Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by timmaah on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @12:15PM
(#743665)
Once the user has filled in anything then the label is completely lost. How is that better then having the label above or to the right where it is always viewable?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by alabut on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @12:33PM
(#743694)
It's sort of lost - the info is still there in the form of the information they entered, which is a pretty strong hint. You're not likely to forget your name or website url, for example.
You still have a point about the usability of labels outside the form field, especially given the caveat in the article that "this plugin still has problems when the browser tries to pre-fill the fields".
But it's still a useful technique because it makes the labels a lot easier to read because it's possible to left-align both the labels and the input fields. Just to give you a sense on how much thought needs to go into the graphic design of labels and form fields, here's a breakdown of the pros and cons behind labels arranged vertically, left-justified and right-justified:
http://www.lukew.com/resources/articles/web_forms.html
There's so much to learn about form design that the guy milked into an entire book.
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by teej on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @02:00PM
(#743892)
LukeW did a talk in March that goes in to more depth then that article. It's definitely worth listening to: http://www.lukew.com/ff/entry.asp?794
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by dcneiner on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @01:45PM
(#743866)
The link has great info. Thanks!
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by pmichaud on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @12:36PM
(#743702)
I think it just saves space in applications where UI space is scarce. It's also a useless trick that amateurs can abuse for fun. Yay!
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by oneplusone on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @01:13PM
(#743784)
A plugin such as this has a very limited and specific set of use cases. The most obvious one being a search box that says search inside, but once it receives focus it goes away.
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by arockwell on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @03:20PM
(#744044)
What's worse is that this doesn't gracefully degrade. If you have javascript disabled your text will be written over top the label text and is completely unreadable.
Re:In-Field Labels: A Better Way + jQuery Plugin
by rapind on Wednesday August 05, 2009 @04:01PM
(#744120)
Well instead of styling all labels in the css, you could create a css class for the overlay effect and then add that class to the labels (all or just some etc.) on the form with jquery. That way it's unobtrusive javascript and works when javascript is disabled without mucking up your form.