks to ensure liquidity providers stayed on their exchange, which starts to sound more and more like a specialist system which I'm generally against.

Of course, I don't think there is some natural right for market makers to exist. I do really like the idea of an extremely small tick size as it much more elegant than a transaction tax.

Re:U.S. stock markets are rigged, says author Michael Lewis by sseveran on Monday March 31, 2014 @01:45AM (#7499864)
latency arb is still important to keep venues in sync.