News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by drew on Monday February 03, 2014 @09:34AM (#7170770)
In principle, Persona is great. Not storing passwords is awesome, a non-FB/Google/Twitter identity option is important.

I would encourage you, though, to look carefully at your login completion metrics. I implemented Persona on my site (http://www.sixquestions.co) to have a pure email option and although users clearly prefer it, about 35% complete the Persona login flow successfully. That's 10 points lower than our next-worst performer (Twitter), and half the rate of our best performer (Facebook). For all the concerns people have with authorizing Facebook/Twitter access, that is (in my view) offset by the alien-ness of Persona's login flow. We've heard from lots of users that logging in with Persona is unusual and they thought they were doing something wrong because they'd never seen anything like that.

So, as much as I believe in Persona, I'm about to deploy a change that removes it entirely. It adds a lot of surface area to our testing and future development, but if it means we lose fewer users in their signup flow, it will be worth it.

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by rebelde on Monday February 03, 2014 @10:37AM (#7171122)
Here's an example: I just failed to login to Zonino myself.

I enter in the Gmail address that I use for registrations and other junk. I get the message: "Accounts don't match. You are currently signed into Google as [my normal Gmail address]. ... Force Google logout?" Forget that. I'm not interested in logging out of Gmail. Logging out of #1, into #2, out of #2 and back into #1 is more work that simple registration. I expect that I'm not the only person with this problem. I hope a solution can be found, because it would be really helpful.

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by callahad on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:19PM (#7171955)
Gah. We still need to switch from OpenID to OAuth for our GMail bridge; OpenID doesn't allow us to tell Google what address we're trying to authenticate. Sorry!
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by StavrosK on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:52PM (#7173399)
Need any help with that/is there a ticket?
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by timmclean on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:32AM (#7175697)
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by kn8 on Monday February 03, 2014 @11:24AM (#7171487)
Normally, when you're logged into multiple Google accounts - Google Bridge in Persona lets you pick which Google account you want to use. This error you're seeing seems like some sort of bug/UX issue (?) in Persona -> Google flow where if you're already signed into multiple Google accounts, but not the extra one you're trying to use - things don't work as smoothly..
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by girvo on Monday February 03, 2014 @10:58AM (#7171285)
Interesting. Persona likely needs work when it comes to multiple Gmail accounts when using the Account Bridging.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by donrhummy on Monday February 03, 2014 @01:54PM (#7172664)
They're working on it: https://github.com/mozilla/persona-yahoo-bridge/issues/178 You should post your findings there
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by jdlshore on Monday February 03, 2014 @02:06PM (#7172744)
That's for Yahoo, not Gmail.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by justinhj on Monday February 03, 2014 @11:09AM (#7171372)
Do you get this problem if you use a different browser for the other gmail account?
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by rebelde on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:12PM (#7171893)
No, and that is what I would usually do since I understand how these things work. (IE does come in handy at times.) The point that I am trying to make is that normal users who don't know these tricks can run into this barrier.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by icebraining on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:19PM (#7171957)
I don't think normal users have multiple Google accounts, though.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by jtheory on Monday February 03, 2014 @08:08PM (#7174798)
Eh, that depends.

All it takes is a personal Gmail account plus working for a company that uses Google Apps.

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by kijin on Monday February 03, 2014 @11:25AM (#7171497)
Agreed. Although Persona's technical basis and privacy protections are second to none, the UX is nothing to write home about. It still feels too much like OpenID, and we know what happened to OpenID. Facebook and Twitter can get away with cross-site redirects because they're well known and people trust them. Persona doesn't have that benefit, so it can't get away with the same cumbersome UX. It needs to do better, much better. The market is unfair. Deal with it.

If you're in the business of implementing an alternative login system, you should also seriously think about what kind of UX you're competing against. Your ultimate competitor isn't Facebook or Twitter. It's the good old email-and-password login system that everyone is used to. You enter your email address, select a password, and you're in, without ever leaving the signup page! It's even easier if you use a password manager like LastPass. That's what you're competing against, and if your UX has any more steps or redirects than that, you're probably doomed.

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by drew on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:57PM (#7172303)
The paradox here is that people are more familiar with the appearance of home-grown-style login systems and are more willing to follow through on those than the novel Persona flow, even though the security characteristics of Persona are stronger. It's a chicken and egg problem, and until someone really big takes the plunge and gets everyone comfortable with this style, anyone implementing it is going to be somewhat of a cost to signups.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by 500and4 on Monday February 03, 2014 @05:25PM (#7173957)
I think you've hit the nail on the proverbial head here.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by StavrosK on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:26PM (#7173229)
If the bridge supports the 3-4 major email providers, it effectively becomes "log in with your email address" (it already supports Gmail), and A LOT of the friction goes away.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by whitef0x on Monday February 03, 2014 @01:54PM (#7172665)
OpenID never really made it not just because of their bad UX design but also because they never got major players to push it to the public. Google or Facebook would much rather have you use their service as login credentials as it makes more monetary sense to do so than to hand it over to some non-profit foundation like Mozilla or OpenID. Data = money in this world and everyone wants more money.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by nl on Tuesday February 04, 2014 @12:31AM (#7175693)
Google, Yahoo and AOL all support(ed) OpenId login using their site as an IDP.

Google's FriendConnect was built on it.

That's a fair bit of "push".

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by zobzu on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:46PM (#7172203)
There's 2 issues with persona.

1) users don't already have a personna account setup. They're used to hit their "login with FB/Google" account instead. They don't know that persona is better privacy-wise. So for many, it's just friction.

2) persona login sometimes appears slightly slower

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by jmathai on Monday February 03, 2014 @02:22PM (#7172846)
There's an OpenID bridge [1] to make it easier for GMail users to sign in using Persona if they're currently logged into GMail/Yahoo! [2]. I haven't used it but the end goal of Persona is that 3rd party email providers can be their own Persona identity providers.

We definitely need something like Persona but I share your concerns WRT friction. Chicken meets egg.

[1] http://identity.mozilla.com/post/56526022621/what-is-an-iden...

[2] http://identity.mozilla.com/post/57712756801/persona-makes-s...

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by StavrosK on Monday February 03, 2014 @03:54PM (#7173410)
Your data (especially the fact that users clearly prefer it) tells me that they're clicking it out of curiosity, to see how they can log in with their email.

Unless by "clearly prefer it" you don't mean the initial button click, but the final login?

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by drew on Monday February 03, 2014 @04:56PM (#7173781)
You can see how we communicate it on our site if you're curious. Basically it's a modal dialog with four options:

* Facebook * Google * Twitter * Email

We don't use the persona messaging, and I think people's expectation when they click the 'email' button is that it's going to just be a normal email flow. We don't call it Persona or Browser ID or use any of their assets or messaging, because we didn't think anyone would click on it if we did.

But yes, we see a small preference for a button labeled 'email' versus facebook, and a medium preference for either over twitter.

Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by StavrosK on Monday February 03, 2014 @05:30PM (#7173984)
I did try it (and signed in) to your site. I'll admit, I knew I was going there for Persona, and "sign in via email" got me curious to click on it, even though I already knew what it was.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by StavrosK on Monday February 03, 2014 @09:50AM (#7170852)
Why not keep it as a (perhaps less prominent) alternative?
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by cheshire137 on Monday February 03, 2014 @10:02AM (#7170920)
Just tried it on your site. It went easily enough. I entered my Gmail address in the Persona form, then it had me pick which Google account to use (strange that it wouldn't just choose the one for the Gmail address I entered), then it said I was signed in.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by drew on Monday February 03, 2014 @12:52PM (#7172260)
The gmail case is special, actually. For a few domains (gmail, yahoo, not sure which others) it will fall back to a flow that's more like OAuth. But for unknown domains it sends you an email with a link, and then requires you to create a new account (with a new password) that is persona-specific.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by slaxman on Monday February 03, 2014 @11:02AM (#7171316)
I agree. Though facebook tends to track users, people are so used to see the facebook login button that they feel comfortable with it. Persona, though really good, feels different and makes the me a bit uncomfortable as an end user.
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by EGreg on Monday February 03, 2014 @04:01PM (#7173452)
How do you know users clearly prefer it?
Re:Why we love Mozilla Persona by drew on Monday February 03, 2014 @05:59PM (#7174158)
We track clicks on each of the four login methods, and compare it with successful sign in events with each of them. So we know completion rates for each type, plus which types are preferred by users. Nothing fancy, just google analytics events + checking the users table.