News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by WalterBright on Friday February 14, 2014 @06:00AM (#7237919)
> Capitalism rewards not just work and the investment of capital but also greed and cheating.

That implies that socialism and communism do not reward greed and cheating, which is hard to believe.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by simonh on Friday February 14, 2014 @06:30AM (#7237989)
In fact by concentrating strict monopolies on political, military, judicial and economic power in a narrow party elite, it pretty much guarantees it will be rewarded. I realize Communism and Socialism as abstract principles don't require this, but that seems to be the way it works out as they have been put into practice historically by actual Communists and Socialists.

There's nothing about capitalism that demands that monopolies of any kind should or must be allowed. This is a subject of much debate of course, since there is no single authority about what Capitalism is. It's not really an ideology in that sense. However if we take Adam Smith as playing the role for Capitalism that Marx plays for Communism, Smith was very much aware the markets must be very carefully regulated in order to protect the common good. Unfortunately Marx was, shall we say, considerably more utopian about how Communism would inevitably emerge and self-regulate itself.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by jbooth on Friday February 14, 2014 @09:23AM (#7238605)
"There's nothing about capitalism that demands that monopolies of any kind should or must be allowed."

It depends on what you mean by capitalism. If by capitalism, you mean a market-based economy, like that adam smith guy, then yeah, we should have anti-trust laws to guard against private anti-competitive behavior. If you mean lack of government interference at all costs (which is more a political program than an economic program, really), then no, monopolies and/or cartels will actually be the end state of many industries if you don't have laws preventing that behavior.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by dnautics on Friday February 14, 2014 @06:53AM (#7238042)
Also the concentration of power, corruption, and depredations against individuals (gulags etc) were predicted as an outcome of socialism and communism by Benjamin Tucker, a contemporary (and critic) of Marx.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by belorn on Friday February 14, 2014 @08:29AM (#7238336)
There is no such implied statement. Capitalism is not the logical opposite to socialism and communism. Assuming that what is true for one is automatically false for the other is a logical fallacy.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by WalterBright on Friday February 14, 2014 @03:42PM (#7240872)
In context of the rest of the parent post, it is listed as a characteristic of capitalism but omitted from socialism and communism, which is a clear implication it is not a characteristic common to all three.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by belorn on Friday February 14, 2014 @07:56PM (#7242111)
That is not how I read the parent post. It said that greed and cheating is serious flaw of capitalism - it reward greed and cheating.

Is every flaw of capitalism implied flaws of socialism and communism and vise verse? Every flaw of communism also a flaw in capitalism?

That is true only if one say that capitalism and communism and socialism is all the exact same ism.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by macspoofing on Friday February 14, 2014 @09:35AM (#7238675)
Not only hard to believe but wrong. Redistribution is at the heart of communism ( From each according to his ability, to each according to his need). This creates a huge incentives to cheat and lie in order to get a little bit more.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by gaius on Friday February 14, 2014 @06:44AM (#7238015)
It's easy to exaggerate ones needs and hide ones abilities.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by philwelch on Friday February 14, 2014 @11:22AM (#7239306)
Cheating by definition leads to undeserved reward. Greed by definition leads to maximal reward.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by nickff on Friday February 14, 2014 @01:10PM (#7239971)
>"Greed by definition leads to maximal reward."

Greed attempts to attain maximal reward, but this does not mean the reward is achieved. Greed is neither necessary or sufficient to achieve extraordinary outcomes.

Re:The Star Trek Economy by philwelch on Friday February 14, 2014 @03:02PM (#7240670)
Rational greed exploits whatever system you have though. A rationally greedy capitalist will do startups or work on Wall Street or something; a rationally greedy communist will gain political power. In a world of magical egalitarianism rational greed will increase the size of the pie for everyone; if you allow society to break egalitarianism purely to incentivize this kind of behavior you have become John Rawls.
Re:The Star Trek Economy by M2Ys4U on Saturday February 15, 2014 @07:54PM (#7246193)
Unfortunately, Perfectly rational actors rarely, if ever, exist.