Maybe the market will some day find that the ones that didn't go to college are valuable as well, usually know how to deal with unexpected situations better and learned more things "on the job" while the college ones were dabbing in theory.
Theoretical studies are nice, but it's one thing to study something theoretically, another, to experience it.
That's assuming that the college degree is a worthless signal, BTW. The scary thing is that the college degree probably is a useful signal. It's an insanely expensive one in terms of time and money, though. And after you finish your undergraduate, you may find out that there is a new, more expensive, longer signal that you are expected to complete to be an office assistant.
When the argument is whether it's better to study an entirely different X or jump straight to practicing Y, if the goal is to get better at Y there's no argument. The problem isn't that the college students were "studying theory", it's that they were on the wrong thing entirely for where they ended up. They're not going to get paid better for their subject X theory.
(And it's a dumb argument since the correct answer is "both at the same time to the extent possible", which at least the computer science programs have definitely picked up on in the last 15-20 years. And knowing the Internet as I do, the "to the extent possible" words are not extraneous... obviously we are not going to put a brain surgeon in a brain on day one of school, OK?)
The market is great, but you can't just sit around and wait for it to figure things out while real people are suffering from its inefficiencies.