Hm, this is very interesting to hear, and doesn't match the what we see in general or what PayPal apparently sees in aggregate[1].
I'd be very curious to hear more about your use case -- could you drop me a line? [email protected].
[1] http://www.quora.com/Online-Shopping/When-purchasing-online-...
It's not sensical to choose one or the other over which YOU like more. You're in business to increase profits. If that means a PayPal button, so be it.