Back in the day, the software on my "Personal Computer" was my friend. It was all wonderful things to have and to learn about.
Looking at my smartphone that's right here on my table, it's shiny, but I've long felt a distinct lack of control over the thing. And now this: Hello - any of you apps mining anything right now in there?
Maybe we've stumbled on a great alternative to the freemium model?
If you run Google applications (on Android or on iOS or elsewhere) you send data to Google. If you don't want to send data to Google, don't run Google applications. The same goes for Apple applications which phone home to Apple, Microsoft applications to Microsoft, etc.
Android works fine without Google applications ('gapps'). It does not need the Google Services Framework to survive. You don't need the (horribly named) 'play store'. Nor Gmail, Google Maps, Google+, etc. This is one of the big differences between Android and the other bigger players in this field - you have a choice.
The severity of financial impact on the victim is irrelevant. If I steal tiny amounts of money ~0.01c from large amounts of people and accrued significant wealth from it, is it fine? Is it a "victimless crime" because the amount is so small?
Not if it actually damage some parts of the phone like the battery because you have to charge it more often.
[edit]
Do either of these apps explicitly state that they will access/use device in this way?
Taking someone else's property can be both theft and conversion.
Conversion is a tort, a matter of a lawsuit between parties.
Theft is a crime, a matter between a citizen and the state.
Someone cuts down trees from land they don't own to haul them away for lumber? That's clear theft to me.
Removing furniture that you don't own from a cohabited dwelling and storing it without telling the owner the location? That's clear theft to me.
Someone finds lost goods that they then keep for themselves without attempting to return them to the rightful owner? I can see that being something other than theft.
Edit: Just a note, I'm not saying this is OK for apps to do, but to call it a theft is ridiculous.
I can think of at least two differences. First, the developer profits from one but not the other. Second, the developer intended one but not the other.
We evaluate the morality of accidental waste differently from that of deliberate taking for personal gain.
On the other hand, if you look at this from another perspective, inefficient software wasting power means no one gains. If the same power was being used for mining, then someone gains. If I were forced to choose between these two alternatives, I would definitely pick the latter.
And, all else being equal, if someone writes inefficient code and has bad intentions, it's even worse.
Is one of those considered stealing?
http://www.techdirt.com/articles/20041010/2225204.shtml
I imagine that mining crypto currency without permission is due for a high profile court case.
One catch was that the duration of batch jobs was limited to 12 hours, so I couldn't just fire and forget. I ended up scripting it so that when the job ended, it automatically resubmitted itself to the batch queue.
It took about a day before I got a surprisingly friendly e-mail from the sysadmin asking me to please stop.
Providing a user with means to throttle or govern the mining seems appropriate even if not explicit. If I am trying to use my device put the virtual mining crew on break and dont check back for at least 20 minutes.
Secondly, exclusive mining rights. Only one app per device, but each developer can ask for a share of the haul. Having more mining apps competing for time will work in no ones favor. As the device owner I should inherently be entitled to a significant share.
An auditible mining client would be valuable. I could certainly see this as something that could eventually fit neatly somewhere between an optional and encouraged part of an AOSP deployment.
Not according to this: http://www.technologyreview.com/sites/default/files/images/M...
It's this close to a victimless crime (that is, unless the victim gets their CPU/GPU fried, as has happened with these nets before). But what about apps that use spare cycles while you're plugged in, or above 75% battery, or between hours x and y, to mine dogecoins for charity? People would voluntarily submit to that!