News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by spindritf on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:58AM (#7359913)
Or, people who needlessly went to college take jobs they would be doing anyway.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by rayiner on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:10AM (#7360241)
And the savvy kids who skipped college now can't get the job they'd otherwise have because employers think: "why hire him when we can get a college graduate for the job?" I think too many people go to college, but credential inflation isn't something you can opt out of. You shouldn't need a college degree to be an office assistant, but when the market is flooded with college graduates willing to work that job, you don't stand a chance.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by raverbashing on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:23AM (#7360316)
"why hire him when we can get a college graduate for the job?"

Maybe the market will some day find that the ones that didn't go to college are valuable as well, usually know how to deal with unexpected situations better and learned more things "on the job" while the college ones were dabbing in theory.

Theoretical studies are nice, but it's one thing to study something theoretically, another, to experience it.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by danielweber on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:37AM (#7360407)
The market can still irrational longer than you can stay unemployed. :(

That's assuming that the college degree is a worthless signal, BTW. The scary thing is that the college degree probably is a useful signal. It's an insanely expensive one in terms of time and money, though. And after you finish your undergraduate, you may find out that there is a new, more expensive, longer signal that you are expected to complete to be an office assistant.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jerf on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:40AM (#7360432)
You're misfiring on the "theory" bashing there. The whole theory-practice argument comes from whether given a desire to learn subject X, it's better to study for a while before practicing or jump straight to practice.

When the argument is whether it's better to study an entirely different X or jump straight to practicing Y, if the goal is to get better at Y there's no argument. The problem isn't that the college students were "studying theory", it's that they were on the wrong thing entirely for where they ended up. They're not going to get paid better for their subject X theory.

(And it's a dumb argument since the correct answer is "both at the same time to the extent possible", which at least the computer science programs have definitely picked up on in the last 15-20 years. And knowing the Internet as I do, the "to the extent possible" words are not extraneous... obviously we are not going to put a brain surgeon in a brain on day one of school, OK?)

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by levosmetalo on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:30AM (#7360377)
That's comparing apples and oranges. There's no reason someone will take someone that didn't go to college instead of someone that did if both are equally inexperienced.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by malyk on Friday March 07, 2014 @03:25PM (#7362532)
And while "the market" is trying to figure this out a generation of people are suffering with no/minimal income, no real safety net, etc.

The market is great, but you can't just sit around and wait for it to figure things out while real people are suffering from its inefficiencies.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by rayiner on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:35AM (#7360401)
Employers have very little incentive to look beyond their usual filters for "diamonds in the rough." Especially when it comes to lower-level, lower-paying positions.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by bennyg on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:32AM (#7360387)
Well, if they spent those four years at one place of work, then they're probably the college graduates' supervisor.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by rayiner on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:42AM (#7360443)
In this economy, they never got the entry-level position to begin with, because four years ago they were an 18 year old with a high school education competing against 22 year olds with college degrees.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by bennyg on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:48AM (#7360484)
Maybe. I'm talking about being a bar manager, or movie theater manager, etc.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by rayiner on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:57AM (#7360531)
Fair enough. I'm thinking of all the office jobs that used to be within the reach of non-college graduates not too long ago.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by vacri on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:58AM (#7360535)
I think my brain just got a new fold in it, from trying to imagine someone whose target job was being a McDonald's Corp drone being described as 'savvy'.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by rayiner on Friday March 07, 2014 @10:03AM (#7360574)
McDonald's Corp drone is a good fucking job. Programmers and management consultants have made lower-level service jobs hellish, with demand scheduling and highly regimented workflows. A corp drone gets to sit at a desk, won't get fired for being a few minutes late, and might even get health insurance!
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by lucasnemeth on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:51AM (#7360142)
Do you sincerely think History is a complete waste of time, a useless human endeavor?

You see... It would be great if people had better history/sociology knowledge, I don't know about you, but I don't want to live in a technocratic dystopia. The fact that these fields are seem as "useless" is a terrible thing.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by turnip1979 on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:03AM (#7360203)
Studying history is not a useless endeavor. Taking a 100K loan to do it is.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Dirlewanger on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:58AM (#7360174)
No one's picking on history speficially, relax...the bigger point is that in the past decade or so high schools across the US have been needlessly pushing everyone to at least strongly consider college, and many buy into the hype. Why do you think roughly only 30% graduate? Some just are not cut out for that pace.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Kurtz79 on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:14AM (#7360263)
Absolutely not, history, literature, sociology, arts are incredibly important.

But we live (at least US/Western countries) in a capitalist society, like it or not.

This means that the monetary value of your skills is directly linked only to the monetary value they can generate, not other types of value that undoubtedly they have.

People choosing to study humanities must be prepared to face a job market where their skills are not in great demand.

Then again, money is not everything.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Perdition on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:04AM (#7360212)
Why do you need to go to university to to improve your knowledge of history or sociology?

A degree in history or sociology is seen as useless because it mostly is outside academia. The people who are good in the field will most likely end up on the academic track, and those who aren't will most likely end up in low paying jobs having wasted several years and tens of thousands of dollars.

The problem isn't history or sociology degrees, it is people thinking that a degree is a ticket to a good job.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jrs99 on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:23AM (#7360318)
But the guy in the article wants to be a High School teacher. It's not like the guy wants to be some historian at some institution. And a college degree is probably something you really want if you want to become a High School teacher.

Is it wrong for him to think that he needs a college degree in order to teach high school? What are his chances of teaching high school WITHOUT a degree?

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Perdition on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:06PM (#7363790)
>But the guy in the article wants to be a High School teacher.

I already mentioned low-paid jobs.

Also, at least here in Australia the only pure degrees that the high-school education system cares about are maths and science, everything else is "generalist" and can be filled by any teacher. In addition, at least here a general degree isn't good enough any more, you either need a teaching degree or a graduate diploma in teaching.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jrs99 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @02:36AM (#7364557)
i wouldn't call a high school teacher a low paying job. i guess it is compared to software.

In the US at least, it sounds very reasonable to go to college to get a history degree if your goal is to become a high school history teacher.

To me, it sounds perfectly an achievable goal to decide to go to college, get a major in history, know that you're not even close to the best historians out there, and expect a job teaching high school. just like the guy in the article assumed.

Unfortunately, it didn't work out, and might have been a waste of money. But there was nothing unreasonable in his thought process, from my perspective at least. I would even bet it won't be too tough for him to get a teaching job in the future.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Perdition on Saturday March 08, 2014 @03:49AM (#7364687)
>expect a job teaching high school.

Yeah see the expectation is the problem. Here in Australia most of the people with teaching degrees are waiting for the boomers to retire, because there are very few full time positions (unless you are willing to move to the most remote and poor communities).

>But there was nothing unreasonable in his thought process, from my perspective at least.

The unreasonable thing is believing that just getting a degree will get you into a middle-class profession. That hasn't been true for at least twenty years. You need good grades, co-ops, and connections.

As the article points out the market for tertiary educated workers is smaller than the pool of tertiary educated workers.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jrs99 on Saturday March 08, 2014 @05:22AM (#7364811)
I agree. But what can you do? You're a student and want to be a high school history teacher. You might not have what it takes to be a PhD Historian. You might not get a teaching job. Still probably want to get a degree.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by bennyg on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:33AM (#7360389)
Gotta' have a teaching certificate for most public school institutions. Private schools is less formally strict in that sense, but where I'm from they struggle to keep up with the public schools - thus they require teaching certificates too.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by JanezStupar on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:32AM (#7360388)
I think that having college educated historians as high school history teachers is a terrible waste of resources.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jerf on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:47AM (#7360478)
Oh, well, good news then, if you actually examine the curriculum requirement for being a history teacher and compare it to getting a degree in straight-up history, you'll see that the teacher is not required to take anywhere near as much, and the teacher will not take the really hard history courses that grade in terms of reams of essay writing.

Some teachers take the initiative to double-major of their own free will (respect!), but it is certainly not required. When I was in school I casually assumed that my teachers knew a great deal more about the subjects than what they were teaching; when I got to University and had the opportunity to look at their curricula requirements I learned that was not true, at least not in general.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jrs99 on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:39AM (#7360424)
I think that's true for every field. Some people love degrees when they hire though.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by jlockfre on Friday March 07, 2014 @10:00AM (#7360547)
And if they're doing out of a passion for the subject? What then?
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Perdition on Friday March 07, 2014 @07:53PM (#7363737)
They should be thankful that they are privileged enough to waste the time and the money on a hobby.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by lotsofmangos on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:17AM (#7359981)
Yeah, who do they think they are? Going off and learning things willy-nilly without considering whether their increase in knowledge is economically necessary. They could have put that time to use by just starting work earlier. Not they would have got the job if they had started earlier, as it would have gone to someone with higher qualifications, no doubt also needlessly acquired of course...
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by davidw on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:27AM (#7360020)
There are plenty of ways of learning things. I consider myself as well-learned as most college-educated people I know, and I never had any student debts. I'm also incredibly lucky to be in a field where the lack of a degree is not a problem, but perhaps this will be more common in the future.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by zanny on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:31AM (#7360381)
It is also their choice to put themselves in as much debt as they want. And it is an employers choice to hire someone with a piece of paper for arbitrary reasons.

The problems aren't with trying to change the minds of millions of people, it is with reconciling a system that no longer works because we are still operating under the false tautology that human labor, of any kind, has value.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by Shivetya on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:35AM (#7360060)
Let us combine with the story earlier from the week about the SAT test being changed. Having a college education is marketed very heavily in this society and what do the ACT and SAT have use for other than determining which colleges are open to a student. With High Schools pushing these tests hard they in turn are pushing students to college even when it might not be the best choice.

Don't underestimate the power that marketing has. Between state and privates schools there is a lot of money to be had and it only keeps working if they can convince each generation that the education they provide is indispensable

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by aestra on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:26AM (#7360018)
Having a history degree doesn't exactly make you more qualified to be a bartender (going by the example in the article).
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by kokey on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:33AM (#7360047)
I'm not sure, I think in the UK it's a fairly common assumption that a history degree means you'll most likely be operating a beer tap to pay the bills. This is also useful in most pubs since they are a few centuries old.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by aestra on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:26AM (#7360341)
>in the UK it's a fairly common assumption...

This story was about the US.

>This is also useful in most pubs since they are a few centuries old.

And? I've been to a pub in the US that was 3 centuries old and thought to be the first building in the city (used to be a private residence). The building's history was probably part of the orientation, and it isn't like it is hard to memorize. Having a history degree doesn't make him more qualified to talk about it, it isn't like the history of pubs is included in the undergraduate (or even graduate) curriculum.

>assumption that a history degree means you'll most likely be operating a beer tap to pay the bills

Yea, a history degree is known to be pretty "useless" to most people who obtain one, that doesn't mean one is more qualified because they have one, it just means there is very little one can do with a history degree.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by lotsofmangos on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:58AM (#7360172)
Learning history is an end in and of itself though. You don't need to have an application in mind to justify getting a degree.
Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by danielweber on Friday March 07, 2014 @09:01AM (#7360194)
As consumption -- "I want to know about history" -- it's great.

As investment -- "I want a degree to get a better job" -- it may not be good for the individual, and for society it's probably a net negative, because the benefits to your human capital are minimal while you are putting more resources into a zero-sum status competition.

Now, it's perfectly okay to have consumption, but you shouldn't confuse it for an investment. Spending 4 years backpacking across Europe also sounds like an awesome time, another end unto itself, but you shouldn't borrow money you don't have to do it.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by lotsofmangos on Friday March 07, 2014 @11:26AM (#7361096)
Not all returns on investments are financial.

Spending money improving the level of history knowledge in a population can have paybacks that range from better national security through to the quality of art. These things are very hard to quantify and to just look on their direct financial return gives a very poor measure.

Re:College Grads Taking Low-Wage Jobs Displace Less Educated by antr on Friday March 07, 2014 @08:02AM (#7359927)
either way, those with a degree take the job – although I don't see enough data in the article to justify such title