Re:The Star Trek Economy
by belorn on Friday February 14, 2014 @08:29AM
(#7238336)
There is no such implied statement. Capitalism is not the logical opposite to socialism and communism. Assuming that what is true for one is automatically false for the other is a logical fallacy.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The Star Trek Economy
by WalterBright on Friday February 14, 2014 @03:42PM
(#7240872)
In context of the rest of the parent post, it is listed as a characteristic of capitalism but omitted from socialism and communism, which is a clear implication it is not a characteristic common to all three.
That is not how I read the parent post. It said that greed and cheating is serious flaw of capitalism - it reward greed and cheating.
Is every flaw of capitalism implied flaws of socialism and communism and vise verse? Every flaw of communism also a flaw in capitalism?
That is true only if one say that capitalism and communism and socialism is all the exact same ism.