The search for a general counsel, though, had been commissioned by the CFO, who was politically powerful within the company, and who wanted the GC to report to him. I told the headhunter that, especially because this was a public company, in my view the job would have to report either directly to the board, or to the CEO with a dotted line to the board; I explained why.
The headhunter said he thought that would be a problem but would check. He later let me know that what I'd said had killed the CFO's interest in me. I later saw in the paper that they'd hired someone else, who was reporting to the CFO. Best of luck to them.
Yes, I'd say that from a governance perspective the ideal situation is to have a GC or CLO reporting directly to the board. In startups the board doesn't necessarily do as much governing as they normally would, though, especially in the case of a founder-CEO; in such a case of a dysfunctional board, having the GC report to the actual nexus of decision-making (aka the CEO) might work better.
Fortunately I/T seems to be on it way out, though regrettably slowly.
I am referring to "I/T" as a corporate computing function within the company, a function which often hiders rather than accelerates the business.
I/T typically picks technologies which are easier for I/T. Hence there's a corporate standardization on one mail system, one OS; very strict upgrade cycles etc. This kind of made sense in an earlier era when computing wasn't really integrated into the business processes -- people would be "on email" and if the icons changed an expensive "training program" had to be rolled out because the majority of working people had a passive aggressive learned helplessness towards computers.
What happened is that people became more savvy and worked around I/T. First it was the PC: the appeal of the Apple II was that you could buy one, add a copy of Visicalc, plunk it down on your desk, and get work done without dealing with those assholes in I/T. I/T (this is before CIOs etc) fought back (just look at magazines like Datamation from the 1980s to see; I am not exaggerating) and took control of the PC infrastructure. Around 2000 departments would start to put in wifi access points and local file servers under secretaries' desks to just get work done. I/T again was seen as a barrier.
Nowadays I/T is freaking out about "BYOD" because people wouldn't put up with the crappy company-issued blackberries etc. But it is making business more efficient and humane.
You could see the nails entering the coffin for a long time, but these things take time. When I was at MIT in the 1980s I would get a laugh when I would run across a piece of literature from MIT's I/T department about the computing crucial capabilities they provided to MIT -- because they had nothing to do with the systems we depended on in the research labs which were mature and two generations beyond what I/T offered. And even now, heavily computer-intensive businesses often have disjoint departments and technologies for their customer-facing work and their internal systems (a few huge products like Oracle are rare exceptions).
However, that's not because that's what we wanted to do. That's because someone had the bright idea to bring a paper to the CEO, and he said "We can't just have everyone accessing every damned file!!!"
Believe me, it's just as rough being the enforcer as it is being the one being enforced!
However, I think we'll need people to fix computers, update the servers, and wake up at 2AM to put a fan in the server room ;)
I'd say the exact opposite. If the GC is spending most of his time making sure that the CFO isn't doing anything illegal, the GC needs to report to anyone other than the CFO.
Some companies have every C level executive reporting to the CEO.
Some CEO's are big picture people and focus on external issues. This means that the company would usually have most functions reporting to the COO.
Sometimes it just makes sense to have a group report to an executive. Consider Groupon, its largest expense is marketing so it might make sense to have the Chief Marketing officer report to the CFO. It can also make sense for financial companies to have the Counsel report to the CFO as they would be doing primarily financial related duties, like compliance.
General Counsel is a special case as its a bit of an oddball case for companies where its not a core function and will often report to the COO.
IT can often be like the general counsel where it's not viewed as a core function or PnL center and thus report to another C level executive like the CFO or COO.
this is THE classic example of corporate sociopathy. unfortunately its still the way a lot of companies do business.
The story in the article is a great example, I don't think the CFO thought that she was breaking the law. It was a practice that she had engaged in previously, it was vetted by a big-5 accounting firm, and benefited the employees. The CFO was widely respected in the industry -- this wasn't some flimflam person or sociopath.
When your attorney works for someone else, that other party becomes the client. If you, as a CEO (or an individual) are ultimately accountable for the outcome of your decisions, you want the attorney working for YOU, so that you get unfiltered information to drive decisions.
regarding that CFO from the linked article though, the federal prosecutor seemed to believe she was a criminal, and proved it enough that a jury agreed also and she eventually served jail time. we're not mind readers so we don't know how she felt about her actions, but honestly, it kinda looks to me like she really was a low level sociopath. just because she was surrounded by people who reinforced and validated her behavior doesn't mean she was acting morally.
This isn't OT at all since most HN readers won't be CEOs of publicly traded companies. Your situation is far more common.
A good guide for this is how the FDA manages Good Manufacturing Practice (similar to ISO 9000 except focused on, you know getting shit done instead of getting hung up on the process). One important part is the distribution of responsibility. They get extremely upset by situations like the one you describe specifically because of the possibility of undue influence on the results. Manufacturing, R&D, QA and QC have to be organized to ensure proper independence.
(Which also means if you hear about scummy behaviour from a drug company: that flows from the top).
-d
PS: little known fact: the FDA has armed enforcement personnel who WILL storm through the door in some cases where they believe fraud could be involved in endangering people. I know of cases of this on the pharma side at least -- the food side may be more lax.
One of the huge problems in an unregulated stock market is that you have people exaggerating their financial position either because they aren't doing due diligence or because they are lying. Investors (including workers paid in stock options) have no way to evaluate the claims, and so you get exaggerated claims, false advertising in efforts to raise money, etc. We give some deference to those only seeking investment from small pools of friends or family, or those seeking help from venture capitalists who are presumed to be able to spot irregularities themselves, but on the stock market this is considered dangerous.
The second problem has to do with the convenience of stock analysts but is a related problem. The analyst always has less information than the CFO of the company he is analysing. Differences in ways of accounting lead to distorting effects as analysts read into them more of a difference than is justified by the facts. The stock market thus breeds a need for uniformity of accounting standards that small, locally supported and financed businesses do not need.
The result are things we call "securities law" which always includes "following the best practices from the relevant accounting organizations" (i.e. IASB or FASB depending on where you are).
Do the right thing is sufficient, on the other hand, if the business is a small one serving local markets and invested in by local individuals. It breaks down quite a bit as one tries to scale up.
The larger the group of people, the more the structure of that group rather than the moral makeup of its members determines that group's behaviour.
What happens when the head of risk management and head of compliance report to business unit heads rather than functional lines? (See most big banks)
What happens when the local partner can overrule national standards committees? (See Arthur Andersen)
If the watcher reports to the watched, you're just going through the motions. Very informative.
This needs to be in bold 72-point font. Corporate behaviour aligns with corporate structure, and if the General Counsel is subordinate to the Chief Financial Officer, complying with the law will inevitably be secondary to making money.
If you want to avoid jail time, you should either have General Counsel reporting to the CEO or General Counsel / Chief Legal Officer appointed by and reporting to the board.