News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by zhyder on Friday July 31, 2009 @07:49PM (#735694)
I'm impressed with how quickly the FCC is responding (and that it's responding at all). The questions are thorough and well thought-out too. There's still hope...
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by paul9290 on Friday July 31, 2009 @08:31PM (#735752)
The head of the FCC is now Julius Genowaski(sp?). He's a Internet tech guy. He's an investor and one of the principals who started the DC incubator LaunchBox Digital. I would assume he's a great proponent for net neutrality issues!
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by Scriptor on Saturday August 01, 2009 @02:13AM (#736061)
In case anyone's still interested, actual spelling is Julius Genachowski.
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by wheels on Saturday August 01, 2009 @03:23AM (#736101)
I remember being excited when I saw that he was appointed. Ironically, being as the head of the FCC co-founded a YC-ish thing, it's entirely possible that he also reads Hacker News, and almost certain that he reads TechCrunch – so it's really not surprising at all to see that they're monitoring the nerdier channels.
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by rosser on Friday July 31, 2009 @08:13PM (#735728)
My favorite part is the bit where the respondents will have to specifically justify each bit they want kept confidential. To wit: Accordingly, “blanket” requests for confidentiality of a large set of documents are unacceptable.

We may actually get some visibility into the embarrassingly capricious and opaque App Store policies.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by andreyf on Saturday August 01, 2009 @01:49AM (#736046)
We may actually get some visibility into the embarrassingly capricious and opaque App Store policies.

I wouldn't hold my breath. This just adds a lot of busywork for Apple's lawyers. I'm sure they'll justify in detail every piece they want to keep private, and the FCC isn't interesting in pissing people off by blowing their secrets.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by jacquesm on Sunday August 02, 2009 @05:02AM (#737235)
What possible reason could they have to keep things secret that should have been public in the first place ?

My guess is that this list of questions is just for openers. The answers will lead to follow up questions.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by jonursenbach on Saturday August 01, 2009 @03:23PM (#736546)
If Apple's lawyers can can justify that legally unlocking phones will lead to more drug deals and collapse of cell towers, they will be able to justify this.
Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by fauigerzigerk on Saturday August 01, 2009 @03:33AM (#736105)
I have to say it makes me a little uneasy how quickly this is happening. Isn't the market supposed to sort this out on its own?

I'm not familiar with the relevant law, so maybe I just don't understand. Is it illegal to run a proprietary phone platform and lock competitors out?. Isn't that basically what has always been the case in the pre smart phone era?

Don't get me wrong, I don't like what Apple/AT&T does and as a developer I'm not going to sign up to a platform that puts me in such a weak position. But I see that as an issue between me and Apple. I'm not sure why I need the government in it.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by stevecooperorg on Saturday August 01, 2009 @06:06AM (#736193)
I think a free market has to be free -- that practices that stifle competition hurt consumers immediately.

I think Apple's locking out of Google is very similar to Microsoft's locking out of Netscape. It's reasonable tobring the samre monopolies law to bear, I think.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 02, 2009 @02:17AM (#737131)
I agree in principle, but it's a difficult line to draw. There is no clear distinction between contracts that stifle competition and contracts that are legitimate means of competing.

There are all sorts of exclusivity arrangements or vendors selling only their own branded wares or that of their partners in their own store. It's not like Apple invented this scheme. For a very long time telcos selected every single application that was allowed to run on their network.

Consumers have their own means of defending against such practices. They can simply stop buying iPhones for instance. It's not like there were no alternatives. As a consumer, in this case, I have to say don't need the government.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by jacquesm on Sunday August 02, 2009 @05:04AM (#737237)
It's not really comparable, sizewise Microsoft was much bigger than netscape at the time, and the only route to the desktop was through microsoft. The iphone is not a monopoly by any stretch of the imagination, even though the 'hip' people all seem to have them.

(hm, the implicit conclusion is that I'm not hip...)

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by stevecooperorg on Thursday August 06, 2009 @05:33AM (#745092)
Not the same size, but vastly more controlling. On a windows machine you could always install netscape. On an iPhone you have to download apps only from apple-approved sources.

I suppose the question is whether the concerns of one marketplace (handsets) should override theneed of another (apps). As someone who hasalready bought an iPhone for what is a considerable amount of money, I don't like the turn towards crippling a product I thought was mine.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by etal on Saturday August 01, 2009 @10:54PM (#737016)
It would be less if an issue if the iPhone weren't so popular and AT&T weren't involved. But the iPhone takes a nearly dominant share of the smart-phone market right now, and AT&T has even been convicted as a monopolist in the past. The two-year service contracts and shortage of decent competitors probably contribute, too.

It was cute when Apple locked down its operating systems, because there was no serious threat to the market -- but with two big companies involved in flagrantly anti-competitive behavior, in a market the government understands better, there's a higher standard for fair play here.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by fauigerzigerk on Sunday August 02, 2009 @06:34AM (#737293)
There's a pretty large number of credible competitors in the smart-phone market - RIM, Palm, Nokia, Google, Microsoft and probably a few others. Also, there are other carriers than just AT&T.

So at this point I fail to see what's the issue other than some disappointed iPhone users. Maybe there's a legal problem. We will see.

Re:FCC Takes On Apple And AT&T Over Google Voice Rejection by dkokelley on Saturday August 01, 2009 @01:36AM (#736031)
It looks like there's some pending legislation that requires immediate investigation.

"In light of pending FCC proceedings regarding wireless open access (RM-11361) and handset exclusivity (RM-11497), we are interested in a more complete understanding of this situation."

I'll bet those have something to do with the swift response by the FCC.