He also put a ton of emphasis on it being a "start-up" and essentially said something along the lines of "in this type of culture its expected that you earn less". I can only guess they passed on me because of my salary requirements which are ~20k under the average. If that is the case which I can only guess it was, not exactly filled with respect or value for work/life balance. /2 cents
EDIT: and jeez they are pushing themselves hard on ycombinator lately.
"in this type of culture its expected that you earn less"
Serious question: is there any other for-profit industry where candidates wouldn't laugh in your face for saying something like this?(This is not meant as a criticism of ZenPayroll or their front-end lead in particular, especially since this instance is just hearsay, but I've come across the attitude described before and have found it personally baffling every time.)
To flip your question around: Is there any other for-profit industry where employers wouldn't laugh in your face for saying you would like 0.8% of the company worth in stock options in addition to your salary...
It all boils down to whether you believe in the company you are building. If it is positioned to do great, then of course you would want the equity for that IPO. If you don't have that faith, then what are you doing interviewing at that company anyways...Use your skills to get a higher paying job without the options.
It's easy to get lured into the excitement of working in a "start-up culture" but you will recognize the red flags after one has sucked you dry without adding much to your finances.
1) turns your employees into neighbours
2) reduces wasted commute time
3) increases exercise compared to drivers (10 mins is better than nothing (edit: twice a day!)) thus reducing medical costs
4) reduces absenteeism due to dental appointments, kid concerts, etc that tend to be near home. Improves family life.
5) reduces the carbon footprint of the business
6) reduces the car-related absenteeism: breakdowns, maintenance appointments, even injuries and deaths.
Increasing salaries would do none of these things.
Some parents with young children find it difficult to get time to be alone in private while not exhausted. This can cause awful stress on a relationship. "Lunchtime" with a partner at home can make a big difference.
This might not sound like a big deal to the pre-kid people, or those with tons of energy after the kids are in bed, but for some people this is a relationship-saver.
Besides, how reasonable is it to expect to be able to raise a family in downtown SF? Surely if you want space, good schools, and room to grow an extra $500 in downtown rent terms isn't going to make that much of a difference.
Edit:
(* ok, maybe $300 difference after taxes.)
Some companies give stipends to employees who commute using public transportation. They could just give everyone a raise to cover those fees, but tying the stipend to the behavior actually encourages people to do it.
E.g., they would be incentivized to raise rents $500, but then one of then could get more business by only raising it to $450 letting the employee capture $50 a month, and so on and so forth.
If you boil it down to numbers, the most you're looking at is a $2000 round-trip ticket to Japan. So it could be similar to a ~2% salary bonus your first year. But of course in practice, most people will get cheaper tickets, and this bonus doesn't give you anything after year 1. Compare this to the $500 stipend - that's $6k every year, and it directly affects your checkbook, instead of being a perk you may be able to enjoy.
The spirit of it is very nice, as a reward for loyalty. But I think it's always useful to look at the bottom line as well.
After all what voter is going to argue with clamping down on tax avoidance if it means that the increase in property tax isn't as big this year or that the federal government can use this additional tax to reduce the deficit (or more likely for pork in some agricultural state)
Either way, health care is the precedent here. Wage freezes in WWII resulted from FDR's Executive Order 9328[1] left employers in a lurch. The government had control of all wages, earnings, etc., and those wages were (basically) frozen by position. A tax man made $x, while an ad man made $y, no matter where they worked.
This put employers in a tough spot because, so long as incomes were the same everywhere, hiring was difficult because they couldn't raise wages to attract candidates, so they petitioned the government for an exemption on health care benefits, as a way of attracting new hires and competing in the market place. In competitive industries, as these benefits were given in lieu of free market wages, benefits became fairly lavish, and for competitive positions, health care benefits became the norm even after the wage freezes were eliminated, but the net result was that health care as a benefit grew 700% in a 20 year span.
The sum of all that of course is the system we have now, where health care is so broken as a system that we're going to 'fix it' with more of the same, but that's another discussion.
[1] - http://www.archives.gov/federal-register/executive-orders/19...
Taxing the benefits is the fairest way to do it.
You could handle this by moving to a system similar to the UK PAYE - any benefits in kind are identified to the Tax man by your employer (via the P60 form) woudl simplify the federal tax system.
1) Housing stipend of $500/mo if employees live within a 10-minute walk of the office
2) A semi-annual retreat / hackathon where employees cook meals, hang out, bond, code, and present their projects
3) Plane ticket anywhere in the world that must be used between their 1 and 2-year anniversary at the company.
I know of many companies that already do #1 and #2, but I suppose I haven't heard of this complimentary vacation ever before. Seems like a pretty awesome perk, which shows they respect and value work/life balance.