Also, the DOJ does not have sole authority to challenge. Here is the breakdown for telecommunications (taken from DOJ website, http://www.justice.gov/atr/icpac/3b.htm)
Telecommunications. Mergers involving telecommunications
service providers usually are subject to competition policy
review or challenge by:
One of the federal antitrust agencies (only the DOJ has
jurisdiction to review mergers involving telephone
companies; both the DOJ and the FTC have reviewed mergers
between cable television firms);
The Federal Communications Commission (FCC);(8)
The PSC of each state in which the parties do business
(although most state PSCs lack jurisdiction over cable
television mergers and some lack jurisdiction over mergers);
In the case of cable television, county and municipal
authorities with responsibility for granting and overseeing
cable franchise agreements;
The attorney general of each state in which the merging
parties do business; and
Private entities such as competitors to the merging parties.
As with mergers involving electric power firms, review by
any of these entities is nonexclusive. Approval of a
transaction by one entity does not preclude a separate
challenge by any of the other entities, nor does it bar
another entity from seeking adjustments that exceed
concessions that resolved the concerns of other bodies.
I suspect the DOJ (who has sole jurisdiction in telecommunications) will object, and that comcast is just willing to fight it out in court.What's different is that electricity tends to be heavily regulated, and water is generally a public utility. Cable providers are historically under no such constraint, because we tend to think of them as television content providers first and foremost, and the TV bit of the business is not a natural monopoly. Unfortunately that is where they make their money, and that leads to some really obnoxious behavior, including price gouging people who want their network services but not a TV content subscription.
Probably the best solution would be to go the same route that many other countries do and require network operators to share network bandwidth with anyone who can pay for it. That would allow us to re-instate market competition on top of the bit where it cannot occur naturally, while still allowing them to maintain their regularly scheduled TV industry whatever-ness.
In the US, this fact was pretty clearly demonstrated when the regulatory overhaul of the telephone industry in the 1990s introduced competition by requiring owners of the local copper to share it, and also by how people are able to choose their long distance carrier. The latter would be analogous to being able to choose among any number of ISPs while still using the same copper to handle the last mile.
Unfortunately, cable companies live under a different set of regulations, so the same rules don't apply to them. Meanwhile the industry progressed to the point that in many markets companies that were once just cable and phone companies now offer the same menu of services. But the law hasn't changed to keep up with that, so the net result is that we've got a regulatory regime that cripples an already anemic competitive environment by arbitrarily giving an enormous advantage to only one of the players.