I also went to high school with a guy named John Conner and everyone use to thank him for some day saving the human race from the machines.
If he was some coincicentally named private individual, the obvious thing to do would be to deny being the celebrity Nakamoto, and possibly to advise the reporter to discuss the matter with his lawyer.
Why is that so "obvious"? That may be the obvious choice for you, and maybe it's even the "correct" choice.
But fame is incredibly enticing ego food.
I'm not saying he is or he isn't. I don't know, obviously, but I do know that people do things for many strange and contradictory reasons.
Here's a real world example: Hundreds of people have claimed that their father, brother, friend, odd uncle, strange neighbor etc were the Zodiac killer.
Many such claims came along with a lot more "evidence" than has yet been presented about "Dorian S. Nakamoto". Clearly, most of those claims (or all) are false.
Or even something like this: http://radaronline.com/exclusives/2012/11/sweden-notorious-s...
There's a british general who goes by Mike Jackson when his real name is Michael Jackson [1]. If someone asked him to moonwalk I'd expect the resigned frustration of someone who has heard that lame joke a thousand times before - rather than him denying having heard of the pop singer of the same name.
[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mike_Jackson