News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by primitivesuave on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:17PM (#7250118)
A couple years ago, when I was still on Facebook, I got in this big fight with my girlfriend. I unfriended her on Facebook as a childish act of vengeance, and I noticed that the ads on the side suddenly turned into ads for dating websites. Maybe it was just me, but from the looks of it, Facebook thought I had broken up with my significant other and was targeting ads based on this assumption.

It was then that I realized that every inference they make about you means big business. It means they can now target ads specific to your relationship tendencies on Valentines day, her birthday, his birthday, on your anniversary date, and so on. They can also pick up on events like break-ups and target ads toward you even then. Just another manifestation of Big Data.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by saurik on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:49PM (#7250206)
What I find most fascinating about these kinds of situations is that it isn't clear that Facebook even "knows" this information, despite taking advantage of the "knowledge": they have a massive statistical inference system that notices certain kinds of events cluster with certain kinds of behaviors, leading to differing reactions to potential advertisements; so, while the website clearly has learned something about you, and if it were sentient might be able to have a really scary conversation with you, past asking the question "show me users who are likely to click on dating ads today" (which is a sufficiently different question as to require its own inferences and leading to its own errors) a developer at Facebook might not have "access" to this knowledge any more than a brain surgeon can use your brain to figure out who your mother is. In fact, these data scientists working their way through the data themselves are only now "discovering" something their ad engine already "understood" a long time ago, and while them knowing it explicitly might help them improve the UI of their website, it likely won't help their ad optimizer as the optimizer might already be "smarter" than they are.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by noonespecial on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:09AM (#7250727)
Its starting to sound an awful lot like when skynet wakes up it won't be a terrifying overlord, but rather like a crazy old lady that no one really understands who sells kitsch and loves cats.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by xerophtye on Monday February 17, 2014 @02:26AM (#7250998)
Interesting point. it's not necessary that these behaviors are specifically programmed into the ad engine, rather it might have learned them on its own from the enormous amount of data it has.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:50PM (#7253267)
That's actually a big problem in machine learning. We can make AIs that learn from the data, but trying to reverse engineer the models that they learn is extremely difficult.

I remember hearing about a scientist that used symbolic regression on some of his data sampled from microorganisms of some kind. Eventually it discovered an equation that described the data perfectly. But he can't publish it because no one understands it or can figure out why it works.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by primitivesuave on Sunday February 16, 2014 @09:56PM (#7250380)
Thank you for the very illustrative explanation. It's fascinating to think about how smart the ad optimization will be after another decade, after the size of the training data set gets exponentially larger and the algorithms become more and more refined.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Symmetry on Monday February 17, 2014 @10:29AM (#7252464)
The even more interesting thing is the extent that human beings can do the same thing.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by patio11 on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:39AM (#7250782)
Facebook has a policy where you must target dating-related ads to people who are not in a relationship. See: https://www.facebook.com/help/143949649021372

What you're experiencing post-breakup is merely Facebook normal mode, which your girlfriend was protecting you from. (I'm aware of the targeting rule due to work on Internet advertising and aware of Facebook normal mode due to being a single 20-something male for the majority of my Facebook history.)

There's nobody at Facebook who said "Single? Hit him with all the dating ads!", it's an emergent consequence of that policy rule, auction-esque mechanisms for ad placement, and the measurable behavior of most people demographically similar to you, which is that they click on cleavage but buy virtually nothing as a result of Facebook ads.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by goblin89 on Monday February 17, 2014 @05:41AM (#7251426)
That's interesting. Still, it doesn't sound too unlikely if Facebook allowed targeting ads to those who just broke up.

For example, when you target your Facebook ad you can pick those who have just traveled somewhere, or even “intenders”—those, I assume, who only think about traveling.

You can also target your ads to people in long-distance relationships already. There seems to be no way to specify that explicitly in your Facebook profile, and yet Facebook provides the category for advertisers.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by jchendy on Monday February 17, 2014 @09:15AM (#7252150)
That's pretty interesting. Any idea why the dating sites can't target both men and women?

> The "Sex" targeting parameter must be set to either "Men" or "Women" and cannot be both

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by krcz on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:00PM (#7252955)
Why do they disallow targetting people in open relationships?
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by silencio on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:11PM (#7250593)
The first Facebook page I saw immediately after marking myself as "engaged" started showing me wedding related ads, and I fully expect "married" in a month will mean ads for home buying and baby clothes.

It was a nice change from "we want smart, educated Asian women to donate eggs for $10k+" though.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by icambron on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:17AM (#7250740)
The internet seems so much less sinister when you block ads.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by joyeuse6701 on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:33PM (#7250643)
I would have loved to have the ads "we want smart educated black men to donate sperm for XXX", then again, this might be one of those, 'careful what you wish for, you just might get it' sort of things.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by jsemrau on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:46PM (#7250199)
By Big Data, you surely mean Big Brother ...?

Must be me, but this level of data mining was for me the reason to leave.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Aloha on Sunday February 16, 2014 @09:06PM (#7250251)
I'd rather have ads that might be relevant than ones that are not.

This stuff can be done while keeping peoples privacy intact.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by 001sky on Sunday February 16, 2014 @09:51PM (#7250361)
I'd rather have ads that might be relevant than ones that are not.

This is preposterous. You would rather be manipulated better? Seriously... This is not a teneble position. Most people would prefer white noise. What you are espousing are simply the talking points of the advertsing indusrty. This is like a congressman thanking the lobbyist for "educating" him on the issues.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by rescripting on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:06PM (#7250419)
You're missing his argument completely, which is that targeted advertising has upsides for both the advertiser and the consumer. While I prefer no ads over ads, given the choice I'd prefer relevant ads vs random ads.

That being said targeted advertising infringes on your privacy. Rail against it for that reason. Don't make false assertions that people would prefer random advertising than advertising that they may actually be able to use.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by d0mine on Monday February 17, 2014 @03:23AM (#7251106)
You are assuming a benevolent advertiser that uses knowledge about you in a way that is aligned with your long-term interests.

If we assume that a white noise advertising is less effective than a targeted advertising then it is in the interest of most people to prefer the former because a benevolent advertiser is a rare bird in real life.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by oafitupa on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:12PM (#7250441)
He understood his argument just fine.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @01:10PM (#7253413)
What he is saying is that advertisements manipulate you (likely without your knowledge) and that this is a net cost the the consumer (not to mention even dirtier ads for scams and malware, that's a different subject.) The other kinds of advertisement, the ones that actually inform you of something that is useful to you, do exist. But how much of a benefit are they? I don't think I've ever clicked on an internet ad or bought something because of one.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by kbenson on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:48PM (#7250543)
You are missing a very big point of advertising, which is not just to convince you the product is better than the competition, but that the product exists. In your example, it's like a congressional representative thanking a lobbyist for alerting them to a problem (which presumably they would then educate themselves on). I see no problem with that.

I admit, I would rather the information come in a less obnoxious form in many instances, but let's not kid ourselves that ads have no informational content. Given that they produce some level of useful information, increasing the the level of usefulness without reducing privacy seems a laudable goal.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by 001sky on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:28PM (#7250634)
but let's not kid ourselves that ads have no informational content

Every piece of knowledge has an opportunity cost.[1] To make this point more explicit, the cost is asymetric. Advertising is no different than a drunk on a subway or a schizophrenic homeless person shouting nonsense to a passerby. Yes, they are communicating information. Let me put a bunch of this "information" in front of an advertsing executive's home in Atherton, and watch him call the police and have his lawyer write a letter to the housing association to change the zoning code. And then, the circle of life (and information, and special interests) will be complete/. =D

[1] To paraphrase Nietzche.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by kbenson on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:41PM (#7250671)
But the cost is already paid. We aren't talking about increasing advertising, we are talking about increasing the usefulness of advertising. Interspersed with that schizophrenic's nonsense is the useful tidbit reminding you it looks like rain, and there's a cheap umbrella a few steps ahead... Not to mention in-between his ramblings he does a pretty entertaining Hamlet. ;)
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by 001sky on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:04AM (#7250713)
Everyon understand's advertising makes other people money. It does so at the expense of polluting the information flow of other people. That is a market externality being exploited by one group at the expense of another. One person's eye0sore is another person's "information". But they have zoning laws that dis-allow LA style billboards in expensive neighborhoods...for good reason. The "information" has a negative externality on real-estate costs (aka: its an eyesore). And just like IRL, online advertising is the same way. Who makes the rules is just a matter of people's self-respect. It turns out that wealth white people find it degrading to be subject to advertising, so they put all of those ads for menthol ciggarettes in and alchohol in the black people's neighborhoods.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by kbenson on Monday February 17, 2014 @03:01AM (#7251056)
I'm honestly unclear why you keep trying to shift the argument to whether advertising is a good or bad thing. That wasn't the assertion (or statement of preference, if you will) of the comment you first replied to, and it isn't my assertion one way or the other either. I believe I've made my position clear on whether making existing advertising more useful for the targeted individuals is a good thing, given that privacy is protected. You've made your opinion on some other issue very clear.

And just like IRL, online advertising is the same way. Who makes the rules is just a matter of people's self-respect. It turns out that wealth white people find it degrading to be subject to advertising, so they put all of those ads for menthol ciggarettes in and alchohol in the black people's neighborhoods.

So what's the online equivalent to wealthy white people keeping large obnoxious advertising out of their neighborhoods, and the advertising dollars being redirected towards less affluent or influential people? Who are the elites in this situation?

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by 001sky on Monday February 17, 2014 @04:44AM (#7251284)
User's time and bandwidth are valuable commodities. To safeguard these resources, people engage in social activities which exclude people likely to waste their time. There are entire industries that peddle influence through social engineering to penetrate this approach. Surely I don't need to spell these out ... ;D. But you don't see much of the activity you are interested in here at HN, and when you do the evicence suggests it is the exceptions that prove the rule. And also when those exceptions are not in place it is the typical case demonstrating the case quite nicely.

The issue about "better targeting" is that the delterious elements of advertising do not go away. This is the reason why sometimes we decline to take a phone call in the middle of the meeting. Its not always the targeting, the content, or the message that it counter-productive. Sometimes it is the time and the context.

So it is not just that privacy is protected, or not. Nor is it sufficient that "better targeting" should be an excuse to increase attack surface for placing adds; or that "more secure" should increase the attack surface for data-intensive surveilance and information gathering.

Part of the art of marketing is reaching people in a constructive way. Advertising is not always the way to do that. No matter how "well targeted" it is. That is why we have PR and lobbying, informal networking, social circles, and country clubs, alumni networks...etc. And why we don't accept advertisments in front of phone calls like we do at the movies. Etc.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by panacea on Monday February 17, 2014 @05:09AM (#7251341)
You're fighting an uphill battle with your argument, because I'm quite sure I've never (nor have many people reading HN) encountered targeted advertising based on data mining on sites such as Facebook, that has resulted in tangibly better ads.

I simply have never had my life enhanced by them in the slightest. Curated ads on blogs with content I appreciate are different. But that's editorial curation.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by kbenson on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:34PM (#7253158)
Curated ads on blogs with content I appreciate are different. But that's editorial curation.

Which is fine, and is in line with my point, which is that given ads, making them more useful without increasing the negatives, is a net win. I'm not arguing that we have seen that, just that if we could, that's a good thing.

Distilled this down to its most basic form, names on the front of shops are advertising. To someone looking for a specific shop, they serve an immediate and useful purpose. To those just trying to enjoy a stroll down the street, they may seem annoying eye-sores. At any future date, those roles could be reversed.

Like most things in life, advertising spans a spectrum, in this case from almost entirely useful with few negative side effects (reasonably represented shop names), to entirely useless (long boring message about a product you couldn't use, event if you wanted to). I see no reason not to try to eliminate as much of the latter as possible.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @01:15PM (#7253448)
IMO "informational" ads are few and far between. Most ads are for manipulating people in some way. Not to mention ads for complete garbage like scams and malware.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by michaelt on Monday February 17, 2014 @05:37AM (#7251414)

  This is preposterous. You would rather be
  manipulated better? Seriously... This is 
  not a teneble position.
I watch youtube videos about electronics [1]. Some of the content I watch is created by full-time video bloggers who rely on ad revenue to keep producing content. I figure skipping all ads isn't universalisable, so I watch ads from time to time.

Sometimes I get interesting ads which do things like tell me about the new features I'd get if I upgraded my 10-year-old CAD software to the latest version, or if I brought a newer digital storage oscilloscope. These are things I could conceivably want, and that I'm interested to be told about.

Other times I get videos for "latest horroscopes in hindi, the dynamics of capricorn" which there is no chance of me watching ever.

Is it so hard to believe that, given I am going to see adverts, they might as well be adverts with some relevance to my interests?

[1] http://www.youtube.com/user/EEVblog

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @01:28PM (#7253533)
>I watch youtube videos about electronics [1]. Some of the content I watch is created by full-time video bloggers who rely on ad revenue to keep producing content. I figure skipping all ads isn't universalisable, so I watch ads from time to time.

This is an interesting concept, subjecting yourself to manipulation as a form of payment for a service. Of course if the ads are genuinely useful some of the time, it might be worth it. Or if you believe that ads don't affect you. And that you are somehow tricking companies to waste money on ads that are ineffective.

But there is an argument to be made that advertisements do affect you without your knowledge and that watching them is a net loss.

[deleted]
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @05:13PM (#7254874)
That's not the same thing at all or a good reason to do it.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by kevincrane on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:37PM (#7250658)
Absolutely I'd rather be "manipulated" better, if you count advertising that way. I'd much rather be shown ads for things I might actually want than stuff I have no interest in at all, and I say that as someone who has actually purchased things off of Facebook ads. If the ads going to be there regardless, might as well work it for the benefit of both me and the company presenting it.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by normloman on Monday February 17, 2014 @10:06AM (#7252347)
This assumes you already want to buy the item in question, and advertising just helps you find the best place to buy it, or the best model to get. Consider the other side of the coin. Let's say Facebook shows you products that you don't already want, but based on your age, interests, and past behavior, you have a high likelihood of wanting. The barrage of ads you see convince you to buy that product. In this case, making the advertising more "useful" through better targeting doesn't save you, the consumer, time and money. Just encourages you to buy something you we're perfectly happy without. So is this the kind of advertising you'd like more of? The kind that sells more products for the company, but doesn't help the consumer make the best purchasing decision?

Now I'm not opposed to advertising, and I think advertising can benefit companies and consumers. But we need to start a debate about the usefulness of advertising to separate good advertising from bad. Please pick apart my example above. I'm sure my argument has weaknesses, and I'd love to know what they are.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by monkeyspaw on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:30AM (#7250768)
I"d like to add that I'm also OK with Facebook/Google/whomever making money off that. I think it's just a spectrum of perspective. One side is privacy concerns, the other is the win/win/win where I see ads relevant to me, facebook makes a little money [in exchange for providing a free service that I value], and the advertiser makes a sale for promoting a product that I want.

I don't know the right answer, but I think there's a balance to be struck.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by escherba on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:41PM (#7250517)
> You would rather be manipulated better?

There is another way to look at it. "Manipulation" is sometimes necessitated by poor targeting.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by twelvechairs on Sunday February 16, 2014 @09:40PM (#7250335)
no it can't. Not unless 'privacy intact' means "people with access to the database will never use it for unintended purposes and it is completely secure from being broken into" both of which can't happen.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by justinpombrio on Sunday February 16, 2014 @10:45PM (#7250534)
Wait, if you broke up with someone a few days ago and are now seeing dating ads, how could your privacy have been kept intact? This implies that an ad network has knowledge about your love life.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by jsmeaton on Sunday February 16, 2014 @11:14PM (#7250602)
The assumption is that you've changed your relationship status, and that's how they know you're now single. Telling Facebook that you're single, and them using that information to present an ad for a dating website is not an abuse of private information. You've freely given a first party some information, and they've used that information to display an ad from a 3rd party. There is no abuse of privacy here.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by higherpurpose on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:52PM (#7250215)
And yet Facebook ads don't seem to be that effective - certainly nowhere near where Adsense ads are, which appear because the user would be looking for dating sites, as in your case.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by reddit_clone on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:43AM (#7250786)
Yep. Targeted FB Ads merely seem creepy.

The moment I break up with my girlfriend if someone shoves an Ad on my face for a dating site, I would find it very irritating.

Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees by panacea on Monday February 17, 2014 @05:10AM (#7251343)
It's tone-deaf.