If I don't have some way of knowing whether someone is actively at their keyboard, or has their phone/tablet screen on, and is likely to see my message and respond instantly, then my only recourse is to stare blankly at my display and hope that they show up. This is a huge fucking waste of time. Right now the "green chat bubble" means that the person (is at their computer || owns a smartphone).
Blindingly useless.
The critical thing to consider with hangouts is this: it is not Talk/your regular "synchronous" IM system. It is an async system, an extension of SMS (in terms of use case). As such "staring into the screen" is not using the system correctly, since it's a fire-and-forget system that will push-ping you back when the other side replies. Once I acknowledged that, I basically signed out of Hangouts-via-Talk on my computers and happily use it almost solely on mobile, with conversations synced across all devices (the conversation holes themselves in a XMPP client provide for quite an uncanny experience, which is also why I like the SMS/Hangouts split conversations instead of transparent fallback that becomes obvious once you swap devices).
Since it's a significantly different product, I don't know if they had better completely split Hangouts or outright kill Talk, because as such they used network effects to convert people from Talk+Messages Plus+Android Messenger (or whatever it was called) into the unified Hangouts. What I wish though is that they provided extensions to XMPP allowing existing XMPP clients to implement reasonable feature parity for text chats (I could care less for video+audio in my XMPP client of choice, especially given the increase in dependencies and code complexity), so that the experience would be more seamless and more async overall instead of the XMPP-is-sync/hangouts-is-async beast we have to handle, without having a browser plugin overflow into my native OS.
That just taught me to use Hangouts for conversations where I don't need (but might welcome) a realtime reply. Hangouts are in a nebulous zone between chat and email for me.
For me, if I absolutely need an instant reply, I really need to call the person. (Even presence indicators aren't a promise that someone will prioritize your IM and reply. There's no indicator for "desperately wants to surrender absolute attention to you no matter how insignificant your topic.")
With Hangouts, they stay "open" in the background, so I can have an idle conversation with new notes every few days, it doesn't bother me. I can have a hangout with multiple people when some are online and others can catch up with the conversation later. And it's less formal / less work than email.
This all comes down to use case. I'd probably grant that Hangouts is a terrible new ICQ. But I've found it to be a great improvement over email for close friends.
presence is one feature that i liked a lot in google talk and i am baffled this was removed in hangouts. anyone know why?
And that perhaps by lying to users and telling them that all their friends are "online" even when they clearly aren't, people will be more likely to chat with them and "grow" the service. Nevermind that you need another person to actually be there before you can have a conversation.
There must have been at least a fraction of the hangouts development team that thought this was a boneheaded idea. And the millions of complaints that they got when they released? Those didn't stop because the experience got better, they stopped because it was clear that nothing was going to change. This screams "management decision" to me.
(a) In the web version, there seems to be no way to curate your "friend list." Despite choosing "Never show," people I've once interacted with via a Craigslist ad keep showing up. Deleting contacts is a pain.
(b) iPhone client lets you enable images in messages. Great! Unfortunately, they don't show up on the web client.
(c) On the iPhone client, past conversations keep popping up even after I "archive" them. They disappear for a bit, and then appear again a few days later.
(d) The GV app doesn't let you make calls inside the app (it insists on calling another number of yours). The GV webpage doesn't either. And yet, the Gmail interface lets you place calls and I use this all the time. So confusing.
Now it opens a fresh Hangouts window and takes at least 15 seconds to actually answer/place a call. Horrendous.
I ported my Google Voice number out to my cell phone which is a huge pain but it did work eventually.
I was also an early adopter of Google Voice, which is now heavily integrated with Hangouts, and the recent merger of the two services has made it even worse. When Hangouts is signed in on my desktop and I receive a phone call on my GV number it will often only ring on my desktop and not on my phone, and there is no way to turn this feature off.
Additionally, some of my friends have poor internet service and Hangouts handles that about as well as a toddler falling down an up escalator. Messages are frequently significantly delayed or dropped altogether, we often find ourselves asking each other what messages we have and have not received because our chat windows frequently do not match up.
There are few things more infuriating than having a messaging service tell me it has delivered a message when it actually silently failed to send it.