News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by smokeyj on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:54AM (#7380003)
Did you know walking is the leading cause of taxi cab unemployment? You should really consider the ugly nature of walking next time you decide not to cab it up. Taxis cost money, and their kids eat food.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:01PM (#7380069)
The difference between taking a taxi and walking are significant. For your analogy to work you must alter it in one of two ways:

1. You hijack the taxi and demand the driver take you to your destination for free. This creates an equivalent or better experience for the consumer at zero or near-zero cost.

2. Instead of clicking a button and watching 12 Years a Slave, you get a crudely animated version pieced together by drawings crowdsourced from 1st grade students around the nation, and voiced entirely by Gilbert Gottfried.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by smokeyj on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:29PM (#7380311)
The reason I think my analogy applies is because "pirating" costs cameramen nothing. You can measure their net worth before and after I pirate a movie and it will be the same. The same is not true of bumming a taxi ride.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by earbitscom on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:47PM (#7380459)
For this comparison to be effective you have to measure their net worth, inclusive of their time available to earn an income (which has value), prior to making the movie. If they "spend" that time on being a cameraman in order to earn income and the movie studio has to pay less because free loaders keep watching the movies without paying, you have cost them money.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:02PM (#7380560)
A cameraman's salary is paid by the movie's budget, which is effectively a loan against the projected future earnings of a film.

Sure the cameraman already got paid for the film you just pirated, but if said film doesn't earn enough then the studio will decide to make fewer films or go bankrupt, either of which could cost the cameraman their job and significantly reduce future earning potential.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by nightski on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @02:36PM (#7381264)
But if the movie wasn't worth any money to said person in the first place, then maybe it isn't such a big loss. Maybe some just do not value cinema entertainment very much even though they may watch a movie.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @04:50PM (#7382025)
Absolutely. Certainly the hypothetical cameraman has no inherent right to be paid to do whatever they want to do, I only assert that the so-called utopian pirate market is incapable of sustaining cinema without drastic changes to the business.

Not to say those changes aren't currently necessary, only that if everyone chose to pirate rather than pay then all of Hollywood would likely just shut down rather than keep throwing $100+m AAA blockbusters into a financial abyss.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by a8000 on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:57PM (#7383490)
Hollywood shutting down would not be a huge loss to the world. Movies of cultural value could still be funded and then be made available to the public.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @10:19AM (#7385725)
That's a highly debatable point. People's definitions of cultural value differ wildly, and the sort of violence and humor that many people find entertaining would be difficult to justify seeking public funding for.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by chrismcb on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @02:39AM (#7384292)
It might not be worth any "money" BUT it was worth something to the person who pirated. As they watched the movie. It had SOME value to them.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by freyr on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:51PM (#7383473)
"pirating" costs cameramen nothing.

If only one person thinks that way, and pirates a movie, your statement holds true.

If 1,000 people think that way, it probably still holds true.

Extending this, however, you reach an obvious tipping point, where a critical mass of people pirate the movie and the production costs are not recouped (and the cameraman is out of work and his children starve in the street).

It's the logical conclusion of your line of thinking. What if everybody believed pirating the movies they want to watch will not affect the cameramen. What if nobody paid for the movies they're watching? Obviously, high-budget movies would no longer be possible, and we'd all be reduced to watching shoe-string-budget art house shlock (I know, I know... Primer).

Obviously, that is not sustainable. So what makes you special? Why should you not pay for the movie you're watching, while other people should foot the bill?

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by albedoa on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @03:05PM (#7381431)
> 1. You hijack the taxi and demand the driver take you to your destination for free. This creates an equivalent or better experience for the consumer at zero or near-zero cost.

For completeness, this is true only if the consumer prefers the taxi ride over walking and considers it to be a better experience.

> 2. Instead of clicking a button and watching 12 Years a Slave, you get a crudely animated version pieced together by drawings crowdsourced from 1st grade students around the nation, and voiced entirely by Gilbert Gottfried.

A counterpoint to this is Primer ($7,000 budget, 70% RT, 7.0 IMDb): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Primer_(film)

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by kisielk on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:23PM (#7380261)
#2 (or something pretty close to it...) worked pretty well for http://ourrobocopremake.com/
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by nnnnni on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:09PM (#7380139)
#2 actually sounds kinda interesting...
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:12PM (#7380174)
I'd certainly watch it, but I don't see it winning any Oscars...
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by mcv on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:06PM (#7380106)
If taxis go out of business, you can still walk. If people stop making new movies, you can't watch new movies.

(You can still watch old movies of course, so if you restrict your downloading to old movies, and not fairly recent releases, your argument works.)

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by Zikes on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:10PM (#7380157)
I often wonder what would happen if the de facto standard in an industry were to disappear overnight. If taxis disappeared, would more people find ways to participate in carpool/rideshare systems?

If we stopped making new movies, would people learn to appreciate older classical films they'd never considered before? Surely there have already been more movies produced than a person could consume in a single lifetime, though it's debatable whether or not most of them are worth viewing at all.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by gizmo686 on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:51PM (#7380486)
Movies are still a new enough medium that there quality is still improving, so current movies tend to be better then those from a decade ago, and (likely) worse then those a decade from now.

Once the medium platues (or long enough after to build up a supply), then this would work.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by footpath on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @01:04PM (#7380584)
By better than, I hope you were referring to the image quality and special effects. In terms of filming techniques and the actual content of the movies, I do not think films made decades ago are categorically worse than films made today.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by whiddershins on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @04:06PM (#7381788)
A great book about this is Concerning the Spiritual in Art by Wassily Kandinsky http://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/5321

The argument being that art is intensely connected to the time in which it is created, and the function of art in the context of the progression of humanity requires that artists constantly make new art for the current generation.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by bduerst on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @02:28PM (#7381180)
I doubt it.

It's not like people are making professional-grade movies now in the free time, as they are now driving around cities with their own cars. Likewise, not everyone is trained to make movies as most adults are already trained to drive cars.

Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by dllthomas on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @02:30PM (#7381201)
The big thing that slips is relevance. Culture moves.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by freyr on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @11:59AM (#7380048)
If you hopped in the taxi cab, rode to your destination, and jumped out without paying the posted fare, you'd have a point.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by steveklabnik on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @12:52PM (#7380494)
While infinite other people are able to also use the same taxi.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by freyr on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:23PM (#7383386)
Sure, and infinite other people screw the driver. Oh, I suppose some people will pay the posted fare for their ride. As long as it doesn't have to be us, right?
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by a8000 on Tuesday March 11, 2014 @09:59PM (#7383497)
The point is that digital copies cost (almost) nothing, so by standard market principles you would not expect to pay something.
Re:Popcorn Time – Watch torrent movies instantly by freyr on Wednesday March 12, 2014 @02:35AM (#7384283)
I understand the reasoning, but I believe it is flawed for two reasons:

First, you're confusing the cost of distribution with the total cost of creating media. While digitization has driven down distribution costs, it doesn't affect the tens or hundreds of millions of dollars that a typical movie costs to produce. Just because you can download a movie from a server to your laptop for free, does the cost suddenly cost nothing to produce? Of course not.

Second, the scenario we're discussing does not reflect traditional free markets. Conventionally, a seller offers a product or service, and if the seller and a buyer agree on a price, there's an exchange. Basic supply and demand.

Technology now allows buyers to set the price of certain services to zero against the wishes of the seller, and the seller is powerless to stop the transaction. Clearly, this is not a conventional free market scenario, and we may need new principles.