News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by sejje on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:11PM (#7207869)
I can't. Mind making a brief summary?
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by a3_nm on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:34PM (#7207991)
The main count on which Bluetouff was found guilty is that of "maintien frauduleux dans un système de traitement automatisé de données (STAD)", namely, remaining "in" a computing system (STAD) without being allowed. The key point is that Bluetouff made an important admission, apparently during his 30 hours of "garde à vue", meaning, being under arrest at the police station, where he seemingly neglected to apply his right to remain silent: he recognized that, when going up the folder hierarchy, he landed on a username-password login page. From this, according to the court, he should have inferred that the documents were private and that he had nothing to do there. Instead, he spent several hours siphoning the documents afterwards, which established his intent to remain in the system despite having found out that he wasn't supposed to.

One can then discuss whether this law is fair or not, whether things would have been different had Bluetouff not made this key admission, whether it is reasonable to consider that the login page was sufficient to indicate that the documents weren't intended to be public, and whether the 3000 EUR fine is balanced or not.

Meanwhile, Bluetouff has appealed the ruling to the Cour de cassation, France's last-resort court for civil and criminal cases, whose role is to break rulings where the law was not correctly applied (without discussing the findings, only the application of the law and the adequate forms). I do not think we know yet how Bluetouff will phrase his appeal, but Eolas estimates that there would be a possible way to attack the ruling based on the court's finding that Bluetouff's retrieving the documents constitutes "vol" (theft) though it does not fall within the scope of the formal definition of theft (because the ANSES was not deprived of the files).

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by jordanthoms on Sunday February 09, 2014 @11:06PM (#7209054)
This is a good time to remind people: Don't talk to the police. Ever, under any circumstances - it can only hurt you, never help you. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6wXkI4t7nuc
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by pyre on Monday February 10, 2014 @12:38AM (#7209341)
This is a very US-centric view. In some places, you have a right to remain silent, but that can be used against you in a court of law...
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by nodata on Monday February 10, 2014 @04:47AM (#7210036)
He means don't talk to the police until your lawyer is there.

Which countries will use that against you?

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by ItendToDisagree on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:06AM (#7210090)
UK or US, among other countries, if you are being held on 'homeland security' (read: Suspected terrorist) charges.

IE: You are required by law to answer questions/turn over passwords when suspected of such things. David Miranda being a recent and well known example.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by nodata on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:12AM (#7210108)
"Let's wait until my lawyer gets here" will count against me?

You got a cite for that?

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by ItendToDisagree on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:22AM (#7210140)
Heres the first hit on google, I'm sure many more instances, citings could be procured.

According to former White House Counsel Alberto Gonzales (later the former attorney general), “[t]he stream of intelligence would quickly dry up if the enemy combatants were allowed contact with outsiders during the course of an ongoing debriefing.” Warren Richey, “Beyond Padilla Terror Case, Huge Legal Issues,” Christian Science Monitor, August 15, 2007, http://www.csmonitor.com/2007/0815/p01s08-usju.html. Yoo also explains that introducing a lawyer immediately after capture of an enemy combatant would disrupt interrogation as any competent defense counsel would tell his/her client to remain silent. Yoo, War by Other Means, 151.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by refurb on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:03AM (#7210282)
That quote is in reference to enemy combatants, not those who fall within the regular court system. I get your point though.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by ItendToDisagree on Monday February 10, 2014 @06:22AM (#7210369)
As my post said 'homeland security' (read: Suspected terrorist) charges who are not part of the normal court system.

But this also happens to immigrants or those stopped at the border in general. [0] The right to counsel is being eroded at the edges (apparently not applied to non-citizens whenever possible).

Over the past year, the American Immigration Council, along with the American Immigration Lawyers Association (AILA), has documented instances where the DHS immigration agencies—Customs and Border Protection (CBP), Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE), and U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS)—have deprived noncitizens of access to counsel. For example, ICE also has taken the position that there is no right to consult with a lawyer during an interrogation. Likewise, many CBP offices outright deny access to all lawyers. [1]

[0] http://law.psu.edu/_file/Immigrants/LAC_Right_to_Counsel.pdf

[1] http://immigrationimpact.com/2012/01/23/its-time-to-improve-...

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by digitalengineer on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:07AM (#7210093)
In the Netherlands you have the right to talk to a lawyer before you talk to the police. But not during the time you talk to the police. Nice huh?
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by pyre on Monday February 10, 2014 @08:30AM (#7210873)
Similar in Canada.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by meric on Monday February 10, 2014 @05:05AM (#7210089)
What if someone random on the street stabbed you. You wake up in a hospital and the police is asking you questions about what the attacker looked like. Should you stay silent? If it was me, I'd want to get back at that person who stabbed me, and the police would help me do that.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by noonespecial on Monday February 10, 2014 @07:51AM (#7210688)
If you're talking to police, and you don't know who the criminal is that they are trying to find, its you.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by a3n on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:02AM (#7211390)
Nice twist on the mark in a poker game.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by yeukhon on Sunday February 09, 2014 @07:05PM (#7208152)
Instead, he spent several hours siphoning the documents afterwards

Do we know how he accessed the documents? Did he crawl the directory with a login or without a login (meaning the directory is not protected)?

And why would he share such document with his fellow writer? What for?

The fact that a judge can't comprehend technical explanation according to the article seems to be the main issue here. Was he given a fair hearing?

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by tripzilch on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:16AM (#7217670)
Yikes. And he didn't know that? Assuming if he did, he'd have kept his mouth shut about it.

We have pretty much the same law in the Netherlands. What I understand (IANAL), this goes as far as observing an open WiFi access point with the SSID named "UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS PROHIBITED", if you willingly connect to it (ignoring the message), you'll be in violation.

This is of course not security, and maybe it's kinda stupid, but the rule is also pretty clear and pragmatic. It's analogous to having a door with a "NO ACCESS" sign on it, even if it turns out to be unlocked, you're still not supposed to go there. Often such a sign will cite "Article such and such from the Book of Criminal Law Code" in smaller letters (Dutch people will know what type of signs I'm talking about), but afaik this is not necessary for the legal power of such a sign.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by dalek_cannes on Sunday February 09, 2014 @11:47PM (#7209199)
Excellent.

Although I'm not sure the correct word here is "hacking". Law and government should stop using the word to mean "any adept use of computer knowledge or skills that result in undesirable effects for some party". That could be used to accuse anyone with a computer and an opinion. There needs to be a proper legal definition (similar to how we distinguish between degrees of murder, manslaughter and involuntary homicide).

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by tripzilch on Tuesday February 11, 2014 @09:20AM (#7217688)
I always compare hacking in that sense to magic tricks: As soon as you know the trick, it's hard to still consider it "magic".

Compare "They just used the Windows Remote Access feature/You just changed the document_id part of the URL" to "You just dropped that coin in your pocket".

The line between "hacking" and "expected behaviour" can get very blurry, the more knowledgeable a person is. And in the end, like with magic tricks vs con men, it's the intent that makes it right or wrong (IMO).

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by a3n on Monday February 10, 2014 @10:03AM (#7211393)
That ship has sailed. We should pick another word.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by norswap on Sunday February 09, 2014 @06:43PM (#7208044)
Basically he was charged on three count: intruding in a private computer system, maintaining himself in said computer system, and theft of private documents.

The ruling said he was innocent of the first charge, since it was due to a security flaw, but guilty of the second, since he realized he was in a private system (he admitted to navigating the hierarchy and finding that the repository was "protected" by a login and password). He was also ruled guilty of the theft (the author of the blogpost, an attorney, says he should have been charged with counterfeiting instead, since that is the proper indictment for copyright violations).

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by fab13n on Monday February 10, 2014 @01:16AM (#7209444)
Tldr: he's not fined for entering on the website. He's fined because he kept mirroring the site after he realized it was opened by mistake (he unwisely admitted as much to the cops).

It's the digital equivalent of figuring out that a house isn't locked, and concluding it's OK to loot it.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by gislifb on Monday February 10, 2014 @03:36AM (#7209814)
It's the digital equivalent of figuring out that a house isn't locked, and concluding that it's OK to make a copy of the furniture. FTFY
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by Sharlin on Monday February 10, 2014 @04:13AM (#7209940)
Make a copy of the owner's diary and other sensitive documents, snoop through nightstand drawers... Equivalently, finding someone's personal computer unlocked and deciding it's all right to mirror the contents of its hard disk.
Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by sejje on Monday February 10, 2014 @11:36AM (#7211925)
I don't agree with any of these assessments.

I think it's the equivalent of going down a public road and passing through a gate that was left open, onto private property.

While driving, off in the woods beside the road you notice a "no trespassing" sign, but it's not obvious that you're trespassing currently, even if you start to wonder.

A place on the disk was accessed that was unintended.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by fab13n on Monday February 10, 2014 @12:31PM (#7212279)
> it's not obvious that you're trespassing currently, even if you start to wonder.

He's admitted that he kept snooping around after he fully realized that the files were online by mistake.

Re: French journalist "hacks" govt by inputting correct URL,... by fab13n on Monday February 10, 2014 @12:28PM (#7212262)
My point wasn't about the theft/piracy distinction. It was that your victim being incompetent at defending themselves is not a valid excuse for committing a crime against them.

Besides, counterfeiting one's furniture doesn't cause any embarrassment. I'd rather equate it to photocopying your secret business plan, or your collection of naked self-pictures.