News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by Theodores on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:09AM (#7452661)
They should just go straight to Android - nice touchscreen drivers, 3G, that Dalvik thing - what more is needed apart from a few device drivers to spit the money out?
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by brudgers on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:12AM (#7452901)
Tooling to integrate with a COBOL backend?

Bankers and ATM manufacturers ain't morons. They aren't using Windows XP out of ignorance. ATM's have been widely deployed in the US since about 1980 and it's the last version of Windows that runs old 16 bit code directly.

It is not as if banks have an aversion to Linux. What they are averse to is risk. Reimplementation requires testing for a level of robustness well to the north of MtGox. Multi-touch pinch to zoom doesn't matter- ATM's require physical buttons for handicap accessibility [by law in the US].

Disrupting banks isn't about ATM's. It's about new financial structures.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by NameNickHN on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:56AM (#7453008)
> Bankers and ATM manufacturers ain't morons.

Moron is perhaps a harsh word but it's been known to the public when Microsoft will stop supporting Windows XP. They had years to prepare. And they are multi billion dollar corporations. How can they have dropped the ball with this?

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by brudgers on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:26AM (#7453224)
What is the ball they dropped?

Please show me the comparative risk analysis of sticking with XP after support ends versus rewriting an existing code base across fleets of machines that not only spit cash but are also hardwired into the electronic transfer systems.

I''ll stipulate that coming across as a brogrammer friendly workplace doesn't count.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by zanny on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:03AM (#7453333)
The thing is they weren't updating their ATM software anyway, and they were always on isolated subnets. Why would you care if support is dropped?
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by keithpeter on Sunday March 23, 2014 @08:08AM (#7453038)
Time taken to certify a more recent version of the OS? Time needed to sort out a 16bit backend?

I don't know, I'm just thinking of possible reasons. Same as in the good old NHS in the UK [1] and especially the comment at [2].

[1] http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/03/20/doh_microsoft_nhs_on...

[2] http://forums.theregister.co.uk/forum/1/2014/03/20/doh_micro...

and

http://forums.theregister.co.uk/forum/2/2014/03/20/doh_micro...

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by test1235 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @08:51AM (#7453130)
No one's dropped the ball - everyone's ignored it as someone else's problem as it's a maintenance issue, not one for direct profit. Same as for the y2k and and IPv4 problems. Outside of IT, it's probably the same for global warming. There's probably a special/psychological term for this.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by brokenparser on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:10AM (#7453182)
Procrastination?
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by bsder on Monday March 24, 2014 @12:49AM (#7456765)
They didn't drop the ball.

Every single manager did a quick analysis, worked out that the upgrade would cost "Holy shit, how much of my budget?", and punted down the road in the hope that someone else would have to eat the cost.

And, Microsoft will probably extend support (for a big chunk of money) after the big companies scream enough.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by jrabone on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:57AM (#7453556)
XP Embedded != XP Retail
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by tluyben2 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:16AM (#7452674)
I must say I really agree on this one; solid coding environment made for touch, energy friendly, small footprint, easy to use, lot of programmers. But... Is there actually a company who does support for it? As I understand that's not Google. I mean they develop on it, but who can I call/contact 24/7 with issues? So someone needs to do that anyway.

If I would be into POS systems still they would be Android anyway. Makes all the sense in the world.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by Zigurd on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:46AM (#7453273)
Yes, there are multiple systems integrators who can create and support embedded Android devices. It's not too complicated to keep up with AOSP if you didn't go overboard with OS mods.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by zurn on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:06AM (#7452892)
No security updates after next versions ships...
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by kalleboo on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:27AM (#7452944)
Easy! Just run CyanogenMod nightlies on the ATM...
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by kiallmacinnes on Sunday March 23, 2014 @08:27AM (#7453077)
Haha yea, that was my first thought when someone suggested android ;)

I'm an android fan.. But, I just don't see it for something like ATMs.

ATMs need physical buttons for disabled users, so the whole touchscreen thing is a no go. They need experienced, stood the test of time, companies to provide support over the 10-15 year lifetime. They need reliable and auditable source code, so the less code, the better. In other words, they need something that's not android.

The Linux kernel makes a lot of sense given these requirements, paired with a bare minimal userspace and graphics stack, they can likely make good on their existing hardware until it either ceases up or simply can't support new standards like Chip+PIN.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by brokenparser on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:18AM (#7453199)
NanoBSD would be easier to audit than anything Linux based. Once it's booted, you can physically disconnect the write pin of your storage device. If you can manage to dump the contents of it externally to the host, you can then compare checksums to see if anything has been compromised.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by bradyd on Sunday March 23, 2014 @01:54PM (#7454252)
> Once it's booted, you can physically disconnect the write pin of your storage device.

Does this mean it requires someone on site to boot the machine? I could see that might not be an issue for ATMs, as they are usually located near banks. It might be an issue for remote locations, though.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by TD-Linux on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:50PM (#7454481)
You can use a write-once hardware register at the end of the boot sequence for similar effect.

But you can actually just leave the entire sector write only, even on boot. This is what most embedded Linux systems do - the entire rootfs is read only, /tmp and the like are on a ramdisk, and only a small writable partition remains for things like logs. In fact, Linksys routers didn't even have a writable filesystem - they stored all their settings on a separate EEPROM.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by brokenparser on Sunday March 23, 2014 @03:31PM (#7454690)
> You can use a write-once hardware register at the end of the boot sequence for similar effect.

Or use a turn-key switch. First put it into II, wait for the boot sequence to complete, switch back to I. Yes, that does require someone to be on site but that tends to happen anyway when someone restarts the ATM in the first place. If you want to update the software remotely, you could download it into ramdisk and run it from there. For the base system, you'll want something robust so it's more or less guaranteed to get to the point where you can manage it remotely. And you could verify the downloaded application bits against a locally installed root certificate.

The old MS-Windows-based ATMs may be rebooted daily, but let's face it, that's just because Windows. When the base system has to be updated for some reason, a service technician will have to physically replace the storage device for it. If that happens very often, they're either doing it wrong or I'd recommend against such a setup. But perhaps the vendor can charge for the service, in which case /care ;)

Or they could turn the key into II every last Monday of the month for example (the ATM would go into maintenance mode) at a certain time and let the big maintenance server do its work overnight, avoiding the situation altogether at the cost of a slightly greater risk that the machine becomes defective.

In any case, a tiny embedded OS would be perfect for the job.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by e12e on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:05AM (#7452890)
I wasn't aware Android had drivers, I thought Linux had drivers, and Android was mostly a userland?
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by gambiting on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:12AM (#7452900)
I think you are misunderstanding something here. Android runs on a modified linux kernel - and that kernel can load drivers like any other. You make a distinction here as if Android was just this thing running on top of the kernel - it's not, the kernel is absolutely essential and part of Android. So yes, following the logic of this, Android absolutely does support drivers.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by e12e on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:15AM (#7452915)
The kernel is GPL, drivers for "Android+Linux" are also available under Linux -- afaik there isn't an "Android ABI" making the porting of "Android" drivers much of a port at all?

[edit: I suppose things might be a little (but only a little wrt drivers) worse than I thought, given eg:

http://lwn.net/Articles/481661/ ]

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by Nux on Sunday March 23, 2014 @06:28AM (#7452811)
How well does Android fair on x86? (I'm assuming that's what most ATMs use)
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by josteink on Sunday March 23, 2014 @06:31AM (#7452822)
Very well. It does better than most version of both Windows and Linux as far as smoothing and responsiveness goes. It runs well on much less resources.

It does have some quirks when trying to use it with software designed for swiping in mind and a keyboard and mouse, but that's probably not going to be an issue here.

I say Android could be a good choice, and it will also give them a migration path from X86 should they later on want to.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by gambiting on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:13AM (#7452905)
There is plenty of phones and tablets which run ultra-ultra low voltage of intel x86 CPUs and run Android - they are almost always faster and more energy efficient than their ARM counterparts.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by geekxworld on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:24AM (#7452691)
Clever suggestion! Android seems perfect, almost as if it was made for ATMs. Plus, it is based on Linux, which is extremely secure.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by ekianjo on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:30AM (#7452702)
> Plus, it is based on Linux, which is extremely secure.

Linux the kernel, I would say, to avoid ambiguity. And second, I'm not sure what you refer to when you say "extremely secure" but even Linux had its share of issues recently (GnuTLS library).

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by tsahyt on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:57AM (#7452754)
The beauty about Linux (and a lot of well-maintained open source software) is that security flaws are usually patched rather quickly -- with the possible exception of the disaster that is X, but Wayland is coming along nicely.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by ekianjo on Sunday March 23, 2014 @06:07AM (#7452769)
> patched rather quickly

For offline equipments, not sure how likely they would be patched, though.

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by gambiting on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:15AM (#7452914)
I don't know why you are getting downvoted - ATMs are never connected to the Internet directly, they connect to the bank either using a built in modem(yes, the dial-up variety) or their own VPN systems. So it's extremely unlikely, if not just impossible for them to be downloading their own software updates, unless they are published by the bank for the machines to download.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by hueving on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:21PM (#7454359)
I didn't downvote, but I'm guessing it's because the majority of vulnerabilities are irrelevant if the thing is not connected to the Internet.
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by e12e on Sunday March 23, 2014 @07:04AM (#7452886)
There have been a few bugs that have been patched, but turned out to have been introduce quite a while before they were reported and patched. That doesn't mean they were not found long before they were reported/fixed, though.

I agree that free software seems to be very much responsive to disclosed issues though, and while many vendors (perhaps especially Microsoft) have gotten a lot better lately, the image remains (rightly or not) that closed source companies move (too) slow when it comes to patching security issues.

(Part of that is quality control, patching one bug tends to introduce/expose more)

Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by hueving on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:31PM (#7454401)
Not to be too pedantic, but the GnuTLS library isn't "Linux the kernel".
Re:ATM operators eye Linux as alternative to Windows XP by yitchelle on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:26AM (#7453417)
Sounds like a great idea. One question whether Android would need to go through some type of certification for financial applications?