News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by colechristensen on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:10PM (#7450661)
Sometimes I think back and ask myself if all of this progress in web standards has really got us anywhere. What can we do now that couldn't be done 20 years ago (putting aside connection speed) and is all of this progress really worth the trouble.

It makes a person want to start over, from scratch while keeping it simple adding as little as possible. Of course something like that would have to be done extraordinarily well to be worth it at all to avoid https://xkcd.com/927/

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by dasil003 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:24PM (#7450731)
It's a nice dream, but even if you had that power to go back and time you'd probably just make other mistakes.

There isn't an intelligence capable of designing big open standards like the web, rather they only move forward by natural selection, much like terrestrial life has.

In the end I think we've gotten some pretty remarkable things this way, remember before the web there was no such thing as cross-platform, instantly-available globally, and accessible to any person with any disability multimedia. Few people seem to recognize how much of an accomplishment this is: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uEY58fiSK8E

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by clarry on Sunday March 23, 2014 @05:16AM (#7452673)
> There isn't an intelligence capable of designing big open standards like the web

I think the problem here is big.

How about small standards with a limited scope? I don't want these huge standards that take millions of lines of code to implement.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by dasil003 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @06:53AM (#7452864)
That's exactly what the web is! It's made up of hundreds of such small standards plus thousands of ad-hoc implementations, solutions, and deep supporting infrastructure.

Again, the point is it's too big to be designed.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by clarry on Sunday March 23, 2014 @09:11AM (#7453187)
Yes exactly, too big is exactly what it is. And my point was that it could be small. In practice of course we'd never even agree on a definition of what the web is or what it should be, so even the idea of designing a compact standard for it is hopeless.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by yuhong on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:44PM (#7450811)
Yea, that is why WHATWG HTML is a "living standard". In fact, I am thinking that even the "HTML5" buzzword is a misnomer.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by seagreen on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:25PM (#7450734)
We have gotten somewhere -- the web has become a decent program delivery system.

In the process it's degraded pretty badly as a document delivery system. If you start over I recommend separating those two projects.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by nandhp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:20PM (#7450958)
Well, we tried that for awhile. The web was mainly good for documents and if you had a program it was done with Flash.

And then people were making websites entirely in Flash.

And then people realized that was a bad idea because Mobile, and everything got better.

Until the App Store came along. Fine, so now program delivery has been separated from document delivery, but every document provider that used to just be a website now requires you to use a special program from the App Store instead of using a web browser or some other generic "document viewer". Or, at the very least, you have to tell them you don't want it every time you visit their website.

The problem isn't that the web is a bad document delivery system -- it's not. The problem isn't even that the web is just as good at delivering programs as it is at delivering documents. The problem is that there are a large number of people who know nothing about best practices and are way too enthusiastic about making things look flashy. They create documents and they don't care how you want them to look. If that means they have to create a Program instead of a Document, that's fine with them.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by keeshawn on Saturday March 22, 2014 @05:27PM (#7450985)
Download our app, and let us read your entire contact list and send out SMS messages as you, and read and post to Facebook as you, and do whatever else we want to anything for any reason.

(Accept)

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by pjmlp on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:16PM (#7450686)
It just made us lost the sense where to go, by re-inventing, badly, what was already possible on the desktop with Hypercard and similar systems.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by sequence7 on Saturday March 22, 2014 @11:21PM (#7451967)
> Sometimes I think back and ask myself if all of this progress in web standards has really got us anywhere. > What can we do now that couldn't be done 20 years ago (putting aside connection speed) and is all of this progress really worth the trouble.

Well let's see if we can make a short list:

1) Can I look up almost anything? Yes [0]

2) Can I learn a foreign language for free? Yes [1]

3) Can I fund something interesting? Yes [2]

4) Can I communicate with my family and friends for free? Yes [3]

5) Can I learn stuff for free? Yes [4]

Seriously I didn't even try, yes progress has got us somewhere. Admittedly we do now have n+1 standards

[0] http://wikipedia.org

[1] http://duolingo.com

[2] http://kickstarter.com

[3] Honestly there are so many - email, skype, facebook, whatsapp, etc ...

[4] http://khanacademy.com

edit - edited

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by Jtsummers on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:01AM (#7452322)
As others said, all that could be done in the 90s modulo the bandwidth (specifically important for Khan Academy). But we don't even have to go back that far to get broken sites. IE 8 (released in 2009), forced on many corporate workers, is unable to render many "modern" sites. Some specific examples that I've encountered: Lifehacker & kin - multiple content blocks overlapping, rendering the main content unreadable; NPR - home page totally broken, can't get to different news categories; GigaOM - ARTICLES ARE PRESENTED IN ALL CAPS FOR NO GOOD REASON, AS IF THE AUTHOR WANTED TO SHOUT AT ME FOR USING SUCH AN OLD BROWSER.

And your 4) we could do that in the 90s as well. Email isn't a 21st century invention and doesn't depend on web technologies. Same with instant messengers. Skype - for video, bandwidth is the thing the 90s lacked to support this system. WhatsApp - widespread mobile devices was necessary for this, 90s lacked that. And none of them, other than Facebook, is wholly dependent on web stuffs, they're internet technologies and platforms.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by saurik on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:55AM (#7452199)
I presume the point is not what was already built but what was possible: Wikis have existed for a very long time, and nothing about Wikipedia seems difficult to do with very old versions of Netscape.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by userbinator on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:17AM (#7452361)
Also, email and IRC were available before HTTP/HTML, so people were definitely able to communicate over the Internet, in realtime or otherwise, even before they were viewing Web pages.

Indeed all those sites mentioned are just manifestations of an idea that is really independent of any "progress in web standards", and had someone thought of the idea 20 years ago, they could've just as easily (or maybe even more easily - because of the relative lack of complexity back then) set up a site for it.

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by colechristensen on Sunday March 23, 2014 @12:54AM (#7452193)
Which of those wasn't possible in 1995 with a modern Internet connection? I posit that everything you describe would have been entirely possible with a little less polished appearance 15-20 years ago and that there could be real strong value in starting over and keeping things simple.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by hippee-lee on Sunday March 23, 2014 @10:43AM (#7453497)
Duolingo - because it's not just me learning Spanish, it's us translating English only websites to Spanish. Perhaps I'm not versed enough in the services available in '94 - I didn't really start to use the internet much until college when I got access to the computer labs. Was there something like it around then? I say this because the most impressive thing to me about duolingo ( and the captcha system designed by its founder before it ) is the efficient way to leverages different individual goals to aggregate really large differences for both individuals. Ie the person wanting to learn a new language for free and the person with an English only website that needs to get it translated into multiple languages.
Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by morbius on Saturday March 22, 2014 @09:21PM (#7451665)
This site actually chronicles the terribleness of the modern web quite perfectly. Warning: NSFW.

http://motherfuckingwebsite.com

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by jedrek on Monday March 24, 2014 @08:31AM (#7457811)
> What can we do now that couldn't be done 20 years ago (putting aside connection speed) and is all of this progress really worth the trouble.

Well, I know your 20 years is hyperbole, but let's see:

1) We can display video and play sounds. We can do it using native browser controls now, but in 1994 you couldn't do it at all - plugins weren't introduced until Netscape Navigator 2.0 which came out a year later.

2) We can display updated data without reloading the entire website. This let's us do stuff like chat or use collaborative tools.

3) We can disassociate content from styling, so styling data can be transmitted once and can be changed en masse with ease.

4) Cookies showed up 19 1/2 years ago, so you wouldn't be able to store user login data without it showing up in the URL - it makes sending URLs to other people very awkward.

5) Oh wait, you wouldn't be able to log in because forms weren't in the HTML spec yet, HTML 2.0 didn't come out til 1995.

6) We can actually... do layouts of web content. Tables didn't come around til HTML 3.0.

The initial version of the web was pretty much a prettier version of Gopher - with some inline graphics and styling. This site in would not be able to exist in 1994, unless you wanted to submit comments via email?

Re:Surfing the Modern Web with Ancient Browsers by kmfrk on Saturday March 22, 2014 @04:50PM (#7450825)
CSS has always been a hack, and the web we have today as a result of competing browser rendering however the hell they want based on their popularity - and the popularity of any co-developed devices - is just about the only thing that can make me countenance communism as a web developer.

Having said that, it's possible that we might be in for a second era of webdesign, as MS retire support of XP and the browsers that have dragged down web development.