News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by ChuckMcM on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @01:06PM (#7430136)
"5% of gross revenue resulting from sales to users."

As others have pointed out, that is a huge amount, that is probably 25 - 30% of your "profit". The accounting is pretty easy though. Units * SRP * 0.05 == royalty.

That said, it is a lot simpler than investing $25 - $30K up front while building the game, only to have it go poof because the market or your designer flaked out. Figure 3 year development at $20/month that is less than $1,000 at risk. This gets people using their engine early and often perhaps hoping they can negotiate a different royalty later on. It would also be interesting to see if it had a cap, like $1M or something.

Kudos to the Epic folks for coming up with a pretty creative strategy in todays market.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by adventured on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @01:16PM (#7430212)
Access to Unreal Engine 3's underlying source code cost hundreds of thousands of dollars previously (the CryEngine will run you over a million). You could also license v3, with no access to native code, for $99 and they took a % of sales after $50,000 if I recall. So this is a massive upfront savings in the use case where you need access to the engine code itself.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by jamie_ca on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @01:36PM (#7430357)
Previous licensing was along the lines of 25% of net profit after $50k. Plus $100 for access to the dev kit.

I call it a wash, but the lower numbers (5 vs 25, 19 vs 100) make for some good marketing. And full access to the source is new and welcome.

Also I'm not sure if this change to their royalty scheme will make any difference to their flat $400k-per-game license that the big studios probably use.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by je42 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @03:05PM (#7430927)
Gross revenue is way easier to calculate than profit. I like these terms much better.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by josefresco on Thursday March 20, 2014 @11:33AM (#7436137)
Not only is it easier to calculate, it protects them from publishers who claim no profit due to "expenses".
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by je42 on Sunday March 23, 2014 @02:54PM (#7454500)
Yep. aka "Hollywood accounting".
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by gabriel34 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @07:08PM (#7432507)
Not so fast. Retailers' gross is SRP*Units. Dev's gross is what the next link in the supply chain pays him. That is still true in today's distribution model since Apple/Play/Steam store take some cut of the retail price and pays you the rest. One could even argue that you developing and you selling are two distinct companies and that gross is what dev you makes (actually they are quite distinct business functions, so I'm not bending anything here).
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by gamblor956 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @08:16PM (#7432909)
Unreal redefined "gross revenue" in the EULA for Unreal 4 Engine, so they are not using the standard meaning that's used everywhere else in the world. Their definition of "gross revenue" is actually something similar to "total retail sales."

It's a dick move on their part. They could, and should, have used a different term to avoid the confusion.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by gabriel34 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @07:12PM (#7432535)
Come to think of it, you could wrap it around a thin wrapper program and provide that as a product for a nominal fee over which you'd have to pay 5%, then develop your game over the wrapper. What is to stop anyone from doing this? Maybe the license says your product must be licensed the same way, so if the end user mods your game and sells it they too have to pay 5%.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by cdash on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @07:28PM (#7432623)
License says if you sell your game for 10 dollars on the app store and Apple takes 30% cut of that Epic is taking 5% of 10 dollars and not 5% of 7 dollars.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by gabriel34 on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @08:29PM (#7432961)
Seems you are right:

"When releasing a product using UE4, you're signing up to pay Epic 5% of gross product revenue from users, regardless of what company collects the revenue. That means: If your game makes $10 on the App Store, Apple may pay you $7, but you'd pay Epic $0.50 (5% of $10)."

Still, you'd have to legally define end customer because you could have, as I pointed out, much more complex cases. I didn't search much, but couldn't find the actual fine print license to see how they did it, but they probably did it well and ironclad and don't need legal advice from a guy with no formal legal education. I stand humbled.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by sseveran on Thursday March 20, 2014 @01:59AM (#7434118)
All these types of deals (even not in the game industry) use gross revenue since anything else can be manipulated.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by njharman on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @07:34PM (#7432657)
> What is to stop anyone from doing this?

Being the guy who gets to spend tens to hundreds of thousands in legal fees to convince jury they aren't just trying to cheat someone out of their royalty.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by sixothree on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @01:45PM (#7430425)
I wonder if you can choose a different model if your game becomes more successful.
Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by TheCraiggers on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @02:25PM (#7430685)
I doubt it. You've already "bought in" and agreed to their terms. They have you by the contractual balls at that point. The fact that your game is exceedingly popular and raking in cash makes the contract you've already agreed to worth more, not less.

You'd have to find something that they would think was a better deal. Like "I pay you lump sum $X in exchange for no more royalty payments. At which point, it becomes a gamble for both sides.

You have a much better chance of negotiating something like that before your game even begins development. Expect to spend a metric ton of cash on that license deal, however.

Re:Welcome to Unreal Engine 4 by enjo on Wednesday March 19, 2014 @03:27PM (#7431108)
This seems like an attempt to cash-in on the next Minecraft more than anything else. They want to come along for the ride when someone hits the jackpot. That's the whole point.