News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Oculus on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:10PM (#7227331)
> led NIF's critics to label the facility an enormous waste of taxpayer dollars

> government shifted NIF away from its fusion goals to focus on its other mission: simulating the conditions inside nuclear weapons

I think right there lies the problem with our world. People take up more issue with a multi-billion dollar research facility for science than one for military applications. If we spent a small fraction of the world's military spending on these big, as Google likes to put it, moonshot projects we could probably solve some really fundamental world problems (i.e. energy, climate change) in the near future vs. waiting many, many decades (if not centuries).

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by icegreentea on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:25PM (#7227439)
Do not want to argue with the main thrust of your argument (because I agree with it), but at least part of the reason why people had an issue with the NIF as energy research, but less so as a nuclear test simulator is because the NIF as a device is pretty clearly designed to simulate nuclear detonations. If the problem is "you're wasting taxpayer money", the issue isn't the dollar amount spent, its the return on the money. As a science experiment, the return of the NIF is probably pretty crappy. As a nuclear arms tester, its almost invaluable (infinite return!!!) if you accept the dual propositions that America should obey its nuclear test treaties obligations, and that America gains significant benefits from maintaining their nuclear arsenal.

The NIF was clearly built to maintain America's nuclear arms capabilities, both in providing employment to nuclear physicists, as well as maintaining the viability of the current stockpile. It was practically transparent from the beginning.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by DennisP on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:39PM (#7228262)
It's not quite that clearcut. Since the 1970s a lot of fusion scientists have been keenly interested in laser fusion for power production. It's just that they had to give the program a military justification in order to get funding.

Source: Search for the Ultimate Energy Source: A History of the U.S. Fusion Energy Program, by Stephen O. Dean, who was a major figure in the U.S. fusion program.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by twelvechairs on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:46PM (#7227576)
there's two ways you can take 'return on investment' - the wholistic qualitative way (if x has a tiny chance of improving the whole world then its worth it) or the narrow quantitative way (once we research it, we'l probably have to give x away basically for free and its is likely not to work out anyway and will take years so its practically valueless to our organisation on this years financial model).

unfortunately the latter is used almost exclusively. even in public organisations who should be able to take the broader of public good.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by chc on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:11PM (#7227711)
"Return on investment" generally means what you get back for what you put in. Both quality and quantity matter and I think this is often recognized, but if you're getting essentially nothing, it doesn't matter what quality of nothing you get.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by twelvechairs on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:53PM (#7229037)
yeah - perhaps to better word what I said 'return on investment' for a public body should include a broad definition of 'what you get back' as in 'what the public gets back' not just 'what the agency gets back'. the latter is generally easier to quantify and easy to quantify things are easy to consider and contrast.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by valarauca1 on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:23PM (#7227424)
The cost of the B-2 Bomber program has cost as much as ~5 Large Hadron Colliders.

B-2 bomber program cost 44.75 billion[1] LHC cost ~7.5 Billion Euro ~9billion USD.[2]

[1] http://www.fas.org/man/gao/nsiad97181.htm

[2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Large_Hadron_Collider#Cost

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Oculus on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:29PM (#7227470)
The B-2 Bomber is child's play compared to the F-35's 1 Trillion USD program [1], but the comparison to the LHC's pricetag really puts things in prespective.

1: http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/03/29/us-lockheed-fighte...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by dmix on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:14PM (#7227722)
Or even better failed military projects, such as the $25+ billion spent on a spy satellite project before it was killed in 2002.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Reconnaissance_Office...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by amcnett on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:44PM (#7228296)
The F-35 is not exactly a resounding success: http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2013-02-22/flawed-f-35-fighter...
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by arethuza on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:58AM (#7230683)
It must be a resounding success - the UK is about to commit to buying some - like we committed to buying Skybolt and the F-111 (cancelling the awesome home grown TSR 2 in the process):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BAC_TSR-2

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by protomyth on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @08:11PM (#7228689)
No, at this point we should have built more F-22s for air-to-air. Strange how the "cheap" program is now the expensive one.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by deletes on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:32PM (#7227490)
Yeah... I see no benefit in those, having a few more colliders instead would be really great.

Or just start building the next version already!

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Zancarius on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:20PM (#7227761)
> Yeah... I see no benefit in those, having a few more colliders instead would be really great.

That's because you're seeing it through the lens of our time. Remember, the B-2, and many other programs including the F-22, were devised during the trailing end of the Cold War (edit: that's actually a lie; the call for contracts and other such nonsense that would lead to the B-2 started in the 70s, and the F-22 program had existed in some form since the very early 80s). Whatever your conviction about whether or not such things should exist, government (and their militaries) in particular has a great deal of inertia, both in terms of expenditures and policies. So while both programs were in full swing during the collapse of the USSR, that era is primarily what laid the groundwork for such expenses.

Personally, I'm a fan of both. I love the hardware used in high energy physics. And I love military hardware.

If I were about 15 years younger and lived in a wetter climate, I'd go outside and splash in the mud right now. ;)

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Noughmad on Thursday February 13, 2014 @09:03AM (#7231387)
The Supercoducting Supercollider was started during the Cold War too, but that didn't stop anyone from cancelling it half-way through.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by deletes on Thursday February 13, 2014 @10:37AM (#7231853)
Can I just say, that Superconducting Supercollider is the most awesome name for a device ever, and should be used for the next version.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Zancarius on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:04PM (#7233888)
Then they should hire Ellen McLain, the voice actress who did GLaDoS, to narrate a documentary on the Super-conducting Super-collider.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by deletes on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:04PM (#7234329)
I knew I heard it before!

From the game: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rsXjI6BhMV8

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Zancarius on Thursday February 13, 2014 @06:10PM (#7235349)
Just needed your memory jogged! :D
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Florin_Andrei on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:51PM (#7228345)
> The cost of the B-2 Bomber program has cost as much as ~5 Large Hadron Colliders.

This is the kind of thing that makes me really wanna ragequit on human nature.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Gravityloss on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:35PM (#7227506)
Here's another article that looks at some acquisition programs just by the US Marines. Navy, Army and Air Force acquisitions are often much bigger. Scroll for the tables.

http://www.mca-marines.org/gazette/article/ace-ate-marine-co...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by adventured on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:57PM (#7227630)
I'd like to have a few more satellites that have the impact of a hubble. That cost ~$4b inflation adjusted.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by gnoway on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:52PM (#7227953)
Does this adjust for inflation? Because I think if not, these numbers are even more alarming.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by jonmrodriguez on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:25PM (#7227437)
Totally agree.

Just so you know, the purpose of the NIF was for military testing right from the beginning. The reason it initially got funded (shortly after the end of the cold war) was to help with stockpile stewardship (making sure our aging weapons still work via simulation, without having to do actual weapon tests).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Ignition_Facility#NIF_...

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stockpile_Stewardship_and_Manag...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by gwern on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:19PM (#7228925)
One of my favorite novels, Carter Scholz's _Radiance_, spends much of its length all on NIF and this controversy, actually: http://www.gwern.net/docs/2002-radiance
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by jonmrodriguez on Thursday February 13, 2014 @03:46AM (#7230193)
Wow, sounds like an exciting premise!
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by gwern on Thursday February 13, 2014 @04:30PM (#7234518)
Oh, it's not that exciting. Much of the book is on the corruption of science by funding pressures and sponsors, so it's more of a slow corrosive burn than action.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by vezzy-fnord on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:28PM (#7227461)
Not necessarily true.

A lot of great innovations have originated from military research. War necessitates innovation.

Not to say that we should just funnel everything into the military, but one should not underestimate its importance in the technological landscape.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by Kroem3r on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:19PM (#7227752)
This seems like a myth to me. Radar? Rocket engines? Turing? Stealth bomber technology? Nuclear powered aircraft carriers? ICBMs? Stuff that was happening regardless of a war and stuff that was nearly useless.

Perhaps military first adopters are a net positive; like, the first buyers of a technology who will pay top dollar for working prototypes. But what on the original innovation side can you actually attribute?

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by DougMerritt on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:48PM (#7227932)
Long wavelength radar pre-dated WWII, but it was barely useful and required shore-mounted towers.

Short wave radar, as used on planes ever since, was developed as part of the war effort by the MIT Radiation Lab.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Radiation_Laboratory

Rocket engines were known before WWII (a thousand years ago in China, and efforts like Goddard in the early 20th C), but you can't disregard the Nazi Germany invention of the V2 just because of that; it was a big deal, not just a fleshing out of prototypes.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rocket#World_War_II

"Development of stealth technology likely began in Germany during World War II"

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stealth_aircraft

Later stealth, and nuclear carriers, and ICBMs, were a result of the cold war. I don't see how it matters whether the war is hot or cold.

I'll grant you Turing (aside from crypto), not that anyone is claiming differently.

The Internet directly arose from the Arpanet, which was purely a DARPA (Department of Defense) project, and there are lots of other well known examples.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Arpanet

> stuff that was nearly useless.

Citation needed.

> But what on the original innovation side can you actually attribute?

Short wavelength radar is inarguable, regardless of whether cold wars count.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by lisper on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:30PM (#7227473)
The problem with sinking a lot of money into science is that it only pays dividends if solutions to the big problems actually exist. They may not. It may in fact not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small (relative to a star) scale. The only way to find out for sure is the hard (and expensive) way.

By way of contrast, when it comes to military technology you're not competing with nature, only with other humans, and so a "solution" (if you'll excuse the irony) is almost certain to be found by one side or the other.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by VladRussian2 on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:43PM (#7227550)
> It may in fact not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small (relative to a star) scale.

the H-bomb is better-than-breakeven and much smaller than star scale. What you say may be true for Tokamak like confinement schemes whereis H-bomb is inertial confinement, and it works. And it is pretty clear that inertial confinement in several orders of magnitude smaller scale than H-bomb would work too. Look at Sandia Z-machine - an order of magnitude up, and it would get breakeven. Not that anybody really needs it :)

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by arethuza on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:12PM (#7228088)
JET (Joint European Torus) achieved a Q of 0.7 - with break-even being defined as a Q of 1:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joint_European_Torus

ITER is aiming for a Q of 5 for 480 seconds:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITER

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by lisper on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:10PM (#7228073)
OK, let me be more precise: it may not be possible to do better-than-breakeven fusion on a small scale in a way that makes the resulting energy safely harnessable for useful work.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by wcoenen on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @05:18PM (#7227745)
> we could probably solve some really fundamental world problems (i.e. energy, climate change) in the near future

I have a feeling that if we had fusion plants providing limitless cheap power, we'd get back on an 8% yearly growth track for energy consumption, like with oil consumption before 1970.

Then within a century or so, we'd be producing an amount of power equivalent to 20% of what the earth receives from the sun. It would give a whole new meaning to "global warming".

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by yaur on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:17PM (#7228133)
An old article on exactly that which I found interesting http://physics.ucsd.edu/do-the-math/2011/07/galactic-scale-e...

To sum it up "Free energy" buys us about 300-400 years of growth before thermodynamics kicks our ass.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by YokoZar on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @07:21PM (#7228493)
It is a tiny bit unreasonable to project continuous exponential growth in human energy usage on such a ridiculously long timescale. It's like arguing that Moore's law will continue for another 200 years.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by dredmorbius on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @10:53PM (#7229270)
However that growth is precisely what the present human civilization and economic system are predicated on.

That growth will stop sometime and a considerable amount of present pain seems to be that global growth is slowing markedly (and has been since the 1970s).

Globally, economic activity and energy consumption are still tightly correlated: http://www.reddit.com/r/dredmorbius/comments/1vlksg/economic...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by YokoZar on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @11:50PM (#7229521)
Yes, and when you're a child your caloric intake and your yearly increase in height are very tightly correlated too. Lots of society is built around this growth, such as the expectation of having to buy bigger clothes every year. But even a child can understand that one day they will stop growing and eat approximately the same amount of food for the rest of their life.

It would be "strange" to argue that, as a teenager, you were doomed to a life of misery because in order to keep up with this so-far exponential growth rate you'd have to eat entire planets by the time you were 1000 years old. It is similarly bizarre to argue that human society is in some sort of trouble because we can only double our energy consumption a few dozen more times.

This isn't even bringing up economic concepts like diminishing returns to utility: a person who makes 100k per year does not spend twice as much energy as someone who makes 50k per year. There are plenty of other things to buy that make us happy, and that can only get even more true when we're living in some hypothetical future with hundreds of times the economic productivity of today.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by dredmorbius on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:59AM (#7229944)
Humans run through a well-understood lifetime cycle of growth, maturity, and decline. Contemporary orthodoxy neoclassical economics doesn't generally recognize this, though it's beginning to. See Tim Worstall at the Telegraph UK: "Infinite growth on a finite planet? Easy-peasy!" http://blogs.telegraph.co.uk/finance/timworstall/100017248/i...

On the other side, Robert Gordon's "End of Growth" paper: http://www.voxeu.org/article/us-economic-growth-over

Your assertion that a person earning 100k doesn't have twice the energy (or environmental) footprint of someone earning 50k really needs some sort of factual support.

And your hypothetical future with 100s of times today's economic productivity flies in the face of the law of diminishing returns which you've invoked yourself.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by bcoates on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @08:24PM (#7228736)
Free energy buys us a century or more of energy growth. Nobody has any idea what anyone would use that much per capita energy for -- how much A/C, food and transportation are you capable of consuming?
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by DennisP on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:33PM (#7228225)
Fortunately, if we had a lot more cheap energy we could probably get to space pretty easily too. So a lot of the growth wouldn't be happening on this planet.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by yaur on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:51PM (#7228338)
Covered by the linked article to an extent and Asimov IIRC. Exponential growth requires FTL travel within a period shorter than recorded history even with free energy + space travel.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by DennisP on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @07:29PM (#7228527)
Right, I wasn't suggesting it could continue indefinitely, just that the limit is well beyond this planet. Solar system at least, maybe nearby stars.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by arethuza on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:21PM (#7228155)
I don't think fusion power plants are going to be that much cheaper to run than current nuclear power plants. Fuel costs are a small part of the operating costs of a nuclear plant (16% to 28%) and the capex costs probably won't be that different (e.g. they will still be based on heating water to create steam to power turbines to turn generators).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Economics_of_nuclear_power_plan...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by sliverstorm on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:42PM (#7228281)
I totally agree with you, but now I'm wondering what the upside to fusion is over fission, besides being a great science landmark. No radioactive inputs or outputs?
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by ufmace on Thursday February 13, 2014 @01:13PM (#7232986)
Stuff like no possibility of meltdowns, no direct long-lived radioactive waste, plus cheap and abundant fuel.

Fusion reactions can only be self-sustaining at incredibly high temperatures and pressures. If the containment mechanism loses power, the reaction stops. Unlike fission reactions, at least as used in current reactors, which have the potential to keep on going unless we do something active to stop them. Yeah, the modern, well-designed ones have lots of designed-in safeguards against this, void coefficients and all, but it's still safer still to be running fusion.

Hydrogen and it's isotopes in, with other isotopes or helium out is better than assorted radioactive heavy metal isotopes with relatively long half-lives. The only possibility for dangerous waste from a fusion reactor is any transmutation that takes place in reactor components from the neutron flux. Seems likely to be better, but I don't think anybody has really investigated what this part will look like in a running fusion reactor with reaction rates high enough for commercial power production.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by arethuza on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @06:57PM (#7228379)
I guess availability of fuel is one big advantage, along with the cleanup of a fusion plant hopefully being a lot easier and cheaper than a fission reactor:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fusion_power#Waste_management

A lot safer too!

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by vinceguidry on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @09:32PM (#7228962)
Isn't the primary cost of fission complying with safety regs? In that case, a safer design would directly translate to lower costs.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by arethuza on Thursday February 13, 2014 @05:08AM (#7230530)
According to Wikipedia the cost of electricity from modern nuclear stations is roughly comparable with sources like coal - which surprised me:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cost_of_electricity_by_source

What I don't know is how much of the cost of nuclear power is the much higher level of safety precautions they need.

I haven't seen any projected costs for DEMO which might well be the first fusion power plant (DEMO is the proposed successor to ITER):

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DEMO

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by coliveira on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:14AM (#7232113)
> the cost of electricity from modern nuclear stations is roughly comparable with sources like coal

It has to be, otherwise nobody would be using nuclear power plants...

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by AnthonyMouse on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @11:50PM (#7229520)
> Then within a century or so, we'd be producing an amount of power equivalent to 20% of what the earth receives from the sun. It would give a whole new meaning to "global warming".

Assuming we don't use the new energy in significant part to colonize other planets, with the colonies representing a significant part of the growth in human energy consumption.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by graylights on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:01AM (#7232027)
An abundance of energy would result in new technologies, engineering and infrastructure to use it.

Water shortages could be addressed with large scale desalination. Shipping/transportation would become real cheap without significant fuel costs. Food issues could be addressed by commercial hydroponics.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by wcoenen on Thursday February 13, 2014 @11:43AM (#7232317)
Exactly. There is so much incentive to keep using more and more power that we'd eventually cook ourselves in waste heat. You can't beat thermodynamics.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by javert on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @11:17PM (#7229357)
We could also tackle those fundamental world problems if we had about 100 Bill Gateses. But we don't, because of how much the government loots.

I'm not an anarchist, so I do believe there should be a government that provides military defense. I'm not a progressive, so I don't believe the government should try to loot people to try to solve other people's pet problems.

Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by pfraze on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @04:53PM (#7227609)
Just want to toss in, I think military applications are much easier for the layman to conceptualize. You hear science research and your gut doesn't send any strong signals.
Re:Scientists Say Their Giant Laser Has Produced Nuclear Fusion by drjesusphd on Wednesday February 12, 2014 @10:14PM (#7229116)
Fusion is and always has been a PR excuse for NIF.

Their purpose never been anything but "Stockpile Stewardship". Anyone who has been paying attention has known this for decades.