422 MJ capacitors ←────────────┐
↓ │
(?) xenon flash lamps │
↓ │
3 MJ IR laser pulse │
↓ │
1.5 MJ UV pulse │
↓ │
150 kJ X-ray pulse │
↓ │
* 14-17 kJ Fusion yield (this story) │
↓ │
7-9 kJ Potential electricity →────────┘
system
breakeven
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#NIF...As it was already mentioned in the threads like this before, the NIF was built using the technology that was available in those years of the past when NIF was planned and started. Flash lamp pumped lasers are bigger, more expensive and much less efficient, i.e. mere few percents efficiency at best vs. tens of percent efficiency of modern laser diode pumped IR lasers. (Even with such improvement though, i still think laser driven fusion is inferior to many other forms of inertial confinement and much less probable to result in system-level break-even. My personal favorite, Sandia Z-machine is on the scale of 15% efficiency of generating X-ray pulse, and schemes like deep plasma focus or polywell by-pass the energy to radiation conversion stage all together and thus avoid related losses.)
EDIT: Okay here, but I have limited bandwidth so get it while you can: https://mega.co.nz/#!CNgVhZra!JcsLGB5y0FGUffI4rdyNr-BBl82YJD...
Also, if you do "pull an Aaron Schwartz" please change the ending - we need a very public Supreme court administered kick-in-the-teeth for all the out of control copyright regime and its criminal sentencing farce.
"Come now, editorial board of Nature. Do you expect me to pay for a subscription?"
"No, Mr. Finster -- we expect you to fuse!"
The terrorists won.
It could then be called the Terraists and possibly solve the whole issue through discordant namespace collision.
Right now they are 3 orders of magnitude off (10^15 they get, 10^18 or better 10^19 they want).
Mirroring: https://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/216352/bigscarylaser.pdf.
My tax dollars paid for this research I should be able to read it.
As far as YC is concerned AirBNB and Uber encourage people to break the law all the time, some rules are just stupid and outdated and don't make sense and should be broken. This is "Hacker" News after all.
1. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lawrence_Livermore_National_Lab...
I mean, I agree with you, but this is a silly statement. Just because the government pays for something does not allow you access to it.
That's not this work, but arguably the original motives and intent of the law is subverted if what's happening here is the government outsourcing the creation of the work to a third party.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_status_of_work_by_the...
I see no parallels to firearm possession.
In what world does personal expected value versus expected cost of breaking the law ever become a good way to make moral decisions?
There are at least two counterarguments to this.
1) The law is written for precisely this reason. Most people do live by a cost vs benefit mindset, and the penalties of laws are generally tuned until people stop committing the crime. I wouldn't want to live in a world where the penalty for murder was only a week in prison.
2) Anyone who uses the law as a way to guide their own moral compass probably isn't very moral, because throughout history every society has had laws which are later agreed to be evil.
I suppose my question is, do you care more about expressing yourself than convincing others? If so, then that's detrimental to a message board.
In this one, where my taxes paid for the goddamned research.
IMO, IP is a loaded term that distorts the wide range of issues. IM for Intellectual Monopoly is much closer to the truth. To be clear I have no problem with the idea of copyright or a well run power company being run as a local monopoly, but there outside of the normal business. And the goals should be finding rules that best serve society not the owners of said monopoly.
If the public is paying for the research should they not have access to the published papers resulting from it without paying $32 to a private company for a PDF download?
D-T fusions are about 17.6 MeV, but 80% of that is in neutrons, which escape unless captured in a special blanket. The 8 kJ reported was all alphas. So 8 kJ / 3.5 MeV = 1.4e16 fusions, vs. 5e15 in the quote. He was probably talking about a previous shot.
For comparison, a typical AA battery stores 16 kJ.
E_{fusion} is the calculated neutron yield Y_{total}=6.1e15 times 17.6 MeV: 17.2 kJ + rounding. Check out page 3, right column.
Anyone have a figure that represents how far off they are?
That's fine by me, it was not very long ago that we were unable to get more out of the fuel than we put into the fuel. That's step one to fusion ignition, and was done for the very first time last fall, so as far as I'm concerned they are still fleshing out step one.
http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/vaop/ncurrent/full/natu...
They would like to charge you $32 to look at it, nature-ally.
The fusion yield is (?) 14 kilojoules (inferring this from physicist Mark Herrman's "5 million billion fusions" [WaPo], at 18 MeV per fusion), which is a moderate improvement over the 8 kilojoule achivement from last fall:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6459289
[WaPo] http://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/fusion...
The "1%" energy efficiency figure [a] is misleading: 14 kJ is about 1% of 1.5 MJ of ultraviolet light hitting the fuel capsule. But creating that UV pulse consumed 3 MJ of infrared light, which in turn took 400 MJ from the flash bulbs driving the IR laser. So the system efficiency is more like 0.003% (and throwing in hypothetical turbines to generate electricity, 0.001%).
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#NIF...
[a] I'm referring to this: "while more energy came from fusion than went into the hydrogen fuel, only about 1 percent of the laser's energy ever reached the fuel."
(update: from yosyp's link, the fusion figures were 14.4 kJ, and 17.3 kJ, on two different runs:
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=7227950