Rather, the server replies with links to tweets, gists, etc. -- maria's public identity proofs. The keybase client does not trust that these are honest, so it scrapes them directly and makes sure they were signed by the same public key that the server provided. In other words, the server could reply with a different maria, and simply lie, but not with the real maria's github or twitter account.
The server could also lie by omission, leaving out an identity. But it cannot invent ones that do not exist, without the client knowing.
Again, the premise here is that maria is the sum of her online identities.
The website itself is of course a different story. When you look up maria on keybase's website, you are trusting that keybase.io did not lie about her github account. Fortunately you can confirm by following the link to her gist, where she announced her keybase username and posted her key fingerprint.
There's a reason that gpg does this..... Maria's twitter being hacked, Maria's github being hacked, Maria's Keystore being hacked....a lot can go wrong.
There are still weaknesses like, you lie about a github and link to your own github, and lie about the public key. And...many others.
Also, WoT works best when people meet other people they trust in person and sign each other's keys as the GNU/Linux community encourages. https://www.kernel.org/signature.html Then it's possible to get other people's keys elsewhere on the planet and know they're probably good given they're signed by someone you trust.
GPG mail plugins that popup a barcode that someone else can scan with their laptop's webcam or some mobile app.
GPG mail plugins should also have a search toolbar that can quickly get a key so it can be verified.
Mobile platforms must support GPG natively, many only support S/MIME.
SSL CAs:GnuPG (GPG/PGP) -> Subversion:Git
> keybase id maria
pgp: C4B3 15B4 7154 5281 5100 1C58 C2A5 977B 0022
github: mаria_leah ✓ https://gist.github.com/23423
twitter: mаria_h20 ✓ https://t.co/mаria_h20/523554
site: mаriah20.com ✓ https://mаriah20.com/X904F...
I looked up for 'maria', all ascii.
The answer, served by a malicious server, contains the first 'a' of maria in Cyrillic (check yourself, you'll see that 'mаria_leah' != 'maria_leah'). This would fool the user.Maybe the client should apply some logic as browsers do for IDN homograph attack to show characters not in your locale in a different way, or at least warn you.
But for future identity proofs (domains, for example, which we've yet to implement), this kind of attack is real. Our approach here will be that anything outside of normal ascii will be highlighted and addressed to the user, as a serious warning.
This form has essentially the same level of security as Hushmail. Anybody using it should consider the content exposed to Keybase or anyone compromising Keybase.
In the keybase Web client, all crypto happens on the browser. The server knows no keys or data in plaintext. Of course, you'd have to audit the front-end JS code to believe that claim.
But our intention is that the only way to compromise the Web-based tools would be to insert malicious JavaScript into the client's browser. A read-only compromise of the server yields only encrypted data, and the server never has access to the decryption keys.
Incidentally, you can't simply audit the "front-end Javascript"; you have to evaluate everything that influences the Javascript runtime (the DOM, stylesheets, cached resources, &c) every time the page loads. Browsers aren't designed to make content-controlled code "auditable"; it simply isn't a capability of the environment.
Next, people usually mumble about auditing it, downloading a copy, signing it, etc. At the end of the day, you arrive to code installed on the client - which you already have.
The web version just weakens your story.
1. I like the site design, the story flow on the front page does a great job of explaining what keybase is.
2. I see (from the abovementioned story flow) that keys can be verified by reviewing signed tweets/gists. Is this functionality extendable to arbitrary links; i.e. verifying keys against personal blogs, Tumblr, WordPress or does the third-party site need to implement a recognized API?
Again, thanks so much, and it looks like a terrific site so far.
With twitter, it's the ability to post a tweet under a certain username. With owning a tumblr account, it might be something similar. With your known StackExchange profile it might mean posting a statement in a specific part of your profile. And so on.
The common thread in each case is (1) that you post in a place where only your identity can, and (2) what you post is a signed statement claiming a connection among three things: (a) your keybase username, (b) your public key, and (3) the identity on that third party service. (The third one is necessary so it can't be moved elsewhere.) Note how twitter and github's are totally different, but achieving these three things.
We will build out this list of identity checks, hopefully making all kinds of them easy to do. Everything from proving you own a domain to having a tumblr or reddit accoun. The definition of those checks will all be publicly reviewable, both in the spec and in the client, which is what checks them for you.
Obviously Twitter isn't likely to implement either of those, so some high-value custom implementations are still great. But if Maria owns maria.com and can assert it automatically, that's pretty strong supporting evidence.
Authenticating a self-signed domain certificate via keybase is a neat idea, but would probably need some browser support, unless there's a clever hack that I'm not thinking of.
If you want to encrypt a message to my key, just run the following command:
gpg --auto-key-locate pka -ea -r mike([-dot-])cardwell([-at-])grepular([-dot-])com
It will automatically look up my PGP key in the DNS, fetch it, and encrypt to it. My DNS is secured using DNSSEC so if your resolve supports DNSSEC, you can be reasonably sure that the response is trustable. mike@glue:~$ dig +short txt mike.cardwell._pka.grepular.com
"v=pka1\;fpr=35BCAF1D3AA21F843DC3B0CF70A5F5120018461F\;uri=http://grepular.com/0018461F.pub.asc"
mike@glue:~$Her portfolio: http://www.hadilaksono.com/
Great idea and good luck!
It does demonstrate control of the email account, and you cannot fake it either.
The alpha site's changing every day, and we're working on the documentation now. I don't use the term "alpha" loosely. There will be extensive security details published, explaining every aspect of the identity proof system, client sessions, etc. They will be on the site before we open general access or turn beta. Right now only a few friends are on there. All that said, Max and I can answer questions here.
My profile on the site is https://keybase.io/chris if anyone wants to look. My profile demonstrates early examples of how identity proofs will work, including both twitter and github. We'll of course be adding other public identities in the future.
The site design is also very iffy at the moment; I was about to move into firefox bugs tomorrow.