Also, on the topic of getting distracted - they might work some of the time, but I think pop ups that nag you for your email address are bullshit.
There are obviously exceptions (YC is one of them), however the point of this article is to point out the rampant bait-and-switch that has emerged from me-too incubators.
From Y Combinator's google profile: "Y Combinator is an American seed accelerator, started in March 2005."
From TechStars: "TechStars is a mentorship-driven startup accelerator founded by..."
There's a difference.
Most incubators in my area mainly focus on cheap rent, hotdesking, and basic infrastructure. Nothing like what you're taking issue with.
So the whole thing is confusing.
I have tried to define X and it had absolutely no effect on the "pro/con" comments I had.
Its not what you write it's what people put into it.
I wrote this way back
http://000fff.org/getting-to-the-customer-why-everything-you...
Check the comments and I even went through the hassle of defining it.
Someone even made a presentation about how I was wrong (and called me a tool :) )
http://www.slideshare.net/joystik/response-towhyeverythingyo...
So I say. Better to simplify (within reason of course) and then add details in the discussion.
But each to their own.
However, calling something bullshit with unsupported assertions is, well, bullshit.
Even among people who run accelerators, incubators, and other types of programs, there is a lot of debate over where the lines begin, end, etc.
Instead of saying "incubators are bullshit" why not just saying "Doing bullshit is bullshit" since that seems to be the actual point of this post. Don't do unproductive stuff that doesn't actually advance your startup. Great. That advice is just as appropriate for outside of incubator people as those within an incubator.
For example, while reading this article I just kept getting distracted from the actual main point - many incubators just provide low cost office space. Is that bullshit? Many incubators aren't actually accelerators like the author seems to confuse the term with. Is that bullshit?
I remember reading an article from the New Yorker where they talked about making fun of wannabe authors who just sit around and do everything that authors are supposed to do except write. They called this "writering" and it seems like the author is trying to say the same thing about "startuping". Good. But that problem will always exist, regardless of whatever incubator you're in or not in.
So maybe we should focus on the actual problem instead of just blasting a straw man, hoping for clicks?