That said, between Braintree and Paymill, BT is certainly playing a catch-up. For one, they just recently dropped minimum monthly fee and switched to simple per-transaction fee structure. Also, their integration requires more work on the backend and overall feels less transparent and "heavier" that Paymill's.
In retrospect, Paymill is not bad at all, but it is not dramatically better than others either. They are all about the same.
It's not sensical to choose one or the other over which YOU like more. You're in business to increase profits. If that means a PayPal button, so be it.
I'd be very curious to hear more about your use case -- could you drop me a line? [email protected].
[1] http://www.quora.com/Online-Shopping/When-purchasing-online-...
Paymill is just a bad copy of Stripe in regards of technology, customer support, processes etc. One example of this is the ID verification process. Stripe has this automated and it takes minutes to complete. With Paymill we had to send copies of several different ID documents to different people and the process took weeks.