News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by yoha on Saturday February 15, 2014 @04:33AM (#7243221)
As a French, I must say that we are so much used to this system that it seems obvious. And, French being French, we like to complain about the flaws (well, there are some). But whenever I read this kind of article, I realize that this is not obvious at all and that, in the States, you have to pay for your health like for any groceries.

This is when I understand what people means when they say that France is a socialist country: we have very strong public service. This means that police, fire fighters, healthcare, school and so on are mostly public: we have no militia, prisons have no incentive to get more people jailed by bribing judges, fires are fought without caring if the flat's owner can pay for it, people are being taken care of without delay for checking if there private insurance will accept it, and kids from poor families have a firm chance of getting a good education.

The amusing part is that having this critical services being managed by the state seems so obvious to us that we don't think we are specially socialists (well, the French social party seldom wins the presidential elections). I guess it would seem odd for the government to nationalize a company, but it would be nearly impossible for them to try an privatize a critical public service.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by k-mcgrady on Saturday February 15, 2014 @04:49AM (#7243263)
I'm in the UK and we also have these same free public services. No matter how many ways an American explains it to me I cannot understand how their system can ever work better. In fact it seems barbaric to me. I think that in theory, in a perfect world, a completely free market or a libertarian society could work - but in reality it's never going to. The societies with the best standard of living in the world are ones like France that have social services that every one pays for through tax. I guess we have the added benefit in Europe that if we truly don't like our tax system and want a more private system based country we are free to move and work in any other EU country that meets our needs.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by petercooper on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:09AM (#7243968)
Yet the ironic thing is that everyone in the US is paying for a healthcare system via taxes and they pay far more per capita than, say, the UK or Denmark (yes, US public health spending expenditures are higher despite not resulting in universal care). On top of that, they then pay a second (private) time to get any actual coverage unless they're disabled, old or young.

Update: The data for my claim above - http://www.theguardian.com/news/datablog/2012/jun/30/healthc... - the US had the 4th highest per capita government spending on health in 2010 behind only Luxembourg, Monaco and Norway.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by danmaz74 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @01:20PM (#7244675)
Wow, I never realized that... and it's crazy!
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by bsenftner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:20AM (#7244002)
I believe the "problem" with the US system is the very idea that the private sector can manage and provide such essential services better than the government could. And at the same time run the services for profit, profitably. It's a capitalist fantasy. Its a successful power play by our deluded wealth. We have a sad state, this US of A, with our population completely brainwashed into accepting this absurd situation.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by gordaco on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:07PM (#7244356)
IANA economist, but as I see it, the problem is that healthcare is mostly a captive market, i.e. not having it when you need it is not an option. With such an inelastic demand and relatively high entry barriers for providers (making competition scarce), it's expected that prices skyrocket. So socialized healthcare is a big win for the people and a big loss for the moneymakers.

Living in another country with socialized helathcare, each time the situation in the USA is described, I'm really glad I don't live there.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by basisword on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:54PM (#7244548)
Another issue is the lack of information. Most consumers in the healthcare industry rely on others (doctors, hospitals, pharmacists) to tell them what they need and the people giving advice having conflicting motives (helping the patient, making money).
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by visarga on Saturday February 15, 2014 @01:30PM (#7244707)
Simply put, you don't make a business from treating sickness. When people are sick, they are least able to pay. Also, when one is sick, there is no incentive to insure him/her because it doesn't generate profit.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by Blahah on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:36AM (#7243887)
You're half right - the countries with the best standards of living in the world are the ones that have social services that are paid for by publicly owned oil profits, then other resource extraction profits, then taxes. Scandinavia and Canada are routinely the best. Another important feature of these countries is not a nationalised health service like the UK, but a guaranteed minimum standard insurance with a competitive market for provision. See http://www.oecdbetterlifeindex.org/.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by Carioca on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:55AM (#7243937)
Sorry, but you're mostly wrong on both counts.

Only Norway has a substantial amount of natural reserves in the Scandinavian countries, with Denmark a distant second.

Also, the healthcare system you talk about is the Swiss, the Scandinavian and Canadian systems do NOT have anything close to an insurer (except the State itself).

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by Blahah on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:47PM (#7245260)
Perhaps I'm wrong about the oil-wealth thesis.

Re healthcare: I was talking about Scandinavian and Canadian systems. Government pays the cost but private companies provide the service. Contrasted to the UK where government provides the service.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by kwhitefoot on Sunday February 16, 2014 @06:42AM (#7247368)
I wish people would stop saying Scandinavia as though it were a country. It is not and the differences between the countries in Scandinavia are substantial. For instance: Oil and gas: Norway has lots, Denmark a little, Sweden none. Mineral resources: Sweden has lots, Norway has some, Denmark almost none. Forestry: Sweden has lots, Norway has some but it's uneconomic because of the terrain, Denmark very little (except Christmas trees). Hydropower: Norway has lots (98% of electricity), Sweden has some, Denmark almost none. Land area:Sweden twice the size of the UK, Norway 60% bigger than UK, Denmark half the size of the UK.

I can't speak for Sweden and Denmark but here in Norway whilst private institutions provide services (X-rays, MRI, etc.) under contract to the state, the hospitals are nonetheless public institutions (barring a few, and as far as I can tell not very successful, private hospitals).

What does seem to unite the three Scandinavian countries is a general belief that we really are in it all together. When a rich owner of a chain of supermarkets started making a noise about moving to Switzerland because he was fed up of paying high taxes he was immediately told to " off then" not just by us poor peasants (of course there aren't many genuinely poor here) but also by other seriously rich people. It wasn't long before he was back here.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by afterburner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:16PM (#7244400)
I don't think your theory is very good re: natural resources. Sure, some developed countries have a lot of natural resources, but most don't, include many associated with the highest standards of living and socialized care.

Percent of GDP from natural resources:

Norway: 13.6

Canada: 5.1

Denmark: 2.4

US: 1.7

United Kingdom: 1.5

Sweden: 1.2

Germany: 0.3

Italy: 0.2

France: 0.1

Japan: 0.0

Switzerland: 0.0

http://data.worldbank.org/indicator/NY.GDP.TOTL.RT.ZS

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by Blahah on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:49PM (#7245262)
Yeah, upon reviewing the data (as opposed to my own mental impression of these countries' wealth sources) it doesn't hold up very well.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by zurn on Sunday February 16, 2014 @07:09AM (#7247404)
Also, see "resource curse". Norway is one of the few countries to escape it wrt oil.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by mercurial on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:49AM (#7243921)
Denmark doesn't live from oil profits.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by robbiep on Saturday February 15, 2014 @05:15AM (#7243326)
For completeness I must chime in and declare the Australian system shares more similarities with the French, UK, Canadian, German, New Zealand... The list goes on- countries than we do with the US system
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by twelvechairs on Saturday February 15, 2014 @05:38AM (#7243364)
This is true but its worth noting that the Australian system has been moving towards the US version consistently for the past couple of decades. Private healthcare is common and seen in some circles as something not to be done without. Public services have been sold off and new infrastructure is privatised (telecommunications particularly). etc.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by cturner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:02AM (#7243952)
No. The US system is distinguished by healthcare insurance being tied to employment, and the absence of free options.

Australia has not been moving towards that model.

Private health care options have always been a significant part of the Australian healthcare system. In the current Australian settlement: (1) there is a catch-all system that's available to everyone; (2) if citizens want to chose a chosen private option, the government subsidises this.

There's a similar dynamic in school funding.

The result is that people can choose to funnel money towards the education and health system that's in addition to what they pay in their taxes. Their choice also reduces load on the free options. People spend money on health and education that would otherwise be spent on new cars or more ludicrous mortgages, and have done this through an exercise of freedom, rather than having had the government tell them what to do.

Australia is one of only a handful of countries with both solid education and health systems, yet a contained federal government debt situation.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by twelvechairs on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:45AM (#7244272)
I think you misunderstand my point. I'm not saying that Australia is exactly like the USA in this (yes, health care very sesnibly isn't provided by employers). But the 'dual' system you describe in both schooling and healthcare is definitely a step towards the american (privatised) way of doing things from a 'socialist' model (as exemplified in Australia by the Whitlam era approach). The simple test of the socialist model is if the poor don't get the same healthcare or educational opportunities as the rich. Australia has moved towards this and leans more in this direction than most other first-world countries. Whether this is a good thing or not is not my point (obviously you believe it is - I think there are arguments either way).

Privatisation of infrastructure (and a general lack of building new national infrastructure) is also a key sign that the system is not very 'socialist'

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by cturner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @02:38PM (#7245002)
You appear determined to find a way to paint the recent history of Australian health reform as being somehow American. But it's not - it's its own thing.

The US system is a tangle of health systems provided by every level of government and charities. It's different state by state. There's a major veterans scheme. Some states have systems a bit like Medicare. The majority of people get their care through a employment tied insurance. It doesn't serve as an example of freedom, privatisation, variations in levels of care. It's just a big complicated mess.

I think it'd be more straightforward if you just stuck with 'less socialist' rather than trying overloading America as the standard for those qualities.

Not sure that Australia has evolved that way though. There was a recent reform to introduce means-testing to medicare. And the new hospital in Adelaide - 1.7 billion dollars, 120 extra beds.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by twelvechairs on Saturday February 15, 2014 @05:59PM (#7245850)
OK. understand that you don't like my use of 'american' as the opposite to 'socialist' here. Simplifications like this can be difficult and probably will h healthcare we are less overtly 'like america: although still a ways from being strongly 'socialist' (in the Scandinavian sense)
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by lotsofmangos on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:25PM (#7246646)
That is probably because American isn't the opposite to socialist. The USA has many socialist aspects, it just doesn't like to think of them as socialist. Free education is socialist. Medicare for the elderly is socialist. The NFL has many aspects of socialism. The laws on state funded research being made available to the public are socialist. NASA is socialist.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by twelvechairs on Monday February 17, 2014 @09:27PM (#7255974)
This is true but the USA is still, of all first world countries, the one which takes the least socialist approach on many issues and this is the sense in which I use it as an example.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by cturner on Sunday March 02, 2014 @11:09AM (#7329545)
This risks being brutal, but you didn't have an email in your account details, and I left it a week so the forum would clear. I have tough but fond memories of being called out on things like this when I in my 20s. I think I'm well-intentioned.

Something that ribs me about the political culture in Australia: the intelligentsia will never miss an opportunity to claim their identity as being distinct, yet they judge themselves from a very American world-view. In this sense, the Australian identity is like a rebellious teenager - desperate to be making a break from mum and dad, but unaware how its rebellion is defined entirely by mum and dad's world-view.

You are welded to the (American) popular culture myth that American is an antonym for socialism. This is more important to you than the fact that it isn't. Even after we've discussed that there are better ways to express the idea, after you've gone through the pain of admitting you could have done this differently. You've then recanted, pulled back into your shell and defended your original expression. You won't grow if you do this.

It's not just you. But you can fix it. Turn off the television, blank your mind, read, travel, think, build your ideas on this foundation.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by girvo on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:27AM (#7243571)
Yep, and as an Aussie I find it extremely worrying. I'm fine, I have private insurance, and my family and myself are not struggling financially. But that's not the case for some of my best friends and their families... And those are the people that are going to suffer.

Also, screw Translink. I still can't fathom why a 15% increase in price for a worse service makes sense. Sigh

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by mchusma on Saturday February 15, 2014 @05:40AM (#7243372)
I think you hit the nail on the head in 2 ways. First, s completely free market might work in healthcare, but what we have in America is so far from that, that most people don't even know what they are fighting for. Second, you do have much more freedom to move for tax purposes. The US demands its citizens everywhere to pay income tax, globally, even for 2 years after renouncing citizenship.

A potential downside to the world (maybe good for Americans) would be if changes in American healthcare reduces funding overall for drug research and development. I've always heard we fund most of R&D.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by marvin on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:21AM (#7243450)
A completely free market in healthcare will absolutely not work. Insurance companies will drop everyone who has shown any form of uncommon illness - this is their natural incentive in the absence of regulation. Many serious and expensive illnesses are so rare that most insurance companies would severely curtail support towards these illnesses, with cheaper premiums and more customers as a result.

Libertarians are suffering from the same delusion that the communists did: In a world where humans are perfectly ethical towards each other and always put the public good ahead of their own interests, it will work perfectly. In the real world, it won't.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by philh on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:39AM (#7243592)
I'm having difficulty parsing your prediction. Are you saying that in a free market, nobody would offer insurance against the possibility of developing a rare, expensive medical problem? Or that once you've developed an expensive medical condition, you'll no longer be able to get insurance against it? Or something else?
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by michaelt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:24AM (#7243696)
Assume you were an insurance company executive and you wanted to maximize profit and you were indifferent to the plight of your customers. What would you do?

I'd release new products regularly, while increasing the insurance premiums of old products. Healthy people would just switch to the new product to avoid the price increase, but people with pre-existing conditions wouldn't be eligible so I could price-gouge them.

So you could get insurance against expensive medical conditions - but if you had to claim on that insurance, suddenly your premiums would start rising by 30% a year, and you would have no alternative because of your pre-existing condition.

The companies that didn't engage in this would then look expensive to healthy people and attractive to unhealthy people. And if the healthy (profitable) people leave and unhealthy (subsidized) people join, meaning premiums have to go up further, you could get a chain reaction putting them out of business.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by swombat on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:46AM (#7243744)
So you could get insurance against expensive medical conditions - but if you had to claim on that insurance, suddenly your premiums would start rising by 30% a year, and you would have no alternative because of your pre-existing condition.

To bolster this example, I hear from my parents that this is more or less what's happened to insurance premiums in Switzerland since some idiot in government deregulated the insurance industry.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by sheepmullet on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:58AM (#7243943)
I think a free market insurance system would basically end up paying out lump sums for various illnesses and conditions. Hospitals would publish average price lists and then insurers would advertise and pay based on that.

Get lung cancer? Here take $200k courtesy of your insurance. Only going to cost you $150k? "No problem, glad you found a cheaper place. Buy a nice gift for your wife with the difference"

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by pekk on Saturday February 15, 2014 @01:18PM (#7244666)
Anyone would pay a slightly smaller premium in exchange for the awarded sum being limited to actual incurred/billed costs
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by sheepmullet on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:42PM (#7245240)
Pretty good insurance company to be able to offer a smaller premium when they have to cover the exact same costs on average when they have 10x the overheads of a company that pays lump sums.

Not to mention you are by necessity limited by the hospital and doctors on the insurance companies approved docs list. No thanks; they don't have my interests at heart.

Not to mention the very real incentive for such an insurance company to stop paying for "problem" clients with long ongoing illnesses.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by michaelt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @05:15PM (#7245641)
If 25% of lung cancer cases cost less than $150,000 to treat, 50% cost less than $200,000 to treat, 75% cost less than $250,000 to treat, 99% cost less than $500,000 to treat and 99.999% cost less than $2,000,000 to treat, how much would the insurance company pay out for lung cancer?
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by thelettere on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:40AM (#7244065)
There is no set cost for complex chronic diseases like cancer, so there is no way that could be published. No single case of cancer is exactly the same, and the course of it and how it responds to various treatments varies widely.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by sheepmullet on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:50PM (#7245265)
Sure it could. They would just have to categorize the major varieties etc. if you mean it wouldnt be 100% accurate well of course not as it is rough aggregate data. But it is very useful aggregate data.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ThomPete on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:17AM (#7243678)
Its not just that.

The problem is that for the insurance to work optimally everyone have to chip in so that those that are healthy offset the cost of those that aren't.

In the US the young aren't getting insurance which is one of the reasons for the Offordable Healthcare Act. To force everyone to have an insurance so that economics become better.

Of course in reality the best possible system would be a single payer (tax based) healthcare system with some payment for usage but where no one can go bankrupt or be dropped or fall under the deadly pre-existing conditions clause.

Or a mandated private insurance like in Germany & Switzerland. Obamacare is one step of that way but it's so alien to US culture and have been so poorly implemented that on could fear for its future.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by virtualritz on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:00PM (#7244325)
> Or a mandated private insurance like in Germany [...]

There is no mandated /private/ health insurance, there is just mandated health insurance in Germany.

See e.g. http://www.slowtravelberlin.com/guide-health-insurance-germa...

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ThomPete on Saturday February 15, 2014 @03:38PM (#7245222)
Thats true but I don't think that is as important for the point I am making, but sure.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by 001sky on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:56AM (#7244103)
A completely free market in healthcare will absolutely not work.

It doesn't work because of other reasons. And libertarianism is quite irrelevant. A good economist can point out the flaws in economic markets...using economics. A marxist alternative is clearly from the wrong century and is irrelevant. The important point that govermnet semi-intervention is part of the problem is perfectly plausible. That is a different point than no co-operation is needed for a viable solution. People co-operate all of the time without the need for a "government solution". Try staring at people in the elevator or invading the personal space of someone on the NYC subway if you want to prove this point to yourself.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by codehotter on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:31AM (#7243468)
Would it be possible for charities to fund the medical costs of people with uncommon illnesses?
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by marvin on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:46AM (#7243502)
Of course, but then you're right back at where you started: Taxation.

Charities are much more common in the US than in Europe, because they cover services and treatments which are provided by the public sector in European countries. In the US, many of these services are based on voluntary donations and volunteering.

Of course, if the state is as corrupt as it is in the US, I understand the reluctance to pay more taxes. But in effect, charities do the same thing, except veiled by the fact that contributions are voluntary.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ulfw on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:00AM (#7243416)
It works better for the corporations who benefit from the system with billions of revenues and who can afford to bribe (sorry, 'lobby') US politicians to perform as they please.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by james1071 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:44AM (#7243737)
One difference between France and the UK is that doctors' salaries are much lower there. The French get more value for their healthcare spending than does the UK.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ekianjo on Monday February 17, 2014 @04:24AM (#7251244)
> I'm in the UK and we also have these same free public services.

You forgot the word "crappy" services. It's widely known that for life threatening conditions in the UK, the NHS has a wait list and you have to wait for your turn no matter what and that be months or sometimes more than a year. Sorry, but I want to have a system that allows me to pay more to get priority (or better treatments).

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by galactus on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:39AM (#7243591)
it is not enough to have a free public service, tho. I have no idea about the Uk, but Canada also has free public healthcare yet it is so quite worse than the french system that it feels like they are not in the same league, imho.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by k-mcgrady on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:13AM (#7243673)
The UK system certainly has problems (long wait times, overcrowding etc.) but I think when it comes down to where I'd rather be if I had a life threatening illness, it would be here, not the US. The fact that I can receive a good level of health care without paying a penny (even for prescriptions) is worth the drawbacks that come with this kind of system. Also, I still have the option of paying to go private if I wish.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by 001sky on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:21AM (#7243562)
"in the States, you have to pay for your health like for any groceries."

In the US there is no functioning price mechanism. So, it it is quite unlike a trip to the super-marche. Your money disappears down a rabbit hole (insurance) for which there is very little practical choice; and the rest of it is like a giant "dark pattern" puzzle where all kinds games are played to milk out the most money. That is not to say introducing "market pricing" is the correct answer, in a naive sense, this is not correct. Because markets don't function with opportunistic negotions under duress and asymmetric information (ie, typical medical situations). So, the problems with healthcare are precisely this: money changes hands but it is part of a system that is neither here nor there. As such, its just a corrupt opaque and insider-exploited bit of social engineering. Of courese, that likely describes many of the alternatives. (Hence, tough choices and an unwillingness to do anything other than something well thought out and pragmatice.) At least EU countries have evolved a unique ecosystem over time that has developed it own internal logic. The US is a frakenstein system, and the more money we spend trying to "rationalize it" (buzzword of the 1990's?), the worse it gets...MBA type's and the hippocratic oath don't really mix.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ekianjo on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:42AM (#7243901)
> we don't think we are specially socialists (well, the French social party seldom wins the presidential elections).

Being French living abroad, your comment makes me smile.There's nothing but socialists in France, you just have right wing and left wing socialists but their economic and social policies are all very much converging except for some minor social issues about homosexuals and stuff like that. Liberals or should I rather say Libertarians do not exist at all in France so you have basically a single mindset in power. That's why France is known abroad as "La Petite Russie" (the small Russia).

> be nearly impossible for them to try an privatize a critical public service

and thats exactly why you end with shitty companies like SNCF and the former France Telecom who did not care about their users at all. Having competition does not solve all issues, but God, it can't be worse than State monopoly services.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by yoha on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:03AM (#7244125)
About the political orientation, I do know that we are considered as a socialist country abroad, and even more in the States. I am just sharing what I have witnessed from inside. For instance, in the mind of most people, the left wing (PS, the "Socialist Party") is even considered to be right-wing-oriented. I think that French do no realize that they tend to think in a "leftier" way that the States (well, you could say that the US tend to think in a "rightier" way due to the Cold War).

> and thats exactly why you end with shitty companies like SNCF and the former France Telecom who did not care about their users at all. Having competition does not solve all issues, but God, it can't be worse than State monopoly services.

Some context for non-French: SNCF is the Société Nationale des Chemin de Fer (litteraly national railway company), that now manages most train traffic in France (but not the railways themselves, ironically); France Télécom (sometimes abbreviated FT) is the company which set up the infrastructure for land-line phones and started using it. Both SNCF and FT are public companies.

The statuses of SNCF and FT were logical at the time of their creation as it was an initiative of the state to build the infrastructure so that most people could benefit from it. However, this also meant that the companies had the monopole and, even when it was finally broken (legally speaking), they were considered as the "by-default" company so they still detain most of the market in their respective domains. Because of this, they were never really threatened by competition and evolve very slowly, leading to a degradation of the services they provide. Additionally, it is difficult to privatize those company because of social protests that raise whenever the topic is discussed.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by afterburner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:19PM (#7244410)
The nicest people I met in France were SNCF employees. They seemed to like going out of their way to help me out.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by ekianjo on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:04PM (#7246340)
You must have been extremely lucky, I have nothing but bad experiences with the SNCF and their employees through my years in France. This company is a joke.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by afterburner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:04PM (#7244343)
Interestingly, the case about firemen not helping someone who didn't pay the out-of-county fire coverage fee also relates directly to health care. The reason they didn't help is because if someone was hurt fighting a fire they weren't supposed to be fighting, their health insurance wouldn't have covered it. If there had been universal health care, this would not have been an issue. Many screwed up incentives in the US result from lack of proper health coverage.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:09AM (#7243432)
I'm no flag-waver, but I think it's important to point out that for 40+ years after WW2, it was an extensive (and expensive) US military budget which countered Soviet aggression. So when you talk about all these great social services, you have them in part because of a very expensive investment we made in the defense of western Europe, which freed you to spend money on these things.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by flexie on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:36AM (#7243485)
The first many years after WW2 Europe spent rebuilding itself. America came out of the war with barely a scratch on its home territory. Although many American soldiers had died overseas no cities or industries were destroyed and almost no civilians died. In Europe, two generations had been decimated by the two consecutive wars, hundreds of major cities were destroyed, infrastructure was destroyed, businesses - well, entire industries, were destroyed. The iron curtain meant that trading partners in Eastern Europe were no longer accessible.

For America WW2 meant opening up it's trade with the war. Let's not forget that Europe's welfare states were born in hardship.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by wikiburner on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:09AM (#7243548)
> The first many years after WW2 Europe spent rebuilding itself.

The U.S chipped in quite a bit too. $15 billion, or $148 billion in today's dollars, which was almost 6% (!) of the U.S. GDP at the time. This was in addition to a previous $15 billion in aid before the Marshall Plan was enacted.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by flexie on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:10AM (#7243808)
While indeed massive, the Marshall plan was handed out over 4 years so it was around 1.5 percent of US GDP. I dont think it made it impossible for the US to build public health care.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by smacktoward on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:29AM (#7243878)
Indeed -- in fact at the same time as the Marshall Plan, President Truman actually was trying to pass a national health plan:

http://www.trumanlibrary.org/anniversaries/healthprogram.htm

http://pediatrics.aappublications.org/content/127/3/399.full

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by baby on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:19AM (#7243686)
and all that to impose its views, to counter communism.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by peteretep on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:39AM (#7243588)
The problem with amateur American historians on the internet is that they seem to forget anything pre-1900 happened. You could start your remedial reading with: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/France_in_the_American_Revolu...
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:25AM (#7244011)
The French financial- and military contributions to the American Revolution were motivated almost entirely by a desire to contain the British and exact revenge for the loss of French North America. Financially that ended up being a very bad move for the (royal) French government, but don't imagine that they were inspired by fraternal feelings toward the American revolutionaries.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by julie1 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:39AM (#7244247)
The american contribution to their own wealth was to not pay the debt they contracted to Louis XVI when France became a Republic (and they were right to do it for legal reason).

Le baron de Beaumarchais (famous writer and weapon smuggler) that lobbied the french monarchy for helping the US revolution was clearly doing it for the sake of freeing the people from monarchy (he was one of the philosoph supporting the strange idea that merit matters more than birth rights).

You should really read more. Especially 'le mariage de Figaro'

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:49AM (#7244292)
> The american contribution to their own wealth was to not pay the debt they contracted to Louis XVI when France became a Republic (and they were right to do it for legal reason).

According to a U.S. State Department history [1]: "In 1795, the United States was finally able to settle its debts with the French Government with the help of James Swan, an American banker who privately assumed French debts at a slightly higher interest rate. Swan then resold these debts at a profit on domestic U.S. markets. The United States no longer owed money to foreign governments, although it continued to owe money to private investors both in the United States and in Europe."

Granted, 1795 was a bit too late to help Louis XVI, who had lost his head two years before. Still, it was only 12 years after the peace treaty with Britain -- not too terrible for a brand-new nation, I'd say. And in any case, it'd be unconventional (to say the least) to try to blame the Americans for the French royal government's mismanagement of its financial affairs.

---

> Le baron de Beaumarchais (famous writer and weapon smuggler) that lobbied the french monarchy for helping the US revolution was clearly doing it for the sake of freeing the people from monarchy (he was one of the philosoph supporting the strange idea that merit matters more than birth rights).

Nations aren't monoliths; their governments act in response to pressures from all sorts of different people who have all sorts of different opinions and motives.

(Example: When the U.S. entered WWII, the triggering event was the Japanese invasion of Pearl Harbor. But for months before that, and especially after the Nazi German invasion of the USSR in June 1941, a significant number of Americans had wanted the U.S. to enter the European war --- some to help the British, and some because they were Communists or sympathizers who wanted an immediate second front in Europe to take the pressure off the Soviet Union.)

[1] https://history.state.gov/milestones/1784-1800/loans

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by julie1 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:27PM (#7244432)
I skipped the part with US debts then. My bad

In the rough French revolution context is basically the same as today: * huge debts contracted by gvt; * unfair repartition of the fiscality (the 1% wealthiest don't pay in proportion to their income); * producers (the 10% wealthiest) are not able to produce anymore because fiscality is to high;

The convocation of "tiers etats" that triggered the revolution was about asking how to make the repartition of fiscality more fair.

the 1% wealthier said we don't care we don't pay and you can't change the system anyway because we make the rules and they "mouhahaha"ed The remaining said, okay, are you losing your head (saracasm and irony)? and they said to the other europeans 1% (germans, brits, dutch, spanish)... Oh btw, we are not a kingdom anymore. As a result, we dont have anymore debts. Go fuck yourselves

The banks were pissed off and they said: WUT! Debts are to be honored, if people begin to think that money don't rule the world the world is doomed.

Thus the coalitions against France, battles (Valmy), Napoleon tricking Italia in Republic and then betraying them so that the bankers got another ennemy ...

And here we are, in the same situation again.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by julie1 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @12:40PM (#7244479)
I forgot the part where producers were also asking for the state to ensure a 'fair competition' based on merit and not birth.

Now, takes Forbes top 500 fortunes of the world and tell me how much people are not xth generation dynasty kids.

I love Bill Gates he has a lot of merit, one of which is being well borned.

We do have a meritocratic system, but this system is biased because he is mainly accessible through birth.

This is the definition of a society based on casts. We are regressing in the name of a so called "liberalism" that looks like the "communism" of Lenin : an implementation that contradict the purpose.

Our political systems are wrong implementations of good ideas. How can we repeatedly fail that much collectively?

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by aaronem on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:56AM (#7244102)
And? Unless you're going to try to make the point that post-WWII American investment in Europe was done purely out of the goodness of the post-WWII American heart, I'm not sure where you are going with this.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:49AM (#7244287)
> Unless you're going to try to make the point that post-WWII American investment in Europe was done purely out of the goodness of the post-WWII American heart, I'm not sure where you are going with this.

Not purely --- I would imagine that certainly American leaders had future markets in mind --- but there was definitely a large component of altruism, quite possibly more so than with the French support of the American revolutionaries in the late 1770s and early 1780s.

In the post-WWII era, the U.S. had nukes, as well as two broad oceans as moats. After the Japanese surrender we demobilized as fast as we could, in response to overwhelming domestic political pressure to "bring the boys home."

It might well have been feasible for us to have largely retreated to our own borders and leave the western Europeans to their fates at the hands of the Soviets. Instead, we spent billions, perhaps even trillions, to maintain forces in Europe to deter Soviet aggression and to try to help western Europe recover from the devastation of the war. (We offered Marshall-Plan aid to the Soviets and their vassal states as well, but the Soviets prevented those countries from accepting [1].)

Of course self-interest was part of the U.S. motivation. But there also was altruism, and generosity.

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Marshall_Plan#Rejection_by_the_...

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:55PM (#7246198)
The problem with amateur American historians on the internet...

As opposed to the professionals, who dribble drive-by snark and Wikipedia links?

You could start your remedial reading with: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/France_in_the_American_Revolu...

Other than in an abstract sense, what does the American Revolution have to do with the Postwar Reconstruction, some 170 years later? And how does that mute or counter the statement I made?

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by danmaz74 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:16AM (#7243675)
Perhaps you missed a key point: A universal healthcare system is less expensive than a privatized healthcare system. So, as much as I'm thankful for the protection from a possible soviet aggression and even more for the Marshal plan, it wasn't a lack of money that convinced the USA to have a private system. I think it was mainly a hate of anything "socialistic".
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:03PM (#7246220)
Less expensive on a per-patient basis, but more expensive as a government program, which would compete directly with defense spending and foreign aid. I don't disagree that there were cultural factors involved as well, as Americans have a predisposition towards certain ideas which resemble a notion of individual responsibility (for a certain definition.)
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by kwhitefoot on Sunday February 16, 2014 @07:23AM (#7247428)
No, the US government spends more on health care per capia than almost all other countries.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by nraynaud on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:44AM (#7243498)
I would more talk about plan Marshall. Because France and UK had to build war jets, nuclear weapons, and air carriers on their own (and caravelle, and space rockets and Concord together).

The whole premise of social security in France after the war is that people with their basic needs unfulfilled voted for the nazis. So they decided that the State should provide some minimum services for everybody.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by agilebyte on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:25AM (#7243862)
Because it was in fact the nazis that came up with a quite extensive social program in Europe.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by EliRivers on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:22AM (#7243452)
Which was entirely out of the goodness of their hearts. Certainly not out of self-interest, no no no.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:57PM (#7246204)
No, it was done in near- and long-term self-interest and strategic relationship building. Why would you assume I meant otherwise when I implied absolutely nothing about motive?
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by heedspin on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:44AM (#7243601)
I believe that was Ayn Rand's point: Acting out of self interest helps everyone.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by EliRivers on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:48AM (#7243613)
A stopped clock is right twice a day; if everyone is helped by someone acting out of self-interest, it's a lucky by-product.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by Noxchi on Saturday February 15, 2014 @11:19AM (#7244178)
Do you honestly believe everything humans do isn't done out of self interest?

EVERYTHING we do ultimately comes down to trying to spread and preserve

* our genes * our family's genes * our friends' genes

and all the other social groups humans form, in the order of priority being group size smallest to least.

Emotions are the definable channel to that "gene preserving" desire.

Everything we do in life is to achieve a certain emotional state (think about it). We don't want money. We want what it will mean to us (e.g. security, power, fun, freedom, etc.). We don't want a relationship, we want what it will mean to us (love, belonging, etc.).

Nature's calibrated human has his emotions correctly / optimally linked to spreading and preserving his and other humans' genes.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by EliRivers on Sunday February 16, 2014 @08:05AM (#7247524)
"Do you honestly believe everything humans do isn't done out of self interest?"

Yes, I do. I believe that I have personal experience of people doing thing detrimental to themselves, that they know are detrimental to themselves, that they do willingly. We are capable of overriding our emotional and physical reactions.

I suspect you have already decided on your conclusion, and will fit all evidence to that conclusion.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by kalleboo on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:45AM (#7243499)
Did you miss the part where health care spending in the US is twice as much as anywhere else? Europe is spending less on "these things" than the US.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jacquesm on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:21AM (#7243451)
I don't think you get to guilt trip the French in this respect.

'Force de Frappe'

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @06:39AM (#7243493)
This is getting a bit off-topic, but go back in time 50 or 60 years: Ask the citizens of West Germany, Belgium, The Netherlands, Italy, (neutral) Austria, etc., whether Force de Frappe kept them from Soviet domination.

(Also ask whether the French would actually have used nuclear weapons to stop a Soviet non-nuclear attack on France. That's relevant because in a conventional war without U.S. forces, the Warsaw Pact forces could have rolled to the Channel in weeks if not days.)

No, it was NATO that served as the real deterrent to the Soviets. NATO was largely (and expensively) underwritten by the U.S. Le Grand Charles [de Gaulle] withdrew France from the NATO military alliance in the early 1960s. That freed up who knows how much in the way of French resources, with France still effectively still living under the protection provided by NATO.

Personal note: When I was a kid, my dad, a U.S. Air Force officer, was stationed in France; we lived "on the economy" in a little farm village, where my sisters and I went to the local schools and as a result were bilingual. We were upset when we thought we were going to have to move back to the U.S., and leave our friends, sooner than scheduled because of de Gaulle's announced intention to kick out U.S. forces. (As it turned out, that didn't happen until after our scheduled move back to the U.S.)

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by smacktoward on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:36AM (#7243889)
> Also ask whether the French would actually have used nuclear weapons to stop a Soviet non-nuclear attack on France

I dunno whether the French would have, but I know the Americans would have. It was US policy through much of the Cold War that conventional forces in Europe were only to be a "tripwire" to trigger a nuclear response, rather than a force strong enough to contain a Soviet attack on their own. This allowed the US and other NATO nations to economize on conventional arms and avoid having to conscript massive numbers of men.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:11AM (#7243973)
I don't have any specific information about this, but somehow I doubt that the French atomic capability (Force de Frappe) would have been enough to destroy the USSR as a functioning society, in contrast to the U.S. nuclear arsenal, which was eminently capable of doing the job. The French nukes therefore would have had limited value as a deterrent against the Soviets.

Try this thought experiment:

First, recall the Soviets' ability to absorb fearful military punishment, as well as their willingness to act brutally in eastern- and central Europe during and after WW2; in East Germany in 1953; in Hungary in 1956; and in Czechoslovakia in 1968.

Second, imagine that in the 1950s or 1960s the Soviets had invaded Germany --- but also imagine that there was no effective NATO protection because (hypothetically) the U.S. had gone isolationist.

Third, assume that the Soviets had punched through Germany; reached the Rhine; and pushed through into France.

OK, now let's assume for the sake of argument that in response, the French had nuked the invading Soviet forces, but not the USSR homeland (for fear of provoking massive Soviet retaliation), using only small, tactical nukes.

It's not unreasonable to think that the Soviets would have responded in turn along much the same lines as they did in WWII --- but this time with their own nuclear weapons --- by obliterating the French armed forces, and probably a French city or three to make sure the message got through.

The French would (sensibly) have surrendered, of course. The Soviets then would have done much as they did in eastern Germany after WWII: They'd have carted off everything useful that they could, as war booty (euphemistically described as "reparations"). They probably would have shipped thousands of people off to slave-labor camps in the gulag, most of whom would not be seen nor heard from ever again. They'd have settled in to administer the ruined France as yet another impoverished Soviet vassal state under a Communist puppet government.

So France's nuclear Force de Frappe likely wasn't a real deterrent to the Soviets, but instead was merely anti-American and anti-British posturing by de Gaulle, safe behind what he knew would be the protective shield of NATO military power.

(Do de Gaulle's attitude and actions remind anyone else of what Hamid Karzai has been doing lately?)

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by michaelt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @09:12AM (#7243817)

  Also ask whether the French would actually have used 
  nuclear weapons to stop a Soviet non-nuclear attack on 
  France.
From what I've read, during the cold war many countries developed short-range, small yield nuclear weapons. American examples are some of the most famous, like the Davy Crockett missile.

The thinking was, for the same reason France might not use nuclear weapons against a non-nuclear attack, the Soviets might not use large nuclear weapons against a small nuclear weapon attack.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:09PM (#7246229)
In what way is this a guilt trip?

When you compare the US and the French system, you don't get to just say "well, they did it why can't we?" as if that question exists in a vacuum. We have a defense program which is a massive government expenditure -- which pre-empts other government expenditures such as single-payer health care -- so a fair comparison would have to look at the fact that the French had a de facto defense subsidy.

If each country in Western Europe had been responsible for building up the kind of deterrent force which we were able to present, the calculus for a single-payer program would change. Certainly Force de Frappe was a strategic asset. Can you concede that without NATO (dominated by the US) the French investment in defense would have needed a drastic increase in order to fill that vacuum? If there were no NATO, at the least I think you can acknowledge that all of Germany would have been a Soviet client, putting France on a front line against the Warsaw Pact countries.

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by CiaranMcNulty on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:19AM (#7243683)
As mentioned in the article, the USA spends more per capita on healthcare than France, so it's not as if they're achieving this better service by being incredibly lavish with spending.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by nox_ on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:58AM (#7243774)
This is the most out-of-place comment I have ever read.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by james1071 on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:51AM (#7243754)
What a dumb comment. France was at no risk whatsoever from the Soviet Union.
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by dctoedt on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:18AM (#7243993)
> France was at no risk whatsoever from the Soviet Union.

That's not the way it appeared at the time. Up until the mid-to late 1960s, it was entirely rational for Western leaders to conclude that the USSR wanted eventually to dominate all of Europe and even the Western Hemisphere. [1]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War#Beginnings_of_the_Cold...

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by usrusr on Sunday February 16, 2014 @12:49PM (#7248427)
> That's not the way it appeared at the time.

But how much of that appearance came in form of various gaps that were essentially paranioa turned into a marketing hoax for the weapons industry?

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by jessedhillon on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:13PM (#7246234)
Yes. This comment is much smarter and better informed. I mean, it's not like you had things like this happening during that time: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prague_Spring
Re:The French way of cancer treatment by aestra on Saturday February 15, 2014 @10:12AM (#7243976)
>The amusing part is that having this critical services being managed by the state seems so obvious to us that we don't think we are specially socialists

Neither does most Americans with many of their socialized services. Very few people are protesting for disbanding of police fire or public education or highway infrastructure.

Then we get people protesting like this

http://www.pensitoreview.com/2010/04/05/sublime-tea-baggery-...

(Medicare is socialized medicine. It is only available for the elderly and disabled though.)

Re:The French way of cancer treatment by baby on Saturday February 15, 2014 @08:17AM (#7243676)
And what's even funnier is all the facebook and twitter post à la "That's it, I'm leaving France, going to live in the US" every time there is a new president elected or a new controversial law that is passed.