News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by chris_wot on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:55AM (#7230242)
The original blog post was on HN front page yesterday and it got voted down to oblivion. Or hit some sort of threshold. Frankly, I find the original blog post to be unbelievably weasily - especially this:

"We believe that if you put the user front and center, you can make every experience for them richer and more meaningful. The Content Services team has embraced this, and today I wanted to share some of our thinking and explain our first steps for putting it into practice."

and then:

"While Mozilla hasn’t always seen eye-to-eye with all viewpoints in the digital content community, particularly the IAB, we think they’d agree that users’ interests should come first, and we want to help their members deliver compelling content to strengthen the Web ecosystem."

This:

* beats around the bush

* starts with spin

* says that advertisers have the best interest of users in mind - and I assure you, they do not.

I am very, very unimpressed.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by chestnut-tree on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:39PM (#7234139)
I think people would have (possibly) reacted a little less criticially to this news if the original Mozilla blog post simply got straight to the point i.e.

- Mozilla needs to raise money because it's a non-profit.

- We're going to place ads on the "directory tiles" page.

Questions the Mozilla blog post should have answered, but never did:

- Will these ads only ever appear once?

- Will these ads re-appear if you clear your cache or cookies?

- Can this feature be disabled or bypassed?

- What analytics or tracking will the ads use (if any)?

I understand that Mozilla needs to diversify its sources of funding. I just wish the Mozilla blog post was written in a plain, straightforward manner. There's far too much padding and "corporate-speak".

Phrases such as "publisher transformation", experiences that are "richer and more meaningful", promises to "transform the user’s content experience", and to provide "inherent value to our users" just sound over-inflated and meaningless.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by Drakim on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:23AM (#7230367)
Especially the last part infuriates me, I'm now being done a favor by having ads shoved in my face against my will?

There is just no way you can spin that as "helping", it's advertisements, nothing more, nothing less.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by sheetjs on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:23AM (#7230373)
> it got voted down to oblivion.

It was flagged heavily, which shouldn't be a surprise given the heavy pro-Mozilla bias here. (case in point: this post will be downvoted at least a few times in the next few minutes)

But to be fair, the ads haven't been rolled out yet, and there's a nonzero chance Mozilla will come to their senses and reverse course. And if not, use a browser that actually values your privacy and safety (my current browser is SRWare Iron https://www.srware.net/en/software_srware_iron.php)

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by shrikant on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:09AM (#7230533)
See this: https://web.archive.org/web/20100614055220/http://chromium.h...

I'm not sure what's changed since then, but it's worth considering.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by fauigerzigerk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:14AM (#7230326)
"Mozilla said that the ads are part of an attempt to connect new browser users to sites that they might find relevant."

I understand that Mozilla is looking for ways to fund itself. But they should not join those who use the word "relevant" in this disingenuous way.

This phrasing is an obvious attempt to sugarcoat the fact that we are being inundated by so many schemes to grab a piece of our limited cognitive capacity that we wouldn't even be able to notice something relevant if it were actually there.

Mozilla's advantage over other browser makers is that users trust them not to use the kind of deceptive chicanery that we're being subjected to left and right. So they better not ruin that trust by using dishonest language.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by lucb1e on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:48AM (#7230205)
I'm thinking about proposing something like "I'll run your bloody ads for 1 month. Then you tell me how much you earn off of me and I'll pay you twice that."

I'm all for Mozilla getting income from more sources (instead of search engine revenue), but I just don't like ads. There is a reason I donated in the past.

If I can't disable the ads this way, it's not that hard to install an add-on that does it, edit about:config or just recompile from sources. No problem if you want to play that game. But I'd much rather pay them.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by zebra on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:14AM (#7230327)
The ads in fact are placeholders in the empty dial screen. They will disappear after you visit 6 sites. I'm not 100% sure, but I think that you will not be tracked if they are shown to you.

If Mozilla does not cross this border I'm fine with this very passive advertisement.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by fauigerzigerk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:50AM (#7230469)
The point is that Firefox was supposed to be the browser where you can feel safe. The way they are explaining this new monetization scheme makes me feel that I have to get my guard up.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by chris_wot on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:22AM (#7230745)
Darren Herman is from MDC Partners, a massive advertising company. Then he founded a "media management" company. He's a "marketing innovator".

He writes ambiguous phrases that tend to contradict themselves like "Publisher Transformation with Users at the Center" (what?) and "The new tab page isn’t delivering any value for them." (double-what?)

Let's look at some of the wording from this guy [1], it's straight out of some PR/advertising agency. It makes me so incredibly suspicious, and I worry it will be counter to Mozilla's goals.

"Some of these tile placements will be from the Mozilla ecosystem, some will be popular websites in a given geographic location, and some will be sponsored content from hand-picked partners to help support Mozilla’s pursuit of our mission."

A given geographic region? Who says that it's popular? Hand-picked partners? Who picks them? What are the requirements for being "hand-picked"?

Let's look at some more language, filled with buzz-words and devalued propositions:

We are excited about Directory Tiles because it has inherent value to our users.

While Mozilla hasn’t always seen eye-to-eye with all viewpoints in the digital content community, particularly the IAB, we think they’d agree that users’ interests should come first, and we want to help their members deliver compelling content to strengthen the Web ecosystem.

When the user is at the center everyone benefits

We believe that if you put the user front and center, you can make every experience for them richer and more meaningful.

I know many will find me harsh, but when I read these things I also immediately have my guard up. I wonder what is being hidden behind these frankly contradictory and ambiguous statements. There is, to my mind, a falseness to them that is disturbing. This sort of language is what a politician or PR agency would use to deliver unpalatable news. I feel very strongly that it has no place being on an official Mozilla blog.

1. https://blog.mozilla.org/advancingcontent/2014/02/11/publish...

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by ars on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:10AM (#7230304)
In my config I set browser.newtab.url to about:blank

I have someone javascript bookmarklets and they don't work with the regular new tab page, but they do with about:blank

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by vanderZwan on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:46AM (#7230196)
> "We wanted to get away from being this window into the web that doesn't bring value," to users, she said.

Nice bit of doublespeak there. Not showing me ads is valuable to me, you jerks.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by panacea on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:55AM (#7230247)
I don't get the anger at this. They're talking about pre-populating the tiles with some websites before you fill them up with your own most visited sites.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by chris_wot on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:08AM (#7230291)
I can only really speak for myself, but the reason I feel angry is because advertising is a manipulative and often dishonest industry. Mozilla is the total antithesis of this, and it seems very wrong the way it was announced and the manner in which it was done.

I certainly don't see any discussion around the decision - who made the decision to prepopulate the tiles? Where is the original debate? How involved was the IAB in this decision? When did this get decided and for how long now? What stakeholders were notified?

What about privacy concerns - how will these ads target me? I don't want Firefox to turn into some sort of Facebook where my data isn't safe. There are no details about how they will achieve this increased advertising. In the original blog post, they have said they will target advertising via the country you are residing in - but what other data will it start detecting?

All very worrying.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by joveian on Thursday February 13, 2014 @07:20AM (#7230894)
I'm guessing they aren't going to do tracking yet, but I agree the "we're going to start advertising for the users" presentation is super worrying. This is advanced doublethink. If they can't be honest about the most reasonable changes then I don't trust that they won't at some point make unreasonable changes and simply not mention them. It sounds like they may be trying to copy Opera so take a look at what Opera is doing to see where they might be headed.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by panacea on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:59AM (#7230829)
You think Mozilla will ride the slippery slope to promoting malware or something in the tiles?

It will be links to decent sponsors webpages I'll bet.

Their announcement has been filtered through asshole media.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by blueskin_ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:29AM (#7230401)
"We wanted to get away from being this window into the web that doesn't bring value to our shareholders"

What she really meant.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by cLeEOGPw on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:49AM (#7230214)
Non-profit does not mean free labor.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by kevingadd on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:48AM (#7230206)
Non-profits still have to pay salaries. Or would you prefer FF effectively no longer exist and have to use Chrome instead?

Honestly, explicit ads marked as ads in the UI are preferable to hidden advertisement/deals - like defaulting to Google search without communicating to users that money has changed hands for that preferential treatment.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by dragonwriter on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:10AM (#7230303)
> Or would you prefer FF effectively no longer exist and have to use Chrome instead?

With this anti-feature, I would use Chrome anyway -- even if it was otherwise identical to FF.

> Honestly, explicit ads marked as ads in the UI are preferable to hidden advertisement/deals - like defaulting to Google search without communicating to users that money has changed hands for that preferential treatment.

Whether its the default I prefer or one that I don't, the why they set the default doesn't matter. What matters is (a) is it clear up front what the default is, (b) is it what I prefer, and (c) if not, is it clear and simple to change.

OTOH, ads in the browser UI are a significant anti-feature compared to all the browsers that don't do that.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by pekk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:53AM (#7230229)
A browser which shows me ads versus one which doesn't show me ads. Pretty easy choice. In both cases the funding is coming from ads, but one of these is waving them in my face all the time and the other one isn't.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by kevingadd on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:08AM (#7230292)
The Google search bar that appears in Firefox when you install it, with a Google icon, is effectively an advertisement paid for with Google's money. The fact that it's an effective advertisement (and most people use that search bar) doesn't make it not an advertisement.

Note that for example the default search provider has been different in other countries at times based on other advertising deals Mozilla made - not just Google. It's easier to view it as not-an-ad when it's a search provider you use; less so than when it is a random provider that bid the highest amount.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by rplnt on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:53AM (#7230232)
Don't they have enough money from Google? They must make at least one dollar a year from each user through search. One would guess...

Or is Google finally cutting into that? Just another way to get rid of competing browsers? Sadly Bing isn't an alternative outside of US (and I'm not even sure about that).

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by sgk284 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:10AM (#7230300)
Mozilla has publicly stated that they make at least $300 million per year from Google (as of 2011) [1]. Although there are reports that this is closer to $1 billion per year now (including all search-related revenues).

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation#Financing

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by nnethercote on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:31AM (#7230408)
Where are those $1 billion reports from? That's the first I've heard of a number anything like that large. Firefox's market share hasn't tripled recently, and the current deal with Google is the same one that started in 2011, so it sounds unlikely to me.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by sgk284 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @02:05PM (#7233438)
Yep, you're right. I had read something about Google paying Mozilla $1B, but upon trying to re-dig up the info all I'm getting is non-conclusive and/or misleading articles.

$300MM is still a giant number.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by kevingadd on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:07AM (#7230284)
Define 'enough money'. Should they cut back every non-essential employee until they have 5 people in a room, one of them responsible for all Firefox development? Should they assume that the Google revenue party will last forever, despite the fact that Google clearly is motivated to get all users on their own browser?

I think it makes sense to diversify the ways they can earn money, and advertising is a reasonable approach as long as it's honest. Nothing here seems to indicate that they will be disguising advertisements or sacrificing usability in favor of advertisements.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by dragonwriter on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:12AM (#7230320)
> Should they assume that the Google revenue party will last forever, despite the fact that Google clearly is motivated to get all users on their own browser?

Building an additional layer of advertising into the FF browser is a good way to advance Google's goal of getting all users on Google's browser.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by DanBC on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:38AM (#7230440)
That is a truly baffling stance to take.

Firefox will present new users a panel of six ad tiles. These exist as placeholders for the most visited site tiles. The ads are replaced by the most visited sites, and then they are gone.

Chrome - exists to gather information about the user to send that information back to Google for them to more efficiently serve you ads.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by dragonwriter on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:41PM (#7233209)
IOW, Chrome affects the selection of ads I'm presented on web pages where I am going to see ads no matter what browser I use, Firefox shows additional ads.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by lucian1900 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:27AM (#7230393)
I'd really much rather pay for Firefox (or almost any product/service, really) than have to live with ads.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by DanBC on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:34AM (#7230417)
These ads only exist until you've populated your six most visited sites.

The google default exists until you change it.

You have already been living with ads. But the google ad was not explicit.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by lucian1900 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:23AM (#7230569)
The Google ad happened to match my preferences, sure. I would've noticed more if the default was different.

But just because I live with ads doesn't mean I like it. I'd much rather pay Google a flat fee for all of their services for the assurance that I will never see an ad and my data is not used for their mining.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by blueskin_ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:30AM (#7230406)
I'd rather pay for Firefox, especially if it means they stop halfarsedly aping every bad feature Chrome does as well.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by matthewbadeau on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:40AM (#7230171)
The link didn't work for me but I found the article here: http://news.cnet.com/8301-1001_3-57618750-92/mozilla-to-sell...
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by eXpl0it3r on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:54AM (#7230238)
Didn't work for me either, thanks for a working link!
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by chris_wot on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:55AM (#7230248)
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by nodata on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:00AM (#7230264)
I don't mind Firefox earning money, but can't see how they will avoid the user tracking problem. At some point they will be under pressure to increase revenues, and the advertisers will want more information on who is viewing their ads.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by rubbingalcohol on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:55AM (#7230245)
I would be happy to see ads on the new tab page in Firefox if it means supporting Mozilla. They're doing so much stuff to protect freedom on the Internet, and I just don't see the big deal with helping talented people pay their bills.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by blueskin_ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:29AM (#7230396)
Fuck that, I'd rather pay a small donation. £5/year is going to be more than they get from me for ads (as nobody wants to pay per impression, only click) and I'd double that if necessary.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by doe88 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:02AM (#7230273)
Likewise if it's done wisely (no tracking, ads provided only from Mozilla servers and ideally only once in a while) I'm all for it.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by kule on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:12AM (#7230317)
Reading the original article [1] this doesn't look like such a big issue.

For new users that don't have any recently used sites rather than blank tiles they will get some Mozilla suggested sites and some sponsored tiles.

I presume for existing users you'll never even see these and, for new users, as soon as you've actually visited some sites these will disappear.

[1] https://blog.mozilla.org/advancingcontent/2014/02/11/publish...

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by companerx on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:25AM (#7230382)
So they're going to have certain sponsors' sites on my default New Tab page until I replace them with something else? The horror!!

You people and your slippery slopes.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by jbrooksuk on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:54AM (#7230236)
And there was me enjoying the switch I made just last week.
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by auvrw on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:26AM (#7230388)
so just to double-check: no chance of this making it into iceweasel, right?
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by blueskin_ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:27AM (#7230392)
New tab thumbnails preemptively disabled.

Between this, making Sync less secure and Australis, I start seriously wondering if Mozilla are attempting to drive users away.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by lucian1900 on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:25AM (#7230576)
The more secure sync was apparently too hard to use for non-experts.

Australis is a matter of taste, I personally like it.

They're trying to not drive users away, but you and I are a tiny minority.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by blueskin_ on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:30AM (#7230593)
So why not educate users instead? Especially with the NSA/GCHQ spying still so recent.

Firefox is already a power user's browser - the masses who just want a dumb facebook/youtube/twitter/gmail terminal mostly use chrome and will continue to do so, unaware and unconcerned with customisation and privacy issues (my parents use chrome, and didn't have any addons installed at one point (they now have adblock)). Firefox will never even catch up to where chrome is today in market share, let alone pass it, and I'm fine with that, as it's a browser for power users - customisable, privacy-respecting and more 'traditional' by giving users actual control over their experience and options to customise functionality and looks.

To use beer as an analogy, Chrome is {Budweiser/PBR/Coors/Miller/etc}; Firefox is a craft beer. Yes, it's nicer, but not as accessible, and the majority of people neither know nor care as it's not their market.

Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by D9u on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:08AM (#7230293)
Re:Mozilla to sell New Tab page ads in Firefox by pratkar on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:24AM (#7230375)
I dont care as long as Ad Blocker works well on this!