I get confused when people try to reason with these guys, they can only do what they are allowed to do. They aren't going to make an executive decision and break the rules for you. You need to feel around what they can do, and don't expect miracles.
They won't cancel you over the phone, only via the internet. And their internet thing didn't work any of the three times I tried it until (miraculously) it worked while I was telling the lady on the phone that I wasn't about to give them my new credit card number because I had not authorized the previous charges and their own cancellation page had "failed" on multiple occasions. Yet, when on the phone yelling at a supervisor, I got a confirmation that I had cancelled immediately.
I do have one possible explanation--after cancelling, it claimed that I would receive a call. They never even attempted to call (per my phone logs), but I have to think that some customer retention person somewhere had a quota that was easier to fake if you simply didn't call the customer and claimed that they had changed their mind about cancelling. I bet someone could figure out the truth by examining how many people miraculously change their mind regularly before finally cancelling....
It's been several years and I'm still mad at them. If you ever do have to cancel that service, make sure you log the exact dates and times that you cancel and document it.
Towards the end, I asked if it was really worth losing all my potential future custom over $SMALLISH_SUM and apparently the answer was yes. Complete cretins, all!
There is no excuse for making me deal with some gigantic company's internal structure. You hide that from the outside world, you don't force people to navigate it.
A: Yes, I'd like to speak to your manager, please. Thank you.
You should attempt to escalate at least once by asking for a manager. If you're bothered enough to initially call in and spend the time anyway with the first level support person, the marginal cost in time to ask for a manager is probably worth it.
Comcast: You can have double your current internet speed plus HBO Go and some other junk for only $4 more per month.
Me: <after a while> ok, but I don't need a cable box because I don't have a TV. I'll just watch online. I can do that right?
C: Yes, but we need to ship you a cable box anyway.
Me: why?
C: because
Me: ok but I'm not at home much and packages left on my stoop get stolen. Could you ship it to my office?
C: <after a while> oh all right we'll ship it to your office.
(Ships to my home anyway and the box gets stolen)
C: Sir, please check to see if your doorman accepted the package before we charge you for the cable box.
Me: I don't have a doorman and I told you not to ship the box to my home. The cable box that I didn't want was stolen like I said it would be.
C: We can only ship it to your home. We will ship you another one.
Me: I don't want another one, I just don't want to pay for the one that was stolen.
C: Ok, we'll cancel your new package then.
Me: Can't I just pay for it and not have the cable box? I don't have a TV.
C: No. I will cancel your new package. Is there anything else I can help you with?
It was like talking to a robot. I dearly hate monopolies.