isn't the lack of a denial in this instance tantamount to
an admission? I mean, if it were me, [...] responded to
questions about Bitcoin with "bit-what-now"?
If all his friends and family know he shares his name with the creator of bitcoin, he might have already heard all the jokes and think "not this shit again" as well as not being able to credibly deny knowing about it.There's a british general who goes by Mike Jackson when his real name is Michael Jackson [1]. If someone asked him to moonwalk I'd expect the resigned frustration of someone who has heard that lame joke a thousand times before - rather than him denying having heard of the pop singer of the same name.
I also went to high school with a guy named John Conner and everyone use to thank him for some day saving the human race from the machines.
If he was some coincicentally named private individual, the obvious thing to do would be to deny being the celebrity Nakamoto, and possibly to advise the reporter to discuss the matter with his lawyer.
Why is that so "obvious"? That may be the obvious choice for you, and maybe it's even the "correct" choice.
But fame is incredibly enticing ego food.
I'm not saying he is or he isn't. I don't know, obviously, but I do know that people do things for many strange and contradictory reasons.
Here's a real world example: Hundreds of people have claimed that their father, brother, friend, odd uncle, strange neighbor etc were the Zodiac killer.
Many such claims came along with a lot more "evidence" than has yet been presented about "Dorian S. Nakamoto". Clearly, most of those claims (or all) are false.
Or even something like this: http://radaronline.com/exclusives/2012/11/sweden-notorious-s...
Seems like a confirmation?
tl;dr - Give me proof, not vague "seems like he confirmed it."
However, I give you Hanlon's Razor on this. It's more likely that this Satoshi flubbed his words when speaking about bitcoin rather than intentionally mislead the journalist.
* I'm not working on this * Anymore (i.e., I was before) * It's been turned over to other people (i.e. there were other parties involved in this work) * They are in charge of it now (i.e. there was a project to be in charge of, and Satoshi had been the one in charge) * I no longer have any connection (i.e. he did used to have a connection).
That's not a vague set of facts about something which this libertarian, privacy-minded genius just happened to be mistaken with. It's a detailed accounting, one which is "the exception that proves the rule". By listing what is not true he is definitely implying what is true.
Let me re-paranthesize your quote:
* I'm not working on this * Anymore (he never worked on it) * It's been turned over to other people (this is a public project with dozens of people involved, publicly) * They are in charge of it now (yes, they (as in the publicly acknowledged open source project) are in charge of it now) * I no longer have any connection (i.e. he never had a connection).
> he is definitely implying what is true
What evidence do you have that any of his "implications" are worthy of truthfulness? (or that he's a "genius")?
What other "genius" level work has he produced? Or something even close to what would normally be considered "genius".
Even the obscure professor (Yitang Zhang) who came up with the first resolution of the twin prime conjecture was an "obscure" university professor.
I'm not saying that credentials are the only valid proof of capability. The Wright brothers had no degree. But they had decades of documentation of their efforts before they succeeded.
* It's been turned over to other people(i.e., I sold my graphics cards)
* They are in charge of it now (i.e., The people that own the graphics cards may still be mining. I dont know)
* I no longer have any connection (i.e., It was some guys from Craigslist. I dont remember their number).
See how detailed that is?
Exactly this.
Everyone here assumes that there are only negative consequences of being identified (or misidentified) as Satoshi. That may even be true, but Icarus didn't know the Sun (fame in this case) would burn him.
Rest was just conjecture on the writer's part.
50% of the article deals with material about bitcoin that is redundant to anyone whose been following it for more than a day (like most here).
45% deals with "Dorian S. Nakamoto"'s family, personal background and that he's a libertarian oddball, with a penchant for math (but no other significant accomplishment within it or CS) who (other than possible being the Satoshi) has led a fairly normal, middle class southern california lifestyle.
The remaining 5% or so details a brief encounter with the man, in which he neither confirms or denies it.
I'm skeptical.