News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @10:41PM (#7471213)
> He is right - "social", especially in the way Facebook is doing it at the moment, is terrible for VR. Terrible for any technology that has such an incredible potential to change the world.

It's not just that. VR is not going to be a product that appeals to masses. I don't think it will change the world. It could impact the world of gaming, potentially, and only CERTAIN areas of gaming only.

There are several reasons for that. First, it's a peripheral. You'll need to convince people to buy another 300-400 USD of gear on top of a powerful computer OR a PS4. The PS4 may be winning on the market, but peripherals have a bad History of not selling very well on consoles. Even the Kinect, which sold relatively quite a lot on Xbox360, failed to deliver anything really revolutionary.

For PC gamers, you'll probably need a very powerful graphics card to make full use of it, and we already know that this kind of market is already a small minority in terms of PC users.

There are several issues with VR as well: it's not something you can use to replace the screen completely. You'll probably feel dizzy, nauseous, tired after some time with it. Your eyes will end up hurting. It will work well with cockpit-like simulators (and there aren't many of them left anymore...) but not so well with FPS where camera movements have to be extremely fast. There are other games (3rd person view ones, top view games) where using an Occulus won't really make sense anyway.

As for social applications, I don't know. It's already possible to do videoconference in pretty good quality but few companies actually use it, and still fly people all over the world because they find it works better to have face to face contact to solve issues and discuss projects. I'm not too sure the benefits of VR will outweigh its disadvantages in the everyday world.

And this is coming from someone who badly wants a consumer Rift for gaming.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by weixiyen on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @11:50PM (#7471464)
You're going to read this in 10 years and look like the guy who predicted the iPhone to be a flop. Usable VR is absolutely world-changing.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by rimantas on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:23AM (#7472513)
Actually I think the guys who predicted that iPhone will flop are the same guys who think VR is world-changing. The common theme is misunderstanding of the potential users and the problems the product solves. VR solves zero problems for me.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by voyou on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @08:00AM (#7472797)
This might well be right. VR proponents like to present people who disagree with them as conservatives, but is it not in fact the case that the VR proponents are the real conservatives?

That is, the ubiquity of computing devices that you get with smartphones, which the iPhone kicked off, is something genuinely fairly new, which not a lot of people had previously imagined. VR, on the other hand, is something people have been imagining for decades, producing compelling fictional versions; but every attempt to implement it suggests that it's not actually a very good idea. VR proponents are stuck with a nostalgic vision of the future, rather than trying to imagine something genuinely novel.

(On the other hand, people were imagining video phones as the next big thing for years, and they seemed to never take off, until they did; Skype hasn't replaced non-video phones, but it is ubiquitous.)

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by weixiyen on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:51PM (#7477232)
Perhaps, which is why I put the caveat "Usable" VR. The problem with VR right now is that it's not very user friendly.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by bloaf on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:45AM (#7471661)
Some people predict that the instant we have complete VR, all human progress will cease. We will have no reason to seek new experiences in the real world because we can simulate any experience we want in the virtual world.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by stormbrew on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:05AM (#7471714)
And this means progress stops ... because...?

I could see making this argument for true AI, maybe, but even then I doubt it's true. When in human history has allowing people's minds greater degrees of freedom resulted in progress slowing down, let alone stopping?

This just sounds like "Kids these days..." kind of nonsense to me.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by danieldk on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:22AM (#7472511)
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @04:07AM (#7472158)
That's bunk. Most people don't care about fake experiences.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by bjt on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:46PM (#7474621)
Most people spend quite a lot of time having "fake experiences". TV, movies, and video games are wildly popular, and consume quite a lot of people's time. As they become more immersive through VR, and provide an even better escape from reality, it's natural to expect them to become more popular, not less.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:43PM (#7474988)
TV, movie, and video game story-lines also near-uniformly consist of situations that would be unpleasant or even traumatizing to actually live through.

Everyone thinks it's a great story when the heroine sets out to avenge her father's murder and ends up saving the world. Most people do not actually want to have their father murdered and then deal with an existentially-threatening war for the survival of the human species. Likewise, everyone enjoys a good round of the Hero's Journey, but most people don't really want Spiderman-level responsibility (and yet find superheroism largely meaningless without it).

Many people really enjoy sports dramas in film. Very few people want to pack endless hours over a period of years into athletic training and then find out they've only got even odds against the opponent who also trained hard. Even fewer people want to just beat sports video-games by some athletic equivalent of "Rare Candies", leveling up without actually training or working hard.

Oh, and people who actually try to do the stuff portrayed in romantic comedies are called creeps, let alone the entire creepy-vampire-romance section of the bookstore.

People would have a much better point about escapism "overtaking" real life if more of our culture's fantasies consisted of experiences we actually really want to live through when confronted with the possibility.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by wildpeaks on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:07AM (#7473044)
Only because they're not good enough at the moment: once it's indistinguishable from reality, they'll choose the path of lesser resistance that gives them the most control.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:00PM (#7474281)
Let me put it this way: imagine the derision, scorn, and hatred heaped upon furries, /a/utists, Tumblrites, bronies, MMORPG addicts, and all other sorts of low-status netizens who are already perceived as overly escapist, and who thus get labeled "faggots" and beaten up for their lunch money. Now multiply it by a rather large quantity. In fact, you might have to outright square it.

That is how people are going to act towards those who deliberately cut themselves off from real life to spend time on VRs. There is going to be bullying among children and harassment among adults (but I repeat myself). There will be lawsuits and alarmist attempts at legislation.

Now, I don't really think either side of this coming dichotomy is healthy or correct. I think that escapism is fun, but it's not real life, but it is a strict subset of valid ways to spend real-life time. However, if your prediction bears out, that dichotomy is going to form.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:06AM (#7471519)
Haha. Then I'll hope I'm wrong, but come up with clear reasons why this will be mainstream and mass market.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by rpdillon on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:33AM (#7471792)
Simple: it provides a hyper-compelling experience that is completely unavailable through any other means, and does so for merely the price of a peripheral. Doubters will visit a friend's house and use it and be instantly sold. VR is a Big Deal.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @02:30AM (#7471935)
I've given several reasons why it won't work this way, and you just come up with an assumption that the current VR tech is SOOOOO good that everyone will want one. Did you go to the GDC ?
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by MrScruff on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @04:28AM (#7472202)
Having used the DK1 it was obvious even with all the limitations that VR will be a dominant entertainment platform within a decade. It's simply too compelling to be anything other.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by a3voices on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:13AM (#7473068)
But you can't do other things at the same time, like look at your phone or the world around you. The value is limited.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by crpatino on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:28PM (#7474903)
It is not a joke. I'm not meaning it as a smart-ass retort:

Porn == Money

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by Nursie on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:29AM (#7472527)
LOL. They said this stuff in the 80s too. I remember, I went to an arcade where they had VR...
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by qq66 on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @10:50PM (#7471249)
Your characterization of VR applications seems limited to near-term applications of current or immediate-term technologies.

What about when the device is $20 instead of $400? When it doesn't make you nauseous? When it's so close to face-to-face contact that you can replace 10 or 20 percent of your business travel?

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @11:08PM (#7471309)
> When it doesn't make you nauseous? When it's so close to face-to-face contact that you can replace 10 or 20 percent of your business travel?

That's what I am saying, we are FAR from being there. If we even get there.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by wernercd on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:51AM (#7471680)
We are far? Really?

15 years ago, how far were we from having a 6 inch super computer in my pocket that can communicate immediately with anyone in the world? A choice of a million apps? Music on demand? Movies? All in a touch screen device?

And Palm/BB/MS are bit players?

If we get there? not if... when. Maybe not next year, but you have to be BLIND if you can't see how far CELL PHONES have come in 5, 10, 15, 20 years.

Not a far stretch to say that we'll have mass market VR within 5-10 years.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:14AM (#7471741)
Yeah, we are far from what was refered to in my answer :

> What about when the device is $20 instead of $400? When it doesn't make you nauseous? When it's so close to face-to-face contact that you can replace 10 or 20 percent of your business travel?

We are FAR from having a very cheap VR solution. The VR gear is likely to be 300 or 400+ USD for a while and that will prevent mainstream adoption because it's a peripheral.

We are far from having solved all the problems related to discomfort, nausea, eye strain and stuff that goes with VR systems. Have you had a rift on your heard for 5 hours in a row ? If you had, you'd know what I am talking about.

So close to simulating real human contact? We are not even there YET in terms of 3D technology, we are far from photo realistic human representations on screen, let alone VR.

So yes, we are far from these objectives.

EDIT: and your comment regarding mobile phones to drive VR is senseless. mobile phones are too limited to drive any kind of complex 3d environment, they are limited by battery size, by watts and how temperature they can cope with, and by the size of their processors. The past few years should clearly indicate the pace in mobile phone processing power is slowing down rather than accelerating. You don't get 2x performance every 6 months anymore on a new mobile phone.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by jcrites on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @04:02AM (#7472145)
This is largely a tangential question but ...

> we are far from photo realistic human representations on screen, let alone VR.

Would we actually need to simulate human representations in order for it to be photorealistic? For example, what if your VR headset displays information consumed from a set of stereoscopic cameras?

There would be a lot of complications. (Won't the other guy also be wearing a VR headset, thus obscuring the cameras? Though not necessarily if it's one-directional)

Imagine a VR conversation with another person who's in front of a stereo camera. You can't move your headset much, but you can tilt and pan slightly - basically stay in place and move your head. Imagine combining the VR technology with 3d scene reconstruction such as: http://petapixel.com/2013/07/24/researchers-reconstruct-high... - performed in realtime using the stereo camera. It could potentially present a fairly convincing VR experience of speaking with them in person.

(I assume that you need to perform scene reconstruction in order to generate a display according to the user's head movements in his VR headset given that the camera can't track and mimic the movement in realtime.)

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by anigbrowl on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:02AM (#7471707)
Headphones were a niche product for a certain sort of music lover until the invention of the Walkman, now everyone has a pair. Obviously VR goggles are a bit different since you can't (safely) walk around wearing a pair, but imagine them in a Google Glass like package or with optical nerve transducers. Today's hardcore gamer is tomorrow's prosumer, is the day after's average consumer.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @04:11AM (#7472166)
Excuse me but the cost of producing stereo sound and the cost of producing stereo 3D world in fullHD on each eye has really nothing to do with each other. Cheap speakers are easy to make, cheap VR sets and cheap equipment to produce good enough VR is nowhere near available at a cheap price.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by hjnilsson on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:28AM (#7472525)
The first walkman cost 700$ in 2014 dollars (199$ in 1979). VR sets are not gonna be expensive forever, in 5-10 years your smartphone could probably power it and the device would not be larger than a a pair of sunglasses.
Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by anigbrowl on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @02:34PM (#7475367)
What they have in common is economics. I had to replace a broken smartphone in a hurry last month and I just got the cheapest thing that runs the latest version of Android. I paid $75, not on a plan. I got a slight discount for being a long-time customer, but I think the RRP of that phone is only $99.

VR headsets will be cheap and basically disposable accessory within 10 years; I'm pretty sure they'll be available for under $100 by end of the decade.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by quasque on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @06:47AM (#7472593)
> optical nerve transducers

Apart from some limited, low-resolution medical trials for people who've lost their eyesight already, this is firmly in the arena of science fiction and not going to happen any time soon.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by noir_lord on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @04:25PM (#7476347)
> Apart from some limited, low-resolution medical trials for people who've lost their eyesight already, this is firmly in the arena of science fiction and not going to happen any time soon.

Define any time soon.

The year I was born the ZX80 was released, it cost about two weeks wages (revolutionary at the time for it's price point) and had a 3.25Mhz processor with 1KB of memory.

Against that backdrop imagine walking up to someone on the high street and handing them a Nexus 5 and pointing out that it's floating point performance was about 50% faster than the Cray-1 which was then the state of the art (at about $8 million then dollars) oh and it has 256 times the RAM and a two orders of magnitude more storage and costs less than a weeks wages and run for a full day off a single charge consuming less power than the Cray 1's circulation pump.

It's a hard call to say "not going to happen any time soon" when we have proven the basic principle.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by ekianjo on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @09:24PM (#7477942)
> oh and it has 256 times the RAM and a two orders of magnitude more storage and costs less than a weeks wages and run for a full day off a single charge consuming less power than the Cray 1's circulation pump.

Yeah but mobile processing power is not increasing at the same pace now as it was 2 years ago. The pace is clearly slowing down, just like computational power on PCs too. You don't get 2x faster processors every year anymore. They are adding more cores, but that's not nearly the same thing as single thread performance.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by quasque on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @07:49PM (#7477550)
The basic principle proven so far is that, with an invasive surgical procedure, retinal function can be permanently replaced with technology that electrically stimulates the retinal ganglion cells (i.e. the side of the optic nerve that terminates in the eye) - and that it works in some blind people.

This predicts nothing about augmenting the optical input in people with healthy eyesight. I mean, who is going to volunteer to have their normal eyesight irreparably damaged to play a VR game?

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by samstave on Tuesday March 25, 2014 @11:37PM (#7471402)
>I don't think it will change the world

When you have a clear visor that you're looking through that will seamlessly super-impose exactly matched visuals to reality with enriched data... yes it wil change the world.

Follow the calendar of the Mayans; everthing in cycles. Observe these cycles for great benefit!

In this case, industry cycles around new tech will revolve. Certain circles will reach maturity, age and collapse. All circles will repeat an evolving pattern, spiraling out...

This is how technology evolves:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMY_JlBfClI

AND

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ie-6tcX5jKg#t=15

Think of each end-point of an arm of the spiral as a market leader in that category.

They will evolve, separate, matasticize and cannabalize the other objects in their tech-arm-thread.

We need another visualization of colliding spirals to illustrate this -- but they all start to grow from similar seeds....

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by nitrogen on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @01:49AM (#7471833)
When you have a clear visor that you're looking through that will seamlessly super-impose exactly matched visuals to reality with enriched data... yes it wil change the world.

We need hybrid LCD/OLED displays that give us an alpha channel.

Re:Virtual Reality is going to change the world by andypants on Wednesday March 26, 2014 @12:16PM (#7474422)
> When you have a clear visor that you're looking through that will seamlessly super-impose exactly matched visuals to reality with enriched data

That's augmented reality (google glass), not virtual reality (oculus rift).