Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees
by saurik on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:49PM
(#7250206)
What I find most fascinating about these kinds of situations is that it isn't clear that Facebook even "knows" this information, despite taking advantage of the "knowledge": they have a massive statistical inference system that notices certain kinds of events cluster with certain kinds of behaviors, leading to differing reactions to potential advertisements; so, while the website clearly has learned something about you, and if it were sentient might be able to have a really scary conversation with you, past asking the question "show me users who are likely to click on dating ads today" (which is a sufficiently different question as to require its own inferences and leading to its own errors) a developer at Facebook might not have "access" to this knowledge any more than a brain surgeon can use your brain to figure out who your mother is. In fact, these data scientists working their way through the data themselves are only now "discovering" something their ad engine already "understood" a long time ago, and while them knowing it explicitly might help them improve the UI of their website, it likely won't help their ad optimizer as the optimizer might already be "smarter" than they are.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees
by noonespecial on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:09AM
(#7250727)
Its starting to sound an awful lot like when skynet wakes up it won't be a terrifying overlord, but rather like a crazy old lady that no one really understands who sells kitsch and loves cats.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees
by xerophtye on Monday February 17, 2014 @02:26AM
(#7250998)
Interesting point. it's not necessary that these behaviors are specifically programmed into the ad engine, rather it might have learned them on its own from the enormous amount of data it has.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees
by Houshalter on Monday February 17, 2014 @12:50PM
(#7253267)
That's actually a big problem in machine learning. We can make AIs that learn from the data, but trying to reverse engineer the models that they learn is extremely difficult.
I remember hearing about a scientist that used symbolic regression on some of his data sampled from microorganisms of some kind. Eventually it discovered an equation that described the data perfectly. But he can't publish it because no one understands it or can figure out why it works.
Re:When You Fall in Love, This Is What Facebook Sees
by primitivesuave on Sunday February 16, 2014 @09:56PM
(#7250380)
Thank you for the very illustrative explanation. It's fascinating to think about how smart the ad optimization will be after another decade, after the size of the training data set gets exponentially larger and the algorithms become more and more refined.