They could actually have lost the bitcoins. They could be still having technical problems.
Fennecfoxen's theory could be illegal market manipulation, but I wouldn't be surprised if the BTC market is weird enough that it doesn't fit under the laws against that. Or at least that it'd be such a mess to prosecute that prosecutors would all find something better for their careers to do.
Market manipulation in general isn't illegal, so it would basically boil down to if the SEC considered BTC a currency or not.
Should there be the same laws kick in if they drive the price up, by say, adding fake orders on their exchange? I don't even think that should be illegal.
The market should move as it moves, through whichever means: fairness, deceit or ruse. I wouldn't want BTC any other way.
I strongly agree, and I do believe that there's price manipulation going on with the Gox situation at the moment. Is it just an attempt by Gox to make some money back? Or is it something far bigger aimed at damaging the reputation of BTC? Don't forget that Karpeles has recently been vulnerable to manipulation from the USG [1].
But It's surprising that you wouldn't want BTC, when on the road ahead lies Open Transactions, distributed exchanges, and so much more innovation that will take your above statement and put it directly into code. Thus making these wall-street tactics obsolete.
[1] http://thegenesisblock.com/warrant-for-mt-gox-wells-fargo-ac...
So here is a fun exercise, think of bitcoins as soda cans and rethink the whole situation.
But its still probably illegal just about everywhere.
I don't know, but I don't think so. For the law you may be trading in monopoly money at your risk.
So Kome I'll make you a deal, I've got a ownership title for the Brooklyn Bridge and I'll trade this title to you for a case of beer... deal? Deal. Sucka. Then it goes to court. Assuming you can convince the court I knew the title was fake, and the case of beer is worth more than the fake title (maybe the title has artistic merit, or maybe the beer was worthless American Lite "beer" of negative worth) then its pretty cut and dried as fraud.
It's likely the unregulated nature of Bitcoin that makes this easy to do. After all, who is going to chase down market manipulators with search warrants and wiretaps?
What I don't understand is why people would continue selling at any reasonable volumes at firesale prices when other exchanges are doing "fine" (Bitstamp down ~25% vs 2 months ago). Unless I misunderstand it, the malleability bug won't prevent sending btc to other wallets. Is mtgox going to block their users from sending btc and only allow them to sell internally? That would be pretty much equivalent to seizing all their users' coins. Is it just the combination of lots people who own small enough amounts of btc not to care going "fuck it, I just want out"? People not trusting other exchanges after this, or betting that other exchanges will crash too before they can get accounts verified at them and sell their coins?
That's only relevant if you can move your bitcoins to a different exchange. If your bitcoins are held with MTGOX and you're able to run a transaction that extracts any value then that's better than the potential case in which MTGOX simply declare all bitcoins have gone and close all accounts.
I posted this idea a few weeks ago (IIRC) - basically if MTGOX could crash the price then they could buy the bitcoins at a lower price; make an announcement that they're now fine, rebound the price and then afford to cover losses and possibly make a profit too.
It strikes me that's not moral, though some may consider it so, but it's probably not illegal to manipulate "toy" currencies. In the financial sector it seems it's only really considered wrong to fix real ones if you get caught.
The people holding bitcoins will get nothing.
So, even ignoring the Bitcoin, they lost quite a lot of dollars.
Weren't a number of Mt. Gox's bank accounts already seized for other reasons? Before the loss of bitcoins issue, wasn't this already a source of concerns about Gox's viability?
What if Mt. Gox didn't really lose a post-Panamax boatload of Bitcoin (just a small amount)? They're just manufacturing a panic so they can buy Bitcoins at fire-sale prices, declare "We have all the BitCoin we need after all, we fixed our bug, everything's fiiiine" and maybe even turn a cash profit on the upside?
</conspiracy theory, assumes a modicum of competence, etc>