News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by rlpb on Thursday February 13, 2014 @12:57PM (#7232876)
The law is not an algorithm that can be applied to tell you whether something is legal or not.

Both intent and context come into it heavily. If the majority of rsync shares contain private data, such that your search engine is effectively a private data search engine and can't really be used for anything else without continuously stumbling across more private data, then it could easily be considered radically different from Google's situation.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by lutusp on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:10PM (#7232969)
> The law is not an algorithm that can be applied to tell you whether something is legal or not.

That may be true in practice, but that's what the law is supposed to be -- an unambiguous social signaling system, that applies to all persons equally, without vagueness or the possibility of terminological confusion.

If a given law can be shown to be vague or confusing, it can be declared unconstitutional. Whether it will be declared unconstitutional depends on whether anyone is willing to fight about it in court.

But the principle of public law is -- yes! -- that it is an "algorithm that can be applied to tell you whether something is legal or not." A failure in this role represents a failure in the legal system itself.

> Both intent and context come into it heavily.

Absolutely false. Someone who breaks the law can't argue that their intent or the context makes any difference. That might affect the punishment, but it doesn't affect the question of guilt.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by IanCal on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:21PM (#7233049)
> Absolutely false. Someone who breaks the law can't argue that their intent or the context makes any difference. That might affect the punishment, but it doesn't affect the question of guilt.

How would you explain the difference between murder and manslaughter then? If someone dies on the operating table because the surgeon accidentally nicks an artery that's different from them actively trying to kill someone. The act is identical, only the intent is different.

Intent is, and should be, a deciding factor in whether or not someone is guilty of a crime.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by lutusp on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:27PM (#7233104)
>How would you explain the difference between murder and manslaughter then?

Circumstances, which can only affect the punishment, not the judgment that a crime has taken place. But I already said this.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by IanCal on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:39PM (#7233193)
Did you stop reading there?

> If someone dies on the operating table because the surgeon accidentally nicks an artery that's different from them actively trying to kill someone. The act is identical, only the intent is different.

In one case, there was a crime, in the other there wasn't.

> Circumstances, which can only affect the punishment, not the judgment that a crime has taken place. But I already said this.

The circumstances which change the crime committed. Not just punishment.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by lutusp on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:09PM (#7234811)
I shouldn't have made my original claim without thinking about the fact that there really are crimes that are defined by what is in a person's mind, apart from their actions. One thought, acceptable. Another thought, crime. Thought crime.

So I was being naive and you are right. And George Orwell was right.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by GhotiFish on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:23PM (#7234922)
I, uh, don't know about that, but I will say that thought and intent are not the same.

Thinking about murdering someone and not taking any action to that effect, then actually killing that person; VS taking action to do it, strike me as different.

It's possible that they are legally the same, but I doubt the court can do much to prove thought without a confession.

IANAL

Re:Secure your rsync shares by lutusp on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:41PM (#7235102)
> I, uh, don't know about that, but I will say that thought and intent are not the same.

True, but it's to some extent splitting hairs, because intent is often (but not always) constructed from thoughts.

> Thinking about murdering someone and not taking any action to that effect, then actually killing that person; VS taking action to do it, strike me as different.

Most courtroom battles on these issues revolve around trying to reconstruct intent based on things that actually happened and that can be presented as testimony. Premeditation, for example -- the difference between degrees of murder in many states -- might be inferred by a person's actions leading up to a crime, and afterward.

> It's possible that they are legally the same, but I doubt the court can do much to prove thought without a confession.

It's commonplace for prosecutions to proceed on the basis of a record of actions that are used to infer thoughts and intents.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by sitkack on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:53PM (#7233805)
I agree that this is how the law should be applied, it makes logical sense. But it isn't how it works. I'd like every cop that kills someone to be tried for murder and then let the courts determine if it is justified, not the prosecuting attorney.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by sitkack on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:49PM (#7233776)
Intent is a huge founding tenet in English law (which American law is derived). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Intention_in_English_law

He would be liable for exposing private data, because of the kind of data he found wouldn't be reasonably published.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by 6cxs2hd6 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:07PM (#7235319)
But IIUC US Federal law generally ignores intent -- in a bad way for the accused. A lack of bad intent isn't a mitigating factor.

Prosecutorial discretion is tricky enough to begin with. But also mix in disregarding intent, and season with charging people multiple times for the same act? Federal prosecutors can be little Putins.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by sitkack on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:19PM (#7235786)
Rip Aaron Swartz
Re:Secure your rsync shares by aidenn0 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:27PM (#7233108)
> Someone who breaks the law can't argue that their intent or the context makes any difference.

Huh? The law takes intent into account all the time. (Criminal Defamation, for example).

Re:Secure your rsync shares by andrewflnr on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:24PM (#7233074)
What the law "should" be is very little comfort if you land in jail anyway. Makes it worse, in fact. I agree with you on what the law should be, but it doesn't matter here, unless you're prepared for an enormous fight.

By the way, have you heard of "hate crimes"? Those are a real thing, according to the law, anyway.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by GhotiFish on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:17PM (#7234876)
>> Both intent and context come into it heavily.

>Absolutely false.

seriously? I thought most laws literally have "intent" as a requirement written into them.

With the OP's service dedicated to explicitly revealing unintentionally insecure rsync servers, I can only imagine the plethora of horrid cyber security laws he would be vulnerable to.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by yeahbutbut on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:49PM (#7233273)
Is it really private if the owners made the data publicly available?
Re:Secure your rsync shares by VBprogrammer on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:59PM (#7233389)
I know bringing things from the real world into the digital realm often results in badly overstretched metaphors. Allow me this one; are your belongings really yours if you forget to lock the door?
Re:Secure your rsync shares by sp332 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:37PM (#7234118)
It's not about ownership, it's about privacy. Yes, people are allowed to look at your stuff if you leave it in a public place.

Edit: it's even stronger in this case, because it's your own equipment that is providing the data to anyone who asks politely (using industry-standard requests and no impersonation or other fraud).

Re:Secure your rsync shares by Someone on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:49PM (#7235608)
But is your living room a public place, if you leave your front door open? I don't think so.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by sp332 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:05PM (#7235699)
But you're not in the living room. You asked for the data politely and the server sent the data to you. It even put your address on it to deliver it over the public internet.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by yeahbutbut on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:22PM (#7233578)
> Allow me this one; are your belongings really yours if you forget to lock the door?

Practically, it depends on where you live. In major urban areas: no they're gone and they probably aren't coming back. Insurance might replace some of them.

In the sticks? Most people don't lock their doors, even if they shut them.

> I know bringing things from the real world into the digital realm often results in badly overstretched metaphors.

Except this metaphor is already stretched beyond breaking. An index isn't even a copy.

Copying a set of publicly available read-only files is not theft (you still have your copy I haven't deprived you of it).

But we're not even talking about copying your files, just the names you've assigned to them. And in his proposed form, even allowing you to remove the names from our index.

Pretty kind treatment for a copy that you've given me when I asked for it.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by sneak on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:30PM (#7234071)
> forget to lock the door

oh god this again

Re:Secure your rsync shares by infinite8s on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:03PM (#7233881)
Your belongings are really only yours to the extent that social contract (ie the law) defines them as such or you are able to prevent other people from taking them. Everything else is an illusion.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by gnaritas on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:04PM (#7233434)
Yes. And trespassing is still trespassing even if I leave the front door open. Hacking is still hacking even if the computer is left unsecured.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by yeahbutbut on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:12PM (#7233505)
Creating an index of these files seems more like driving down the street taking pictures of all the houses with their front doors left open. Something Google seems to get away with on a regular basis.
Re:Secure your rsync shares by __david__ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:48PM (#7234211)
Trespassing is not a good example. Let's say your private home is (for some reason) in the middle of some downtown area, where every neighbor is a public shop (IE, the expectation is that everything is welcome to the public). Not only that, it's pretty much indistinguishable from the outside from all the other public shops around it. In this scenario, if you leave your door wide open in the middle of the day then no one would take your cries of trespassing seriously.

So no, I don't think trespassing is necessarily still trespassing, even if you leave the front door open. Like most things in life, it depends on context.

The expectation and the norm of this situation is that data published on public ports is for public consumption. You can't blame someone for accessing data that you put out there in a public manner, even unintentionally.

Re:Secure your rsync shares by gnaritas on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:24PM (#7235443)
Oh I agree, context matters and courts would certainly take it into account. Police however might not.