I'd release new products regularly, while increasing the insurance premiums of old products. Healthy people would just switch to the new product to avoid the price increase, but people with pre-existing conditions wouldn't be eligible so I could price-gouge them.
So you could get insurance against expensive medical conditions - but if you had to claim on that insurance, suddenly your premiums would start rising by 30% a year, and you would have no alternative because of your pre-existing condition.
The companies that didn't engage in this would then look expensive to healthy people and attractive to unhealthy people. And if the healthy (profitable) people leave and unhealthy (subsidized) people join, meaning premiums have to go up further, you could get a chain reaction putting them out of business.
To bolster this example, I hear from my parents that this is more or less what's happened to insurance premiums in Switzerland since some idiot in government deregulated the insurance industry.
Get lung cancer? Here take $200k courtesy of your insurance. Only going to cost you $150k? "No problem, glad you found a cheaper place. Buy a nice gift for your wife with the difference"
Not to mention you are by necessity limited by the hospital and doctors on the insurance companies approved docs list. No thanks; they don't have my interests at heart.
Not to mention the very real incentive for such an insurance company to stop paying for "problem" clients with long ongoing illnesses.
The problem is that for the insurance to work optimally everyone have to chip in so that those that are healthy offset the cost of those that aren't.
In the US the young aren't getting insurance which is one of the reasons for the Offordable Healthcare Act. To force everyone to have an insurance so that economics become better.
Of course in reality the best possible system would be a single payer (tax based) healthcare system with some payment for usage but where no one can go bankrupt or be dropped or fall under the deadly pre-existing conditions clause.
Or a mandated private insurance like in Germany & Switzerland. Obamacare is one step of that way but it's so alien to US culture and have been so poorly implemented that on could fear for its future.
There is no mandated /private/ health insurance, there is just mandated health insurance in Germany.
See e.g. http://www.slowtravelberlin.com/guide-health-insurance-germa...