There's a third possibility: It's being done for reasons that have nothing to do with the US or the NSA, say to reduce latency in Europe or support the telecommunications industry in Brazil, and the Rousseff only mentions the NSA in order to build the popularity of the project and herself.
If the EU and Brazil are using US cables, the US is just interfering with its own cable. Fair enough. Entirely different if the US attacks a cable it does not own. It changes the game. It could be considered a hostile act against allies.
Come on. Nine EU countries are complicit in the warrantless wiretap/metadata collection scheme GHCQ is running here on behalf of the NSA. If the US is tapping an EU cable, it's just more data going in the same fetid pool. You can see how outraged the various EU governments are by how loud they have been about it. The only one who seems genuinely upset is Merkel, and mostly because the German secret services don't have the same technical abilities.
I don't know how genuinely angry Brazil is, but I would be extremely surprised if Brazilian intelligence didn't have a similar setup at home.
I'd like to mention that from an outsiders viewpoint of the Germans, it seems they can't by choice rather than ability.
Never assume that Germans lack technical ability, either!
Problem's how are you going to prove it, run through the whole undersea cable every month to ensure it's not been tapped?
Keeping an eye on the stock-market of the parties involved (who's went up, who's went down, who bought CDS instead, etc.) will tell you enough. For us, me at least, it's kinda hard to follow through. But imagine you are the "Bundesnachrichtendienst" (I know it's incredibly hard to read, not to mention to spell it correctly, maybe they did it on purpose), it's the German CIA counterpart. They have the means to find out easily.
What happens next depends on so many factors that it could be a good task for a prediction algorithm.
http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/20/us-boeing-brazil-i...
-Merkel"
From the telegraph onwards, everyone has signals intelligence organizations, the sole purpose of which is to intercept foreign communications. This changes nothing.
This will launch, reduce latency for South Americans, and 10 minutes later it'll be tapped by the US, France, and everyone else who cares enough to send a submarine on over.
I first read about it in cstross's novel "The Jennifer Morgue"[0], from the Laundry series[1]. A very good read.
[0] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Jennifer_Morgue
[1] - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Charles_Stross#The_Laundry_File...
Encryption software and hardware has to come from somewhere. Maybe it's not the US. What then - China, Russia, Great Britain, or perhaps Israel? Who else has military grade capability? And who won't backdoor it?
Recently I've been reading history. The Sioux warrior Red Cloud shut down the Bozeman trail. Then the weight of 10 million Americans overwhelmed his nation of 20,000. It's hard to grasp vast differences in scale. The NSA isn't Apple or Google.
It can raise billions to combat bogeymen and need not turn a profit let alone answer to stockholders every quarter. It can appeal to a patriotism that runs far deeper than mere brand loyalty. Nobody is going to put their life on the line for iOS.
Nevertheless, the main game at Bletchley was Colossus (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Colossus_computer) which allowed the decryption of high level planning communications between German High Command and the government. By main game, I mean that it was the work on Colossus which created the first machines recognisable as computers. This was the codebreak that truly gave the Allies the ability to outmanoeuvre the Germans at a strategic level. There were no German strategic victories once Colossus came on line in late 1943 (the last substantial German victory in the war was https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Third_Battle_of_Kharkov#Manste... in March 1943), compared to numerous Eastern front victories after the Allies started to successfully decrypt Enigma.
Of course we as geeks tend to overestimate the effects of successfully breaking codes. The results are not always positive - for example Rommel's offensive in Africa originally succeeded because Enigma intercepts indicated that he had been told to sit tight, but Rommel decided by himself to launch an offensive. The English were caught flat-footed, and very nearly lost North Africa as a result (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/North_African_campaign#Allies), with only a well-fought defensive action by the Australians stationed in Tobruk saving the day.
> Properly implemented strong crypto systems are one of the few things that you can rely on.
Of course you can infiltrate the facility to access the keys or attack the management systems with zero day exploits. But every bit of protection is worthwhile, because it might be the crucial step that the NSA is not able to break with the assigned budget.
[1] http://www.theguardian.com/world/2013/jun/17/edward-snowden-...
Use that knowledge to peddle bad information to diametrically opposed nation states to further their own interest? Use that information to further secure their systems they previously thought were secure? That's what everyone else would do.
Its not like the US aren't spied on. If anything, there is probably more intense interest in the US operations from various nation states than anywhere else on earth. I was watching a documentary on UK/US spying (both human and communication intelligence, I believe it was called Modern Spies and from the BBC) and it was suggested from commentators from the CIA as well as Her Majesty's Secret Service that the Chinese have stolen the largest mass of nuclear secrets and have even managed to copy some top secret technology in their fighter jets etc. The commentators also seemed to suggest that nobody is clear how it was done yet. Maybe that was scare tactics to make the Chinese seem scary, but on the assumption that it wasn't, why wouldn't that be considered an act of war? I think that is because the nations who are the most competent at spying are also the same nations you can't beat in a 2 week war or nations that can impact heavily in an economic war and so the word isn't chucked around as quickly.
I suppose one man's act of war is another man's act of diplomacy that can avoid war.
"Politics is war by other means." - M. Foucault
Which is an inversion of military theorist Clauswitz's "War is politics by other means."
Given that the Russians or Chinese or Israelis have almost certainly at one point or another compromised the President's communications, we already know the answer.
Also, the more physical diversity the internet has, the better.
Then what?
With it's budget, the US can tap the cable more times than the Brazil-EU alliance can remove the taps.
The US has the most sophisticated undersea capability of any nation state. Tapping transatlantic cables is something at which its intelligence organs are experienced.
http://www.zdnet.com/news/spy-agency-taps-into-undersea-cabl...
It is but one of a long string of sea bottom operations which include Project Azorian, the Thresher and Scorpion investigations, Palomares and probably much that remains classified.
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Project_Azorian
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Thresher_(SSN-593)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/USS_Scorpion_(SSN-589)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/1966_Palomares_B-52_crash